Audi S5 broken down...
Author
Discussion

Mr Roper

Original Poster:

14,233 posts

225 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
Mornin,


Car is on the back of a trailer somewhere and will be at Audi at some point today.

When pushing the fob to cut the engine and release the key, the engine cut out but the key wouldn't release. Also the car wouldn't restart.

Yellow EPC light on the dash along with the engine management light.

Tried to lock the car with a spare fob but nothing. Disconnected the battery, nothing.

Anyway, I'm sure they will sort it...I'm just impatient to know..

Dr...any suggestions??

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
I've twice seen a similar fault - one was a broken ignition switch and the other a broken selector switch (auto) making the car think it was stuck in gear.

They normally (B8 cars) just need the ignition switch lubricating but they start/stop fine otherwise and just won't release the key.

Mr Roper

Original Poster:

14,233 posts

225 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
As mine won't restart it's looking like a new ignition switch.

How much of a rimming can I expect Dr?

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
Not in front of a PC with parts on but don't recall it being scary expensive.

Mr Roper

Original Poster:

14,233 posts

225 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
Cheers Dr.


mikeh501

800 posts

212 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
had the exact same thing happen to mine a couple of weeks ago. 09 S5. Wasnt terminal like yours but was bloody annoying having to keep restarting the engine to make it release the key. You can hear that the solenoid doesnt activate inside the lock for some reason.

Had the ignition replaced and its peachy now. (approved used warranty)

Mr Roper

Original Poster:

14,233 posts

225 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
Audi have been working on for 2 hours and can't get the key out. No diagnostic faults...so they're stumped.

Not impressed.

Deerfoot

5,259 posts

215 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
Mr Roper said:
Audi have been working on for 2 hours and can't get the key out. No diagnostic faults...so they're stumped.

Not impressed.
Ker-ching. yikes

Mr Roper

Original Poster:

14,233 posts

225 months

Sunday 3rd November 2013
quotequote all
They eventually found the fault....it took 4 hours and to their credit this was not something thats ever happened before.
Someone who owned the car previously had 'somehow' bypassed the contactless sensor which senses when the clutch has been fully depressed/pressed...allowing the car to start without the clutch. A poor job involving brown parcel tape luck.
Anyway...the bodge job finally bodged and now Im looking at a pretty hefty bill to put right.

Parts including a new clutch slave master cylinder should come in at 300. With 3.5 hours labour. Also it needs new pedal as the bodge has effected that too..150 plus 3 hours labour.

None of he above came up on the diagnostics report.





soad

34,769 posts

207 months

Sunday 3rd November 2013
quotequote all
Sounds expensive. frown

Mr Roper

Original Poster:

14,233 posts

225 months

Sunday 3rd November 2013
quotequote all
What I can't understand is why?? Its not something that is likely to fail and if it did why not put right?
The technician says the car should not run at all...and can understand how they've bypassed it.

God knows....my brain was hurting just listening to him.



Anyway....nothing can be done now. I'll suck it it up.


Mr Roper

Original Poster:

14,233 posts

225 months

Wednesday 6th November 2013
quotequote all
Update..


The original problem has been fixed but now the car won't start...

It's been suggested that it could be a fault with the starter motor...to investigate, means taking out the engine and gearbox.


I'm struggling to see the connection between the two.


Kell

1,708 posts

239 months

Wednesday 6th November 2013
quotequote all
Where on earth did you buy the car?

And how long ago?

Mr Roper

Original Poster:

14,233 posts

225 months

Wednesday 6th November 2013
quotequote all
Bought the car from a performance car specialist 10 months ago.

The car is in excellent condition apart from someone tinkering with the clutch release sensor...It baffles me as to why but they have.


Terminator X

21,048 posts

235 months

Wednesday 6th November 2013
quotequote all
Why on earth bypass the "clutch to start" facility, not exactly a hardship is it?!

TX.

Mr Roper

Original Poster:

14,233 posts

225 months

Wednesday 6th November 2013
quotequote all
This is my thoughts.

Dodgy knee?? fk knows.

Mr Roper

Original Poster:

14,233 posts

225 months

Wednesday 6th November 2013
quotequote all
Can anyone confirm if the engine and gear box needs to be dropped to replace a starter motor?

Thanks

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
vorsprung durch technik hehe

Well someone had to, didn't they?!

According to this, it probably needs a new engine.


Edited by fatboy b on Thursday 7th November 13:18

Danger

91 posts

271 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
Assuming you paid a reasonable price for the car you are still within the time limit for pursuing the garage that sold it to you under the 1979 sale of goods act for the car not being of reasonable quality at the small claims court.

I did it when 'Weybridge Vehicle Consultants' sold me a self destructing S3. I eventually got the full cost of repairs plus expenses back.

DP

Mr Roper

Original Poster:

14,233 posts

225 months

Tuesday 12th November 2013
quotequote all
Update:

So, tomorrow the car is being collected from Audi and taken to and indy to finish the repairs.

The original diagnostic was incorrect, although it was someones bodge it wasn't the cause for the car to fail. The actual fault was the stater motor. This was identified AFTER fixing the clutch sensor.

Some conversations later and I have agreed to pay a contribution towards the repair. A small contribution but a contribution nevertheless.

Now, it's off to have the starter motor replaced by an independent, for no other reason other than price. £900 to their £2600. (negotiated to £2093)

Hope to have the car back in the next week or so.

Also hoping thats the last of it.

Bloody cars. wink