Tree damage during storm, who is liable?
Tree damage during storm, who is liable?
Author
Discussion

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

209 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
A current situation I am involved in, need some help from a legal person rather than just opinions if at all possible.

There are 3 properties: A, B and C.

A tree on property A was taken out by the storm over the weekend. It fell crushing fences in properties A, B and C. There was no damage to any houses themselves, just fences and plants.

Property A's insurer will not pay anything for removal and fence repairs as the tree did not damage the house and fences are excluded from storm damage
Property B's insurer will not pay for anything as the tree did not originate on their property
It looks like property C's insurer is going the same way as B's.

My question: who is legally responsible for paying for the damage? A quick google suggests that according to US law (so not much use here I know) provided the tree was in good health and came down due to a storm (i.e. didn't just fall over as it was not looked after), each property owner is liable for their own repairs as it is an act of God as it were.

What is the legal situation here? I'm hoping that myself and my neighbours can come to an amicable agreement, but I just want to know where we all stand should we not be able to agree something by ourselves.

podwin

652 posts

233 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
God

toddygti

96 posts

169 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
Mario149 said:
A current situation I am involved in, need some help from a legal person rather than just opinions if at all possible.

There are 3 properties: A, B and C.

A tree on property A was taken out by the storm over the weekend. It fell crushing fences in properties A, B and C. There was no damage to any houses themselves, just fences and plants.

Property A's insurer will not pay anything for removal and fence repairs as the tree did not damage the house and fences are excluded from storm damage
Property B's insurer will not pay for anything as the tree did not originate on their property
It looks like property C's insurer is going the same way as B's.

My question: who is legally responsible for paying for the damage? A quick google suggests that according to US law (so not much use here I know) provided the tree was in good health and came down due to a storm (i.e. didn't just fall over as it was not looked after), each property owner is liable for their own repairs as it is an act of God as it were.

What is the legal situation here? I'm hoping that myself and my neighbours can come to an amicable agreement, but I just want to know where we all stand should we not be able to agree something by ourselves.
I don't think there is any specific legislation for this, i'm sure a lawyer will be along to clarify.

From an Insurers perspective, Fences etc are usually excluded from storm damage because it's pretty much guarateed to get damaged in the event.

Unless anyone can prove that Property A was knowingly negligent in maintaining the tree etc or planted the tree to the objection of Property B/C then each Property owner is liable for their own repairs in my opinion. Common sense no?

AJI

5,180 posts

248 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
podwin said:
God
Which one?

Retroman

975 posts

164 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
I blame Aeolus.

As far as i understand it, unless you can prove the tree was a liability (i.e rotting / dangerous) and the owner was aware of the potential danger, then each home owner is responsible for their own repairs.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
AJI said:
Which one?
The big three all agree on who he is, it's just the route to him they argue on. Since the CofE is the official route in the UK, then start with the Archbish of Cantab.

Don't forget to post scans of the legal correspondence here. We need a good laugh.

But back to the point - if the tree was in demonstrably good health beforehand, then the fence owners. And there the real fun begins...

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
As above God did it, the thing is in the real world each houshold replaces their damaged panels and the tree owner gets the tree shifted, either paying for it or grabbing saws and cutting up and shifting it out of the neighbours gardens. If the neighbours are reasonably fit and healthy they could join in in cutting the tree up. After a previous storm a group of locals grouped together to shift fallen trees after all it's wood for people's fires and clears the road or gardens to allow people to fix things again.

rallycross

13,764 posts

268 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
AJI said:
Which one?
Depending on what sort of neighbourhood there could be a few versions.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
The Law on Trees:
http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&...

Based on this I don't think you can lay the blame and cost at someone else's door.

IanA2

2,897 posts

193 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
Do insurers still refer to "acts of God?" Seems to me it were 'im.

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

209 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
herewego said:
The Law on Trees:
http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&...

Based on this I don't think you can lay the blame and cost at someone else's door.
Not quite sure which side you're referring to there but that doc seems to indicate that the owner of the tree (i.e. whose property it is on) is only liable if they have been negligent. Do others read it like that? Doc says:

Q
I’m worried my neighbour’s
tree could fall on my house in
a storm. What can I do?
A
A tree is the responsibility of the
owner of the land they grow on,
regardless of who planted them. If a tree
causes damage, the owner may be liable.
However, your chance of making a claim
would usually depend on demonstrating
that the owner had been negligent;
if the tree was obviously unsafe through
disease or damage, for example.
You should write (keep a copy) to your
neighbour expressing your concern and
ask them to have the tree’s health checked
by an arboriculturist. As a last resort, it
may be possible to get a court injunction
requiring an owner to deal with a
dangerous tree, or the local authority
may take action, especially if there is a
danger to the public. Where property
is rented, the landlord may require the
tenants to maintain any trees, this would
be stated in the lease. If in doubt, contact
both landlord and tenant.

mikesalt

108 posts

164 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
As for removal of the tree, advertise it as free to collector. Plenty of chainsaw-equipped folk with wood-burners and a big truck that will happily take that away for you. You'll be left to clear up the sawdust though.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
Mario149 said:
herewego said:
The Law on Trees:
http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&...

Based on this I don't think you can lay the blame and cost at someone else's door.
Not quite sure which side you're referring to there but that doc seems to indicate that the owner of the tree (i.e. whose property it is on) is only liable if they have been negligent. Do others read it like that? Doc says:

Q
I’m worried my neighbour’s
tree could fall on my house in
a storm. What can I do?
A
A tree is the responsibility of the
owner of the land they grow on,
regardless of who planted them. If a tree
causes damage, the owner may be liable.
However, your chance of making a claim
would usually depend on demonstrating
that the owner had been negligent;
if the tree was obviously unsafe through
disease or damage, for example.
You should write (keep a copy) to your
neighbour expressing your concern and
ask them to have the tree’s health checked
by an arboriculturist. As a last resort, it
may be possible to get a court injunction
requiring an owner to deal with a
dangerous tree, or the local authority
may take action, especially if there is a
danger to the public. Where property
is rented, the landlord may require the
tenants to maintain any trees, this would
be stated in the lease. If in doubt, contact
both landlord and tenant.
Yes that's what it says, so you each have to sort yourselves out. The wood belongs to A if he wants it, but you can't charge him for the fences or the clearup.

CanAm

14,210 posts

303 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
Mario149 said:
Property A's insurer will not pay anything for removal and fence repairs as the tree did not damage the house and fences are excluded from storm damage
Depending on the wording of Property A's policy, it may exclude damage to fences caused by storm, but it may not exclude such damage caused by falling trees, which is often shown as a separate specified peril. Check the wording carefully.

TPS

1,860 posts

244 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
Cut the tree up and use it for fire wood or a bonfire.

Replace fence and move on with life.

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

209 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
TPS said:
Cut the tree up and use it for fire wood or a bonfire.

Replace fence and move on with life.
In principle it's a very good idea smile Only problem is it's quite a big tree, we live London so would require wood burning stoves, which I don't think any of us have! I'm gonna get in contact with my sis as they live out in the sticks and would probably be able to add it to their stock of firewood.

pork911

7,365 posts

214 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
liable? whoever put the copper nails in

Mill Wheel

6,149 posts

227 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
a BIG TREE you say... big enough to turn into a lot of fence posts/rails/panels?

(A) could sell any spare timber after he pays for a proper contractor to carry out the clear up - I wouldn't allow just any Tom, Dick or Harry onto my property with a chain saw!

Putting the fence right is your responsibility.

7db

6,060 posts

261 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
Will the insurers cover the cost of the three houses if you set fire to the tree where it lies...?!

orangesrule

1,976 posts

179 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
Sometimes you just have to MTFU and foot the bill for a poxy bit of fence...