Differentiation? Or weakening a brand?
Differentiation? Or weakening a brand?
Author
Discussion

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Sunday 3rd November 2013
quotequote all
Can I call upon the combined wisdom of the PH Non-Exec Board?


Views on brands and sub-brands.


I'll use an analogy: let's say we own Superdry. We are synonymous with t-shirts and hoodies. Everyone (customers and non-customers) knows what we do.

But then we decide to expand a little. And want to launch a range of... country attire.

Should we:

1. Still brand all garments Superdry
2. Create a linked sub-brand, e.g. SuperTweed
3. Create a completely separate sub-brand, e.g. TowniesGoCountry

TRB

2,888 posts

168 months

Sunday 3rd November 2013
quotequote all
or something along the lines of:

4: Country Brand by Superdry

A new brand but with the connection to the original. If new identity becomes strong enough after a period you could ditch "by Superdry"

Mobile Chicane

22,031 posts

243 months

Sunday 3rd November 2013
quotequote all
That sounds to me like brand stretch too far, which will weaken the parent. Depending what the existing brand is, create a new brand and sell it alongside.

An example of this would be the 'Logan' brand of sailing type clothing available down under, and its sister country clothing brand, 'Rodd and Gunn'.

Stores are located next to one another, or at least they were. 'Logan' has since been canned, but 'Rodd and Gunn' is very much still going.

Newc

2,197 posts

213 months

Sunday 3rd November 2013
quotequote all
If that came in front of me on a board as a NED, and you were proposing spending material amounts of time or money on it, I would want to see:

- target customers and market size for the new line
- overlap to existing customers
- go-to-market plan for the new line
- some colour on how that GTM relates to existing marketing activity

and then have the discussion around those facts. There's no absolute right answer for these kind of things, but my initial response would be as above, that the new line seems unlikely to mesh with existing customers and so you're targeting a separate customer set.

You then have to decide how much value there is to the new customer set (existing customers don't care because they're not going to see it) in knowing that the new line is backed by a solid firm with a track record, or if that is irrelevant.

ajcj

798 posts

236 months

Sunday 3rd November 2013
quotequote all
Newc said:
If that came in front of me on a board as a NED, and you were proposing spending material amounts of time or money on it, I would want to see:

- target customers and market size for the new line
- overlap to existing customers
- go-to-market plan for the new line
- some colour on how that GTM relates to existing marketing activity

and then have the discussion around those facts. There's no absolute right answer for these kind of things, but my initial response would be as above, that the new line seems unlikely to mesh with existing customers and so you're targeting a separate customer set.

You then have to decide how much value there is to the new customer set (existing customers don't care because they're not going to see it) in knowing that the new line is backed by a solid firm with a track record, or if that is irrelevant.
I agree with this. I would be interested primarily in the interaction between target market and the channel of distribution - are you using the same routes to market or completely different? The answer to that gives you a clue as to how helpful the parent brand will be in attracting the attention of potential buyers.

Simpo Two

93,113 posts

296 months

Sunday 3rd November 2013
quotequote all
For me, T-shirts and hoodies imply low class, 'country attire' implies high class.

So I would create a new brand, even though they are both clothing.

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Sunday 3rd November 2013
quotequote all
Sorry guys - I have inadvertently led you down a path I didn't intend to create.

Can I pull the request back on track by suggesting that the new range would appeal to the existing market, but that it is quite different cobber from the core for which the brand is known?

miniman

30,238 posts

293 months

Sunday 3rd November 2013
quotequote all
I suppose there are two conflicting issues at play here.

1. The benefit to the new product line that the "halo" of the existing brand could create

2. The damage to the existing brand that the new product line could create

Superdry is a triumph of brand building above anything else, so perhaps it's not the best example. What if Joules were to start offering Superdry-type items alongside their quilted jackets and floral wellies? Personally I think it would be a bit weird.

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Sunday 3rd November 2013
quotequote all
miniman said:
I suppose there are two conflicting issues at play here.

1. The benefit to the new product line that the "halo" of the existing brand could create

2. The damage to the existing brand that the new product line could create
Those are both very real issues.

Assuming that your #2 does't apply for a moment, would the introduction of a linked sub-brand (the #2 in my OP) water down or confuse my customers?

Or might they like the 'I wear that bit of the brand when I do that activity, and I wear that bit when I do something else'?

miniman

30,238 posts

293 months

Sunday 3rd November 2013
quotequote all
I'm struggling to think of other brands that do it to be honest. I kind of wonder whether that's your answer.

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Sunday 3rd November 2013
quotequote all
miniman said:
I'm struggling to think of other brands that do it to be honest. I kind of wonder whether that's your answer.
Per Una in M&S?

miniman

30,238 posts

293 months

Sunday 3rd November 2013
quotequote all
True, but that's a bit of a mish-mash between your options 2 and 3 - it's inherently linked to M&S because it isn't available anywhere else, but has an unrelated name (a bit like St. Michael back in the day).

Perhaps a better analogy is Polo Ralph Lauren.