Contesting a speeding fine due to missing repeater sign
Contesting a speeding fine due to missing repeater sign
Author
Discussion

lifechooser

Original Poster:

22 posts

273 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
Dagmannit, I've been caught speeding for the first time in 10 years doing 36mph in a 30 zone. I'm a bit frustrated as said 30 zone is a main a road though the kind of village which has 3 houses which you can just about glimpse through their wrought iron gates. No streetlights, no visibility issues, no houses near the road, no playing children... just people with influence who don't want the noise pollution despite choosing to live on an a-road.

Rant over.

Driving through said village, I spotted that one of the repeater signs is missing. There is a pole with nothing on it. It happens to be about 1/4 mile before where I was caught by the camera van. I've been playing around with a HD dashcam, and I've found video in my recycle bin from September which shows that the sign is missing.

Bearing in mind I'm not flush with cash, I'm insured by Admiral who ramp up your premium even if you take the speed awareness course, and morally I don't feel guilty as IMO I wasn't doing anything dangerous... what should I do?

- Am I likely to be able to contest this successfully?
- Do I have to go to court?
- Can I represent myself?
- What extra punishment might I get if I lose? Extra points, a larger fine or just costs?

Is there a guide somewhere to contesting speeding fines?

rewc

2,187 posts

264 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
If the repeater sign had been there what speed would it have been indicating? Did you think you were in a higher speed limit and if so why?
Have you got the street view link?
If you want to contest it then follow the instructions on the NIP you were sent. You will have your day in court if the CPS take it that far and you can argue your case to the Magistrates.

lifechooser

Original Poster:

22 posts

273 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
It would have been indicating 30mph.

I was aware that it was a 30mph. I drive the route regularly and all other signs are correct. My defence would be purely technical. Is it enough to use a technical defence like this, or is there a requirement to be genuinely confused about the speed limit?

I have just examined the streetview, and on there the signage is different. There are clearly not enough repeater signs and since google drove through more have been added, but the one I'm talking about is missing. There's a new pole.

I could post video to youtube if it might help?

SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
lifechooser said:
I've been caught speeding for the first time in 10 years doing 36mph in a 30 zone.
lifechooser said:
I was aware that it was a 30mph.
You've just admitted your guilt on an open internet forum.

As Sergeant Wilson would say: "Do you think that was wise, sir?"

agtlaw

7,443 posts

237 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
lifechooser said:
- Am I likely to be able to contest this successfully?
- Do I have to go to court?
- Can I represent myself?
- What extra punishment might I get if I lose? Extra points, a larger fine or just costs?

Is there a guide somewhere to contesting speeding fines?
Possibly. It depends. Missing repeater not the best defence.
Not if you do a speed awareness course or pay £100 fixed penalty (with 3pp).
Yes but not a good idea.
Fine will be around 50% net weekly income (max £1000). 3pp. Pros costs of £620 if trial. Victim surcharge at least £20.
I'm in the early stages of writing a book / eBook.

tex200

447 posts

202 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
lifechooser said:
It would have been indicating 30mph.

I was aware that it was a 30mph. I drive the route regularly and all other signs are correct. My defence would be purely technical. Is it enough to use a technical defence like this, or is there a requirement to be genuinely confused about the speed limit?

I have just examined the streetview, and on there the signage is different. There are clearly not enough repeater signs and since google drove through more have been added, but the one I'm talking about is missing. There's a new pole.

I could post video to youtube if it might help?
So you admit that you were knowingly speeding and want to contest it?

You would now have to lie in order to try and get out of it - I think you are going to have to take it.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
Call me confused, but since when have 30mph repeater signs been required?

rewc

2,187 posts

264 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
lifechooser said:
It would have been indicating 30mph.

I was aware that it was a 30mph. I drive the route regularly and all other signs are correct.
I think that if you say that to the Magistrate then the missing repeater would be neither here or there. I assume that as you entered the 30mph limit then there was a 30 sign and you had not yet got to a NSL or higher limit sign?

agtlaw

7,443 posts

237 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
tex200 said:
You would now have to lie in order to try and get out of it - I think you are going to have to take it.
Completely wrong. Pros to prove - entitled to test pros case - no obligation to give evidence at trial.

edeath

336 posts

222 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Call me confused, but since when have 30mph repeater signs been required?
When there are no street lights as per the OP.

tex200

447 posts

202 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
agtlaw said:
tex200 said:
You would now have to lie in order to try and get out of it - I think you are going to have to take it.
Completely wrong. Pros to prove - entitled to test pros case - no obligation to give evidence at trial.
Ok, I'll rephrase it then. The OP will have to lie to himself.

agtlaw

7,443 posts

237 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Call me confused, but since when have 30mph repeater signs been required?
Not usually required. Is it a restricted road?

rewc

2,187 posts

264 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Call me confused, but since when have 30mph repeater signs been required?
Where there is no street lighting, the default limit is 60 mph for single-carriageway and 70 mph for dual carriageway roads. This is referred to as the "National Speed Limit" (NSL), and entry to these zones is marked by the familiar "derestriction" sign with a diagonal black stripe on a white background. Repeater signs are not normally used but are not specifically prohibited.

Any other limit requires roadside repeater signs at regular intervals prescribed by law. The mere fact that a road runs through an urban or rural area makes no difference to the speed limit - it is the presence or absence of street lighting.

lifechooser

Original Poster:

22 posts

273 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
"Did you know the limit was 30mph" is a question that is likely to be asked in court, to which I would have to answer 'yes'. I drive through said village twice a day.

It sounds as though a simple technical defence isn't enough, and the financial risk of losing is high. That is different to my original assumption of finding a loophole and exploiting it, or losing and paying £35 costs extra.

Is there a way to contest it as a written response to the NIP, but if they still push for prosecution I can then say "it's a fair cop guv" and take the standard penalty?

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
lifechooser said:
"Did you know the limit was 30mph" is a question that is likely to be asked in court, to which I would have to answer 'yes'. I drive through said village twice a day.

It sounds as though a simple technical defence isn't enough, and the financial risk of losing is high. That is different to my original assumption of finding a loophole and exploiting it, or losing and paying £35 costs extra.

Is there a way to contest it as a written response to the NIP, but if they still push for prosecution I can then say "it's a fair cop guv" and take the standard penalty?
No. If you want to contest it you will have to go to court and plead not guilty, which will ramp up your fine and their costs.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
rewc said:
mybrainhurts said:
Call me confused, but since when have 30mph repeater signs been required?
Where there is no street lighting, the default limit is 60 mph for single-carriageway and 70 mph for dual carriageway roads. This is referred to as the "National Speed Limit" (NSL), and entry to these zones is marked by the familiar "derestriction" sign with a diagonal black stripe on a white background. Repeater signs are not normally used but are not specifically prohibited.

Any other limit requires roadside repeater signs at regular intervals prescribed by law. The mere fact that a road runs through an urban or rural area makes no difference to the speed limit - it is the presence or absence of street lighting.
Yes, thanks, I was aware. Missed the absence of street lights in the opening post.



lifechooser

Original Poster:

22 posts

273 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
So do people ever win due to incorrect signage? I always thought that it only took a slight problem with the case for it to be dropped, sounds as though I was wrong.

Sounds like my dilemma now is to choose between SAC or fixed penalty. Is there advantage to the SAC financially now that insurance load premiums?

Super Slo Mo

5,374 posts

229 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
If the signs were missing, damaged or otherwise incorrect at the start of the restricted zone, you might have a case.

Doesn't sound like they are though in this case, so you'd be admitting that you didn't see the 30 mph signs at the start of the restriction, which I don't think will help your case.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
lifechooser said:
"Did you know the limit was 30mph" is a question that is likely to be asked in court, to which I would have to answer 'yes'. I drive through said village twice a day.
Is this correct? I was always under the impression they couldn't enforce a transgression if they broke the rules in any way. Isn't this how that flash solicitor gets so many people off?



Edited by mybrainhurts on Tuesday 5th November 14:28

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
Time to change insurers.
Admiral are the only ones who are cocks about the course.