Discussion
Now I have no real research to back up what I am about to say, but it feels like, since they started squeezing you on how much luggage can weigh, that if you are not one of the first people on the aircraft, you can kiss good bye any chance of getting some overhead locker space.
On my recent flight out to San Francisco, I waited pretty close to the end before boarding in my group because I thought, "I am going to be on the damn thing for 10 hours, why do I want to spend a further 45 minutes simply sitting in an uncomfortable seat on a stuffy aircraft that is nearly as old as me?" This was a big mistake. When I got there the overhead bins were rammed and I had to go play hunt the space. Thankfully I had only a small, pliable, rucksack.
The problem is, people seem to be bringing what look like rather hefty suitcases (many of which are also rigid framed) as carry on and then also packing a large hand bag to the brim as well. One person is easily capable of taking bin space for 3 people. This is exasperated by old aircraft (thanks United for keeping decrepit 747s going) who's bins aren't designed for such use (because you could pack more in your suitcases). People who blatantly flout the rules and bring two such cases on board make it worse as do the airline staff who don't bother to enforce the rule.
I got on my return flight much earlier and yet still it was touch and go with the luggage space. I had to steal some space in the bins over the centre row, as despite the aircraft being a 767-300 with a 2-3-2 layout (with me and my OH sitting on the outer 2 seats) the bin above our seats was full! yet the seats beneath were empty! premium economy too! which on united is just about the same as regular modern day economy, but none the less, it is a small section of the total cabin layout. How on earth are people filling the bins so fast?!
Why do people need to bring so much stuff on holiday? 23kg isn't totally unreasonable, I packed pretty conservatively and still didn't wear half the crap I packed! So why do people bring so much it spills out into carry on luggage?
On my recent flight out to San Francisco, I waited pretty close to the end before boarding in my group because I thought, "I am going to be on the damn thing for 10 hours, why do I want to spend a further 45 minutes simply sitting in an uncomfortable seat on a stuffy aircraft that is nearly as old as me?" This was a big mistake. When I got there the overhead bins were rammed and I had to go play hunt the space. Thankfully I had only a small, pliable, rucksack.
The problem is, people seem to be bringing what look like rather hefty suitcases (many of which are also rigid framed) as carry on and then also packing a large hand bag to the brim as well. One person is easily capable of taking bin space for 3 people. This is exasperated by old aircraft (thanks United for keeping decrepit 747s going) who's bins aren't designed for such use (because you could pack more in your suitcases). People who blatantly flout the rules and bring two such cases on board make it worse as do the airline staff who don't bother to enforce the rule.
I got on my return flight much earlier and yet still it was touch and go with the luggage space. I had to steal some space in the bins over the centre row, as despite the aircraft being a 767-300 with a 2-3-2 layout (with me and my OH sitting on the outer 2 seats) the bin above our seats was full! yet the seats beneath were empty! premium economy too! which on united is just about the same as regular modern day economy, but none the less, it is a small section of the total cabin layout. How on earth are people filling the bins so fast?!
Why do people need to bring so much stuff on holiday? 23kg isn't totally unreasonable, I packed pretty conservatively and still didn't wear half the crap I packed! So why do people bring so much it spills out into carry on luggage?
Crossflow Kid said:
Passengers completely ignore the safety briefing on which their very lives depend.
What makes you think they'll listen when asked to pack light?
What makes you think they'll listen when asked to pack light?

They can't physically be made to listen to the safety briefing. However the size and amount of carry-on luggage could be policed quite easily (afaics).
They already have cages which measure the dimensions of your "carry-on". They just don't seem to be compulsory - i.e. not very airline makes you check that all your carry-on fits within the cage.
Countdown said:
Crossflow Kid said:
Passengers completely ignore the safety briefing on which their very lives depend.
What makes you think they'll listen when asked to pack light?
What makes you think they'll listen when asked to pack light?

They can't physically be made to listen to the safety briefing.
Crossflow Kid said:
Countdown said:
Crossflow Kid said:
Passengers completely ignore the safety briefing on which their very lives depend.
What makes you think they'll listen when asked to pack light?
What makes you think they'll listen when asked to pack light?

They can't physically be made to listen to the safety briefing.
I do pay attention to the briefing, but to be honest I never really expect it to save my life.
I feel your pain Otis. Worse still when it is your partner who's the one insistent on bringing a full sized bloody suitcase as carry on luggage.
IMHO they should force people to leave anything above acceptable hand luggage behind. One or two moany customers in the Daily Mail complaining how no one told them and their honey moon was ruined should spread the word nicely.
IMHO they should force people to leave anything above acceptable hand luggage behind. One or two moany customers in the Daily Mail complaining how no one told them and their honey moon was ruined should spread the word nicely.
Miguel Alvarez said:
I feel your pain Otis. Worse still when it is your partner who's the one insistent on bringing a full sized bloody suitcase as carry on luggage.
IMHO they should force people to leave anything above acceptable hand luggage behind. One or two moany customers in the Daily Mail complaining how no one told them and their honey moon was ruined should spread the word nicely.
They do offer to check any bags that won't fit or don't have space.... I didn't catch whether they then charge for this. One assumes they don't. Perhaps its a ruse to a free additional checked bag?!IMHO they should force people to leave anything above acceptable hand luggage behind. One or two moany customers in the Daily Mail complaining how no one told them and their honey moon was ruined should spread the word nicely.
'tis one of the few moments of schadenfreude enjoyed by regular travelers.
You get to the gate in good time then hang around close-by waiting to get first on - all the time being eyed-up at with disdain by the cool 'we're in no hurry' brigade. Better too when they start to mutter 'the plane won't go without you' or 'you won't lose your seat you know' in a superior tone. A joy then to arrive at an empty bin, directly above your seat and place your [regulation sized
] hand luggage in, and then sit then watch the fun as later boarders chase up and down the cabin ever more frantically hunting for space and the inevitable 'discussions' with the cabin crew.
Of course the truth is there simply isn't enough locker space if everyone takes on even their regulation allowances. Sure some folks take the pi$$ with over-sized bags or just take too many, but in reality most folks bags are within the size limits. But its a bit like over-booking and hoping folks don't turn up; the hope is not everyone takes their full carry-on allowance. The only real solution would be to reduce everyone's allowance so that a 'full load' is guaranteed to fit...but this would reduce the size of carry-ons, and most of the time would leave empty space since not everyone takes a carry-on bag. I note EasyJet now have a policy with 2 bag sizes and that makes some sense - a slightly smaller bag guaranteed to get on, and a larger size the may have to go in the hold if there's no space. Not sure how that would work with the full-fare airlines and/or transatlantics etc.
As it is you just have to 'play the game', and the 'game' is get on early to get locker space. Having a BA Gold Card certainly helps, but sometimes the pre-boarding can be an absolute shambles, and now there are so many other cards that allow pre-boarding the queues on the pre-board lines are immense. But these are the regular travelers who know that if you want bin space, you have yo get on early.
You get to the gate in good time then hang around close-by waiting to get first on - all the time being eyed-up at with disdain by the cool 'we're in no hurry' brigade. Better too when they start to mutter 'the plane won't go without you' or 'you won't lose your seat you know' in a superior tone. A joy then to arrive at an empty bin, directly above your seat and place your [regulation sized
] hand luggage in, and then sit then watch the fun as later boarders chase up and down the cabin ever more frantically hunting for space and the inevitable 'discussions' with the cabin crew.Of course the truth is there simply isn't enough locker space if everyone takes on even their regulation allowances. Sure some folks take the pi$$ with over-sized bags or just take too many, but in reality most folks bags are within the size limits. But its a bit like over-booking and hoping folks don't turn up; the hope is not everyone takes their full carry-on allowance. The only real solution would be to reduce everyone's allowance so that a 'full load' is guaranteed to fit...but this would reduce the size of carry-ons, and most of the time would leave empty space since not everyone takes a carry-on bag. I note EasyJet now have a policy with 2 bag sizes and that makes some sense - a slightly smaller bag guaranteed to get on, and a larger size the may have to go in the hold if there's no space. Not sure how that would work with the full-fare airlines and/or transatlantics etc.
As it is you just have to 'play the game', and the 'game' is get on early to get locker space. Having a BA Gold Card certainly helps, but sometimes the pre-boarding can be an absolute shambles, and now there are so many other cards that allow pre-boarding the queues on the pre-board lines are immense. But these are the regular travelers who know that if you want bin space, you have yo get on early.
Otispunkmeyer said:
I think some of the apathy stems from the impression that if you are in an air crash, you'll probably end up in a ball of flames and feeling pretty dead. Brace positions and life jackets are not gonna save you when plummeting to the ground at high speed. I don't have encyclopaedic knowledge of air crashes but of the ones I have seen on shows like air crash investigation, either they scrape along the runway after the pilot was able to glide it down and some people get off before the flames or the plane is smashed to pieces on impact along with everyone inside. Water landings seem to be complete pot luck.
I do pay attention to the briefing, but to be honest I never really expect it to save my life.
Not every "in-flight" emergency occurs in the airI do pay attention to the briefing, but to be honest I never really expect it to save my life.
Of those you mention (scrapey runway smash and water landing), although they may appear to be pot luck in terms of survival, why ignore the opportunity to load the dice in your favour a little beforehand?
It's been proven many times that even knowing the number of rows to the nearer exit or cross passage can be the difference between a post-crash book deal and premature cremation.
I travelled back from the Dom rep this morning or last night ,i'm a wee bit confused right now, but anything over 20 kilo's people were being asked to pay extra, luckily we were on the limit, i can understand weight limits but just by paying out does that make it ok ? i assume they claim it's a weight/fuel thing, but i weigh twice the weight my youngest daughter does, it's just an airlines scam isn't it.
I've been on Easyjet flights where almost everyone has just taken hand luggage and they've had to delay the flight to put it in the hold....
The attendants always look most surprised - I guess they have never read the bit that says "Check-in Luggage is an additional £30" when you come to buy your ticket
The attendants always look most surprised - I guess they have never read the bit that says "Check-in Luggage is an additional £30" when you come to buy your ticket

Black can man said:
I travelled back from the Dom rep this morning or last night ,i'm a wee bit confused right now, but anything over 20 kilo's people were being asked to pay extra, luckily we were on the limit, i can understand weight limits but just by paying out does that make it ok ? i assume they claim it's a weight/fuel thing, but i weigh twice the weight my youngest daughter does, it's just an airlines scam isn't it.
They've got to enforce it somehow, if a plane ends up too overloaded a pallet of cases may miss a flight, again I suspect all this is down to the fact that most of the time there are spaces in the hold or the lockers but at busy times both of these may end up full.TEKNOPUG said:
I've been on Easyjet flights where almost everyone has just taken hand luggage and they've had to delay the flight to put it in the hold....
The attendants always look most surprised - I guess they have never read the bit that says "Check-in Luggage is an additional £30" when you come to buy your ticket
Do Easyjet not have a weight limit and size limit for carry on stuff?The attendants always look most surprised - I guess they have never read the bit that says "Check-in Luggage is an additional £30" when you come to buy your ticket

ETA - it looks like they do but don't actually provide enough space if every passenger decides to bring on their full allocation. Why not either
reduce the allocation
charge extra for carry-on
Edited by Countdown on Wednesday 6th November 16:07
It IS a problem these days. Two simple approaches:
1. Get on early
2. Know approx where your seat row is, scan ahead as you walk along the aisle and dump your bag anywhere forward of where you will be sitting if it's looking busy up near your own row. NEVER place the bag aft of your row, unless you want to be last person off the plane too (which kind of negates your original plan to minimise the anticipated 10 hours on board
)
1. Get on early

2. Know approx where your seat row is, scan ahead as you walk along the aisle and dump your bag anywhere forward of where you will be sitting if it's looking busy up near your own row. NEVER place the bag aft of your row, unless you want to be last person off the plane too (which kind of negates your original plan to minimise the anticipated 10 hours on board
) Countdown said:
Do Easyjet not have a weight limit and size limit for carry on stuff?
Size, yes, weight no (provided you can lift it into the bin yourself, although large numbers of people seem incapable of this anyway and ask for assistance).Edited by Countdown on Wednesday 6th November 16:07
Gassing Station | Holidays & Travel | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


