Google Adwords Click Fraud - criminal offence?
Discussion
I'll try and cut a long story short - essentially we're finding that somebody, using a public PC (in a library) is clicking on our google ad over and over again, and now doing so in such a way that we cannot block their IP, and Google isn't spotting the pattern, so we're being charged for each click. There is no doubt whatsoever that this is malicious, and intended to cost us money.
The police are involved, but can't find any legislation that covers this - so can't act. So my question to the PH experts is this - is there a crime that covers this behaviour? The police claim no fraud nor harassment legislation covers it, but have invited me to come up with something. Does anybody have any practical experience in the field???
ETA: total cost to the business is probably about £6k a year at current levels. Not huge, but enough to spend some time sorting out. And no, I don't know who the person is - data protection means the library won't tell me, hence the need to try and get BiB down there.
The police are involved, but can't find any legislation that covers this - so can't act. So my question to the PH experts is this - is there a crime that covers this behaviour? The police claim no fraud nor harassment legislation covers it, but have invited me to come up with something. Does anybody have any practical experience in the field???
ETA: total cost to the business is probably about £6k a year at current levels. Not huge, but enough to spend some time sorting out. And no, I don't know who the person is - data protection means the library won't tell me, hence the need to try and get BiB down there.
Edited by Actus Reus on Wednesday 6th November 11:09
So was I, but yes, we're both wrong. Reason being, I guess, that a big office might share the same IP. Either way we're paying a noticeable amount extra, and need this sorted PDQ.
The legislation above is good though, and something I did see a while back - I might phone the copper on the case and see what he says.
The legislation above is good though, and something I did see a while back - I might phone the copper on the case and see what he says.
Easiest way to prevent this happening in the future is to ask the library to install Adblock plus on the computers, then no ads will appear on google searches.
Does the DPA apply even to criminal acts? I bet they wouldn't have any qualms with the DPA if it was someone looking at dodgy porn on the library computers. I would ask the library to filter out searches related to your company, if they don't comply then invoice the library the the six grand as they are allowing a criminal act to occur on their property using their equipment without seemingly doing anything to prevent it.
I think then they would change their tune or ban the internet completely without better logging. Did google tell you what time the ads are being clicked? If they do then it may be worth asking the police to request cctv from the library and matching the two up.
Does the DPA apply even to criminal acts? I bet they wouldn't have any qualms with the DPA if it was someone looking at dodgy porn on the library computers. I would ask the library to filter out searches related to your company, if they don't comply then invoice the library the the six grand as they are allowing a criminal act to occur on their property using their equipment without seemingly doing anything to prevent it.
I think then they would change their tune or ban the internet completely without better logging. Did google tell you what time the ads are being clicked? If they do then it may be worth asking the police to request cctv from the library and matching the two up.
The library have been utterly useless - I can't rely on them helping me at all. They are aware which library card this relates to, and refuse to act, even now the police are involved.
As I said though, the police are not sure what legislation applies - I've passed on Cat's suggestion above, and hope something might now be done by the BiB. I don't care about prosecution, I just want this to stop - we're a start-up, and don't need this hassle/expense. I've been generally disappointed at how all the apparatus you imagine will help you, has done nothing - library, Google, Police - all so far useless, with the exception of the DC now working on the case for me, who seems genuinely keen to help. Let's hope so anyway.
ETA: Definitely possible to write a script for this, but it's too irregular - it seems to be 'manual'.
As I said though, the police are not sure what legislation applies - I've passed on Cat's suggestion above, and hope something might now be done by the BiB. I don't care about prosecution, I just want this to stop - we're a start-up, and don't need this hassle/expense. I've been generally disappointed at how all the apparatus you imagine will help you, has done nothing - library, Google, Police - all so far useless, with the exception of the DC now working on the case for me, who seems genuinely keen to help. Let's hope so anyway.
ETA: Definitely possible to write a script for this, but it's too irregular - it seems to be 'manual'.
Actus Reus said:
The library have been utterly useless - I can't rely on them helping me at all. They are aware which library card this relates to, and refuse to act, even now the police are involved.
If the library staff don't want to know, bypass them and complain direct (in writing) to the relevant portfolio holder at the Local Authority.. Mention the Act that Cat referred to (and keep the DC in the loop too). If you're in the same LA area speak to your ward councillor as well. That's one of the things he/she is elected for - to represent the interests of all his/her constituents.Actus Reus said:
So was I, but yes, we're both wrong. Reason being, I guess, that a big office might share the same IP. Either way we're paying a noticeable amount extra, and need this sorted PDQ.
.
How did you find this out? Do google list the IP addresses somewhere?.
Will google really not just discount pay per clicks from this IP?
Also, presumably the prime suspect is a competitor ergo not malicious as such, just a
?untakenname said:
Easiest way to prevent this happening in the future is to ask the library to install Adblock plus on the computers, then no ads will appear on google searches.
Does the DPA apply even to criminal acts? I bet they wouldn't have any qualms with the DPA if it was someone looking at dodgy porn on the library computers. I would ask the library to filter out searches related to your company, if they don't comply then invoice the library the the six grand as they are allowing a criminal act to occur on their property using their equipment without seemingly doing anything to prevent it.
I think then they would change their tune or ban the internet completely without better logging. Did google tell you what time the ads are being clicked? If they do then it may be worth asking the police to request cctv from the library and matching the two up.
Is an offense even being committed? If being annoying was a criminal act the prisons would be even more overcrowded than they are? Does the DPA apply even to criminal acts? I bet they wouldn't have any qualms with the DPA if it was someone looking at dodgy porn on the library computers. I would ask the library to filter out searches related to your company, if they don't comply then invoice the library the the six grand as they are allowing a criminal act to occur on their property using their equipment without seemingly doing anything to prevent it.
I think then they would change their tune or ban the internet completely without better logging. Did google tell you what time the ads are being clicked? If they do then it may be worth asking the police to request cctv from the library and matching the two up.
Could your web server re-direct clicks from the library IP address to a porn site? Preferably one with a gazillion pop ups.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/URL_redirection
That ought to get the library to take action!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/URL_redirection
That ought to get the library to take action!
OK - yes, I've spoken to the local authority - they too have been no help so far. I may press them further.
As to where did I find this out, an IT forensics specialist tracked the IP for me - subsequently the library confirmed it was their IP (and I've confirmed this myself to be sure).
Is it a competitor? No idea - it might very well be, or it might be a lunatic, an ex-girlfriend...could be anybody. The library card being used belongs to a woman in her 50's apparently. However, you have to pass no checks whatsoever to obtain a card, or the details may be stolen. Certainly there are few women in their 50's who are competitors.
Is an offence being committed - I think it's open to debate to be honest. The legislation Cat cites covers this I think - it's a bit more than a mere annoyance though. We're losing money.
Finally, no, Google definitely don't deserve my business, but Google ads are crucial to our advertising. We will explore other avenues going forward, but those will cost money too and ROI on google ads for us is good, so it's hard to just walk away from them. Damned if we do, damned if we don't. Trying to be as level and reasonable as we can be about all this, and this has been going on for months, but finally it's costing us money, and time more and more, so we feel forced into action. It sounds very minor (and I suppose, objectively, it is), but it's quite concerning for us.
ETA: re-direct has been mentioned, and I may investigate it. Just wouldn't want to catch somebody legit by accident. Nice idea though. Would liven up the library a bit.
As to where did I find this out, an IT forensics specialist tracked the IP for me - subsequently the library confirmed it was their IP (and I've confirmed this myself to be sure).
Is it a competitor? No idea - it might very well be, or it might be a lunatic, an ex-girlfriend...could be anybody. The library card being used belongs to a woman in her 50's apparently. However, you have to pass no checks whatsoever to obtain a card, or the details may be stolen. Certainly there are few women in their 50's who are competitors.
Is an offence being committed - I think it's open to debate to be honest. The legislation Cat cites covers this I think - it's a bit more than a mere annoyance though. We're losing money.
Finally, no, Google definitely don't deserve my business, but Google ads are crucial to our advertising. We will explore other avenues going forward, but those will cost money too and ROI on google ads for us is good, so it's hard to just walk away from them. Damned if we do, damned if we don't. Trying to be as level and reasonable as we can be about all this, and this has been going on for months, but finally it's costing us money, and time more and more, so we feel forced into action. It sounds very minor (and I suppose, objectively, it is), but it's quite concerning for us.
ETA: re-direct has been mentioned, and I may investigate it. Just wouldn't want to catch somebody legit by accident. Nice idea though. Would liven up the library a bit.
Edited by Actus Reus on Wednesday 6th November 13:36
Actus Reus said:
The library have been utterly useless - I can't rely on them helping me at all. They are aware which library card this relates to, and refuse to act, even now the police are involved.
As I said though, the police are not sure what legislation applies - I've passed on Cat's suggestion above, and hope something might now be done by the BiB. I don't care about prosecution, I just want this to stop - we're a start-up, and don't need this hassle/expense. I've been generally disappointed at how all the apparatus you imagine will help you, has done nothing - library, Google, Police - all so far useless, with the exception of the DC now working on the case for me, who seems genuinely keen to help. Let's hope so anyway.
ETA: Definitely possible to write a script for this, but it's too irregular - it seems to be 'manual'.
while its a pain and £, what exactly do you propose the library to do based on your as yet unproved allegations against a backdrop of the police 'being involved' yet what they've actually done is kick it back to you to work out what if any offence there is?As I said though, the police are not sure what legislation applies - I've passed on Cat's suggestion above, and hope something might now be done by the BiB. I don't care about prosecution, I just want this to stop - we're a start-up, and don't need this hassle/expense. I've been generally disappointed at how all the apparatus you imagine will help you, has done nothing - library, Google, Police - all so far useless, with the exception of the DC now working on the case for me, who seems genuinely keen to help. Let's hope so anyway.
ETA: Definitely possible to write a script for this, but it's too irregular - it seems to be 'manual'.
off the top of my head I can't think what offence may be there (am not sure the one mentioned earlier applies), it may be that it's only a civil matter
Edited by pork911 on Wednesday 6th November 13:43
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


