Insurance company fun...
Author
Discussion

Windymiller

Original Poster:

1,937 posts

271 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
Few years back, I took out insurance with a company - let's call them Commodore wink
I'm pretty sure I told them about the points on my license, but they claim I didn't...

Cut to this month, I get a renewal notice off them of £1109 so hop onto Confused to try and beat it.
Weirdly Commodore come back with £860 via Confused so I call their renewals dept up, tell them they've been beaten by themselves and they honour the lower price. I've double checked and I'd declared my points with Confused correctly.

I've now had an email saying that because I didn't declare my points, the £860 policy is going up to £1650! I called them up and was told that it's to cover the previous years that I was under-insured!

WTF?!!!

I've just re-quoted with Confused and Commodore have come back with £950!

So, firstly, can they recoup the 'under insured' cost, or does that not just make the policy void?
Secondly, is each policy not an individual contract that expires at its closing date?

Going home to hunt my old insurance documents down....

speedking31

3,964 posts

167 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
They can propose a premium of whatever sum they like based on whatever reasons they like; it is up to you to then accept or decline the policy.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
Windymiller said:
Going home to hunt my old insurance documents down....
Bet we never hear from you again once you've checked them and the points aren't on there. Feel free to call my bluff by scanning and posting.

Tribal Chestnut

3,001 posts

213 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
Bet we never hear from you again once you've checked them and the points aren't on there. Feel free to call my bluff by scanning and posting.
So, maybe he didn't check his docs properly, but that in no way excuses the conniving, deceitful, ins co for their 'error'.

(obviously I'm assuming Windypops isn't fibbing to us here)

Windymiller

Original Poster:

1,937 posts

271 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
Sorry, the bit I'm talking about is the backdating of sums owed - they said they're going to chase me for what the premium would have been if I declared the points!!! Can they do that?!!

New POD

3,851 posts

181 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
If you go with another insurance company, how are they going to collect last years under payment.

I honestly don't get it. Lets say You forgot to tell them, and crashed killing a bus load of people, and leaving them with a bill of millions to compensate. Would they just be asking for the extra premium ?

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
New POD said:
If you go with another insurance company, how are they going to collect last years under payment.

I honestly don't get it. Lets say You forgot to tell them, and crashed killing a bus load of people, and leaving them with a bill of millions to compensate. Would they just be asking for the extra premium ?
You would expect your Insurer to pay the claim and providing you had not deliberately misled them and they would have offered cover had you declared the convictions originally then they would pay the claims subject to you paying the extra money.

In return for the above, the Insurer would expect you to reimberse them for undisclosed convictions when they discover.

Admiral are very hot on this and will pursue the money.

Ledaig

1,811 posts

293 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
If I were you I would just go somewhere else, if you continue to push they may 'refuse to insure'.

This will then give you additional issues when you try to insure elsewhere as you will have to declare that you have had insurance refused/cancelled which is a standard question.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
dacouch said:
New POD said:
If you go with another insurance company, how are they going to collect last years under payment.

I honestly don't get it. Lets say You forgot to tell them, and crashed killing a bus load of people, and leaving them with a bill of millions to compensate. Would they just be asking for the extra premium ?
You would expect your Insurer to pay the claim and providing you had not deliberately misled them and they would have offered cover had you declared the convictions originally then they would pay the claims subject to you paying the extra money.

In return for the above, the Insurer would expect you to reimberse them for undisclosed convictions when they discover.

Admiral are very hot on this and will pursue the money.
Not any more. The Consumer Insurance Act means if you fail to declare things that are specifically asked about then any percentage underpayment on premium is mirrored on the claim being undrpiad by the same percentage. Quite expensive for the deliberate non-declarers.

Upatdawn

2,202 posts

179 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
They usually wait till you claim THEN find your non-disclosure and refuse to cover you leaving all the bills in your lap

Windymiller

Original Poster:

1,937 posts

271 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
Right, hands up - just checked my policy and it had no points on it. Bugger.

What doesn't make sense though is that they quoted me £1109 as a renewal without of the points, and quoted me £860 as a new customer WITH the points!!!!

Problem is, I paid the £860, then they contacted me to increase it to £1650, I told them no way, and now they've cancelled the policy and taken a chunk out to cover the previous policy! Letter time....

New POD

3,851 posts

181 months

Friday 8th November 2013
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
dacouch said:
New POD said:
If you go with another insurance company, how are they going to collect last years under payment.

I honestly don't get it. Lets say You forgot to tell them, and crashed killing a bus load of people, and leaving them with a bill of millions to compensate. Would they just be asking for the extra premium ?
You would expect your Insurer to pay the claim and providing you had not deliberately misled them and they would have offered cover had you declared the convictions originally then they would pay the claims subject to you paying the extra money.

In return for the above, the Insurer would expect you to reimberse them for undisclosed convictions when they discover.

Admiral are very hot on this and will pursue the money.
Not any more. The Consumer Insurance Act means if you fail to declare things that are specifically asked about then any percentage underpayment on premium is mirrored on the claim being undrpiad by the same percentage. Quite expensive for the deliberate non-declarers.
So if the claim was say £1million, and the points caused a theoretical 20% increase, I'd be expected to sell my house to find £200K?

I'm sorry to the OP, about his mistake, but look on the bright side. YOU never killed anyone, and it's less than £1000.

And we've all learnt the risks we could be taking if we get the details incorrect.

Hence why some brokers demand to see copies of driving licence before the policy is taken out.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Friday 8th November 2013
quotequote all
Windymiller said:
Right, hands up - just checked my policy and it had no points on it. Bugger.

What doesn't make sense though is that they quoted me £1109 as a renewal without of the points, and quoted me £860 as a new customer WITH the points!!!!

Problem is, I paid the £860, then they contacted me to increase it to £1650, I told them no way, and now they've cancelled the policy and taken a chunk out to cover the previous policy! Letter time....
They are well within their rights to do this. Admiral are hugely competitive on price (aka cheap) and maintain this market position by being very hot on chasing down underpayers and deliberate / reckless / careless misrepresentation. It's the same as shoplifting at the maajor supermarkets, they take a dim view of it and you are helping yourself to more than you're entitled to for what you've paid.

Upatdawn said:
They usually wait till you claim THEN find your non-disclosure and refuse to cover you leaving all the bills in your lap
No, "they" don't. Unless you hve deliberately induced the insurer to form a contract that they would not have otherwise entered into. If they would have covered you with all facts disclosed then they must pay out, lbeit with the ability to either reduce the payout by the same percentage by which you underpaid your premium, or to ask you to make up the balance first.

New POD said:
So if the claim was say £1million, and the points caused a theoretical 20% increase, I'd be expected to sell my house to find £200K?

I'm sorry to the OP, about his mistake, but look on the bright side. YOU never killed anyone, and it's less than £1000.

And we've all learnt the risks we could be taking if we get the details incorrect.

Hence why some brokers demand to see copies of driving licence before the policy is taken out.
Put simply "yes". This is a new law live from April 2013. It only applies if the question has been explicitly asked. So "Have you any points on your driving licence2, or words to that effect are pretty explicit and the insurer has this right. If you look t it objectively, you're paying for 80% of the cover you want, so paying out 80% is only fair.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Friday 8th November 2013
quotequote all
Windymiller said:
Right, hands up - just checked my policy and it had no points on it. Bugger.
Surely it's your DL counterpart that has the points? How can an insurance policy contain them? Are you talking about a copy of your proposal form/renewal document(s)?

Windymiller said:
What doesn't make sense though is that they quoted me £1109 as a renewal without of the points, and quoted me £860 as a new customer WITH the points!!!!
Nothing about insurance premiums makes much sense to the man on the Clapham Omnibus.

Windymiller said:
Problem is, I paid the £860, then they contacted me to increase it to £1650, I told them no way, and now they've cancelled the policy and taken a chunk out to cover the previous policy! Letter time....
You've now got a major problem. If the insurer (rather than you) has cancelled the policy you will have to declare this to any other prospective one and this will affect any future quote. It's another case of whoever acts first holds the high ground.

Du1point8

22,987 posts

223 months

Friday 8th November 2013
quotequote all
Not a lot the OP can do, not declaring points and then getting a years insurance at the lower rate, just be glad you didnt crash and they then found out.

I would say you are going to have to suck it up and just accept that you forgot to tell them and they have taken the 'adjustment' out of the money you paid them.

If you did not do this you would not be able to simply move to a new company otherwise your old insurer would not have released your NCB letter.

If it was me and I found out I forgot, I would have done everything, including just giving them the adjustment not to get a cancellation notice of insurance. That cancellation is going to hurt a lot more than not delcaring the points, owning up and paying off the adjustment to get the NCB letter released and moving on.

Im prepared to be proven wrong but I have seen the above happen before and the person didnt take my advice to suck it up and then had to pay the adjustment and is now paying a premium for the cancellation marker too. Not sure how many years they check that one for.

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Friday 8th November 2013
quotequote all
It sounds like technically the OP has cancelled the policy by refusing the increased price so all may not be that bad.Question is are they justified in taking money in this way or could it be claimed back via the bank? He agreed to pay for a policy, not for disputable costs related to previous policies.

OP did you make any claims on the old policy? If you did then it only seems fair that admiral should be able to recover some money from you.

Edited by General Fluff on Friday 8th November 08:50

Du1point8

22,987 posts

223 months

Friday 8th November 2013
quotequote all
General Fluff said:
It sounds like technically the OP has cancelled the policy by refusing the increased price so all may not be that bad.Question is are they justified in taking money in this way or could it be claimed back via the bank? He agreed to pay for a policy, not for disputable costs related to previous policies.

OP did you make any claims on the old policy? If you did then it only seems fair that admiral should be able to recover some money from you.

Edited by General Fluff on Friday 8th November 08:50
OP paid for a service and lied about their risk and got a cheaper policy, it makes not a difference if the OP claimed on the insurance or not, OP was a higher risk person and told the insurance company he was not, that resulted in a lower premium.

What makes you think its fair for the OP to keep the extra money the OP should have paid in the first place for misrepresnting themself?

surveyor

18,709 posts

215 months

Friday 8th November 2013
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
They are well within their rights to do this. Admiral are hugely competitive on price (aka cheap) and maintain this market position by being very hot on chasing down underpayers and deliberate / reckless / careless misrepresentation. It's the same as shoplifting at the maajor supermarkets, they take a dim view of it and you are helping yourself to more than you're entitled to for what you've paid.
They are out of order on one point I believe Loon. If I read the OP correctly, there is in new business terms £90 difference between points / no points this year.

What the insurance company seem to be doing is saying you lied to us so we are going to rape you for almost double the premium.

I have no problem with the fact that they are asking for more money, but more problem that the level of difference does not seem to be fair. But since when did we expect fairness from an insurance company I suppose.

pork911

7,365 posts

214 months

Friday 8th November 2013
quotequote all
Even if no claim was ever made on the old policy I'm not sure why op is dissatisfied with any of what's happened.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Friday 8th November 2013
quotequote all
surveyor said:
They are out of order on one point I believe Loon. If I read the OP correctly, there is in new business terms £90 difference between points / no points this year.

What the insurance company seem to be doing is saying you lied to us so we are going to rape you for almost double the premium.

I have no problem with the fact that they are asking for more money, but more problem that the level of difference does not seem to be fair. But since when did we expect fairness from an insurance company I suppose.
Any business can charge whatver they like for their product. Whilst insurance is compulsory, buying it form Admiral is not. Their rating syatem is saying, "this guy has lied to us before, is that the sort of risk we want?". Simple as that.

Would you keep surveying for someone who kept sending you 70% of your bill?