Self - Employed Sole Trader going into a Partnership?
Discussion
Hi,
Wondering if you could help me with a little issue that I have.
I am currently self-employed as a sole trader and looking to earn in excess of £20k profit in my first year.
I am wondering if I enter into a partnership with my wife, which she is happy to do, could I split my business income 50/50 with her without her doing 50% of the workload.
She would just do a bit of admin and help me make business decisions but may involve more in the future when the children have got a bit older.
What implications would it have, if any, to do this?
I understand the debt issue - i.e joint and several liability we have covered that already.
I suppose in essence, I want our income to be shared. £10k for me and £10k for the wife. Are there any barriers to this?
Cheers
Stix
Wondering if you could help me with a little issue that I have.
I am currently self-employed as a sole trader and looking to earn in excess of £20k profit in my first year.
I am wondering if I enter into a partnership with my wife, which she is happy to do, could I split my business income 50/50 with her without her doing 50% of the workload.
She would just do a bit of admin and help me make business decisions but may involve more in the future when the children have got a bit older.
What implications would it have, if any, to do this?
I understand the debt issue - i.e joint and several liability we have covered that already.
I suppose in essence, I want our income to be shared. £10k for me and £10k for the wife. Are there any barriers to this?
Cheers
Stix
sumo69 said:
Yes - HMRC!
Look up at Settlements legislation!
Have you considered paying her a salary for her work? Wholly legal and may result in a substantial saving of tax and NIC based on your estimated profit.
PM me if you want to talk it through.
David
I'm glad that was such a concise answer.Look up at Settlements legislation!
Have you considered paying her a salary for her work? Wholly legal and may result in a substantial saving of tax and NIC based on your estimated profit.
PM me if you want to talk it through.
David
So essentially I have a couple more options opening up for me here:
1. Stay as a sole-trader in my own right - 100% income - 100% tax liability down to me
2. Stay as a sole-trader and pay my wife no more than £147 p/w for her contributions to pay minimal NI cont. and offset that against my tax?
3. Become a partnership - pay a fair percentage of profits based on wife's contribution to the business - say 30%??
4. Setup a limited company with my wife and give both of us Ordinary Shares.
Cheers
Stix
1. Stay as a sole-trader in my own right - 100% income - 100% tax liability down to me
2. Stay as a sole-trader and pay my wife no more than £147 p/w for her contributions to pay minimal NI cont. and offset that against my tax?
3. Become a partnership - pay a fair percentage of profits based on wife's contribution to the business - say 30%??
4. Setup a limited company with my wife and give both of us Ordinary Shares.
Cheers
Stix
StixUK said:
So essentially I have a couple more options opening up for me here:
1. Stay as a sole-trader in my own right - 100% income - 100% tax liability down to me
2. Stay as a sole-trader and pay my wife no more than £147 p/w for her contributions to pay minimal NI cont. and offset that against my tax?
3. Become a partnership - pay a fair percentage of profits based on wife's contribution to the business - say 30%??
4. Setup a limited company with my wife and give both of us Ordinary Shares.
Cheers
Stix
No.4 is often now the most popular option. In the modern world this tends to be chosen over partnership solutions - even limited liability [partnerships (LLPs).1. Stay as a sole-trader in my own right - 100% income - 100% tax liability down to me
2. Stay as a sole-trader and pay my wife no more than £147 p/w for her contributions to pay minimal NI cont. and offset that against my tax?
3. Become a partnership - pay a fair percentage of profits based on wife's contribution to the business - say 30%??
4. Setup a limited company with my wife and give both of us Ordinary Shares.
Cheers
Stix
Sumo is, of course, correct to highlight the fact that HMRC has "anti-settlement" legislation in place which is designed to stop an individual transferring some of his income to another individual in order to reduce the tax (and NI) liability arising on the income generated in the business.
The most important tax case on this subject to examine is a case commonly referred to as "The Arctic Systems" case.
This was a limited company set up by an individual who then made his wife an equal shareholder in the company, effectively entitling her to half of any dividends issued by the company - thereby splitting the dividends and making most use of his and his wife's tax bands and thresholds.
Although he had done nothing illegal, HMRC challenged the set up and tried to block the arrangement on the basis that the main individual in the business (Mr Jones) was giving away (i.e. "settling") half of his income to Mrs Jones in order to artificially reduce his tax bills.
After three years of appeals (all the way to the House of Lords in the end) and counter appeals, HMRC LOST their case and Mr Jones was allowed to continue with the arrangement.
So, although the anti-settlement legislation exists, it does seem that HMRC will always have difficult in blocking these types of profit splitting arrangements.
After the decision in The Arctic Systems case, the Chancellor stated that the legislation on profit splitting would be revised and tightened to make such arrangements very difficult. However, about 18 months later he confirmed that, due to the impossibility of applying such legislation, there would be no significant changes to the current rules.
The general principle I would apply is that, if a spouse/partner is being brought into the business as part of a "tax planning" exercise, make sure that the spouse/partner has a definable role within the business and does spend some provable time in the business performing some work.
In the case of a limited company, making the spouse/partner a company director (in addition to being a shareholder) will go a long way in showing HMRC that the spouse/partner has a proper role and responsibility within the company.
HMRC said that if Mrs Jones had been a formally appointed director of Arctic Systems Ltd they would never have started the case in the first place.
Simpo Two said:
It strikes me that if a spouse is introduced as a partner after some time, ie when profits are good and tax is becoming an issue, then it is rightly or wrongly seen as tax evasion.
However what if the spouse was a partner from day one? Would HMRC be OK then?
It is very, very rarely challenged by HMRC as "tax evasion" (criminal offence). However, they can tackle it under "Anti-Settlement" legislation which is legal (but not allowable) "Tax Avoidance".However what if the spouse was a partner from day one? Would HMRC be OK then?
And even then, it is rare that partnership or shareholder arrangements are challenged. Having had their fingers burned on "Arctic Systems" they've lost enthusiasm - for the moment.
So Eric;
would you suggest:
1. employing my wife?
2. introducing her as a partner?
3. becoming a ltd co and making her a shareholder and/or director? (I don't yet understand the difference, so would need advice about this at some point)
I am a self-employed debt collector, so would there be additional issues re the FCA coming in and me requiring to get a CCL as well.
I think under the current OFT guidelines, if I employ her she is covered by my CCL as an employee, if she becomes a partner I might have to get a partnership CCL as she would not be employed by me and therefore will require a CCL in her own right. A partnership CCL would cost me an extra £800-ish.
would you suggest:
1. employing my wife?
2. introducing her as a partner?
3. becoming a ltd co and making her a shareholder and/or director? (I don't yet understand the difference, so would need advice about this at some point)
I am a self-employed debt collector, so would there be additional issues re the FCA coming in and me requiring to get a CCL as well.
I think under the current OFT guidelines, if I employ her she is covered by my CCL as an employee, if she becomes a partner I might have to get a partnership CCL as she would not be employed by me and therefore will require a CCL in her own right. A partnership CCL would cost me an extra £800-ish.
There are more factors to consider than tax.
As you say, you have other considerations over and above tax concerning the regulations under which your business has to operate. Making her a director or a partner may not be possible under those non-tax regulations. You would have to check those regulations for yourself to find out whether bringing a spouse in in those terms is desirable or even possible.
In a simple partnership, the partners are joint and severally liable for the debts of the partnership. And the partners are also liable for decisions made by the partnership - which could implicate your wife in any legal problems arising from the business activity.
In a limited liability partnership the legal situation is essentially the same although the personal assets of the partners are (usually) off limits if the partnership fails.
The same goes for directors in a limited company. The directors are responsible for the decisions made by the company. But they (usually) won't lose their personal assets if it all goes wrong. However, there are plenty of exceptions now where directors can be held personally liable.
If your governing regulations don't allow you to make your wife a partner or co-director, then employing her would be an alternative.
A shareholder in a limited company has no day to day responsibility for the activities of the limited company. All they do is own shares. So, under company law, they are entitled to a dividend based on the number of shares held as and when the directors of the company decide that the company should pay out a dividend.
Shareholders (usually) have voting rights attached to their shares - usually equating to one share = one vote. That means they can vote at General Meetings of the company on key decisions.
And, of course, if a person is a shareholder with no control (as in Arctic Systems), they MIGHT be more susceptible to an attack from HMRC under their "settlements" rules.
As you say, you have other considerations over and above tax concerning the regulations under which your business has to operate. Making her a director or a partner may not be possible under those non-tax regulations. You would have to check those regulations for yourself to find out whether bringing a spouse in in those terms is desirable or even possible.
In a simple partnership, the partners are joint and severally liable for the debts of the partnership. And the partners are also liable for decisions made by the partnership - which could implicate your wife in any legal problems arising from the business activity.
In a limited liability partnership the legal situation is essentially the same although the personal assets of the partners are (usually) off limits if the partnership fails.
The same goes for directors in a limited company. The directors are responsible for the decisions made by the company. But they (usually) won't lose their personal assets if it all goes wrong. However, there are plenty of exceptions now where directors can be held personally liable.
If your governing regulations don't allow you to make your wife a partner or co-director, then employing her would be an alternative.
A shareholder in a limited company has no day to day responsibility for the activities of the limited company. All they do is own shares. So, under company law, they are entitled to a dividend based on the number of shares held as and when the directors of the company decide that the company should pay out a dividend.
Shareholders (usually) have voting rights attached to their shares - usually equating to one share = one vote. That means they can vote at General Meetings of the company on key decisions.
And, of course, if a person is a shareholder with no control (as in Arctic Systems), they MIGHT be more susceptible to an attack from HMRC under their "settlements" rules.
Hmmm I think that I should probably employ her as this seems the least invasive method and I can actually pay her for hours worked and she will be covered by my CCL.
What is the best resource I can use to sort this out and get a step-by-step guide on how I apply for it?
She is currently a housewife and has a zero income so there are no issues re tax codes yet and also she is currently in receipt of Child Benefit as our youngest child is 2 so she is already in receipt of State Pension credits so I think no issues there (IIRC?).
What should I pay someone who does basic administration tasks but also does bookkeeping as well, is there a standard 'going' rate?
Cheers
Stix
What is the best resource I can use to sort this out and get a step-by-step guide on how I apply for it?
She is currently a housewife and has a zero income so there are no issues re tax codes yet and also she is currently in receipt of Child Benefit as our youngest child is 2 so she is already in receipt of State Pension credits so I think no issues there (IIRC?).
What should I pay someone who does basic administration tasks but also does bookkeeping as well, is there a standard 'going' rate?
Cheers
Stix
Nope do it all myself as quite a simple income and outgoings business really.
Go collect debts - get paid a commission.
Spend some money doing it.
Income - Expenditure = Profit
I know pretty much what I can claim for and can't...through a lot of research.
Dare I say this...I don't feel that an accountant would benefit me for the cost involved!
Although saying that I don't know how much an accountant would be for my work.
Go collect debts - get paid a commission.
Spend some money doing it.
Income - Expenditure = Profit
I know pretty much what I can claim for and can't...through a lot of research.
Dare I say this...I don't feel that an accountant would benefit me for the cost involved!
Although saying that I don't know how much an accountant would be for my work.
Once you start taking on employees then you may find having a professional looking over your shoulder pays for itself.
If you propose to pay your wife at a level which keeps her salary out of PAYE and NI, then you will not really need to register your business for PAYE.
However, by doing that, you may be -
underpaying her for the work she does for you
not really saving that much tax on the business profits.
Are your profits high enough to take you into the Higher Rate tax area?
Is your business registered for VAT?
Is it likely to exceed the compulsory VAT registration threshold (currently £79,000) in the near future.
The fact that you are on this forum asking questions like this indicates that you could very well make use of an accountant.
If you propose to pay your wife at a level which keeps her salary out of PAYE and NI, then you will not really need to register your business for PAYE.
However, by doing that, you may be -
underpaying her for the work she does for you
not really saving that much tax on the business profits.
Are your profits high enough to take you into the Higher Rate tax area?
Is your business registered for VAT?
Is it likely to exceed the compulsory VAT registration threshold (currently £79,000) in the near future.
The fact that you are on this forum asking questions like this indicates that you could very well make use of an accountant.
Edited by Eric Mc on Tuesday 12th November 12:29
Eric Mc said:
Once you start taking on employees then you may find having a professional looking over your shoulder pays for itself.
If you propose to pay your wife at a level which keeps her salary out of PAYE and NI, then you will not really need to register your business for PAYE.
However, by doing that, you may be -
underpaying her for the work she does for you
not really saving that much tax on the business profits.
Are your profits high enough to take you into the Higher Rate tax area?
Is your business registered for VAT?
Is it likely to exceed the compulsory VAT registration threshold (currently £79,000) in the near future.
The fact that you are on this forum asking questions like this indicates that you could very well make use of an accountant.
My turnover will be around £30k - £40k on a sustainable basis.If you propose to pay your wife at a level which keeps her salary out of PAYE and NI, then you will not really need to register your business for PAYE.
However, by doing that, you may be -
underpaying her for the work she does for you
not really saving that much tax on the business profits.
Are your profits high enough to take you into the Higher Rate tax area?
Is your business registered for VAT?
Is it likely to exceed the compulsory VAT registration threshold (currently £79,000) in the near future.
The fact that you are on this forum asking questions like this indicates that you could very well make use of an accountant.
Edited by Eric Mc on Tuesday 12th November 12:29
My personal profit will hit around £20k - £25k from next year.
Will not need to register for VAT, will not reach threshold.
I would pay her around £8 per/hour to do all my basic administration tasks involved with my work:
route planning
book keeping
stationary ordering
printing
filing
dealing with correspondence
etc etc
Usually takes around 10- 15 hours per week.
So a salary would be around £4,160 - £6,240 p/a
She has a tax allowance currently not being utilised at all.
Would it not be beneficial to employ her and then she can have money in her own right for the tasks she is completing instead of just paying it directly out of my own allowance, which is what happens at the moment.
One point to add is currently these are the thresholds I reach in my self-eemployment
NI Class 4 - 9% (above £7.5k)
Income Tax - 20% (above £9.4k)
Student Loan (Income Contingent)- 9% (above £16.3k)
So if I reach £16.3k I have an additional 9% to pay on top compared to the 'normal' individual without a SL. By paying my wife I could earn below this threshold, therefore saving an additional 9% on anything that I would receive above this level.
I suppose what I am saying is:
If I earn £20k if pay roughly £3.5k in necessary taxes etc etc
If I earn £15k I pay roughly £1.8k in the same. (due to reduced tax burden and no SL payments)
If my wife is then paid the remaining £5k that she would be entitled to she would have no tax or NI burden.
Therefore
Me - £20k = £3.5k tax, NI, SL
Me £15k + Wife £5k = £1.8k tax and NI
Tax Burden = £1.7k less
I suppose the issue was...do I employ my wife, go into partnership or setup ltd co.
If I employ her, I probably could do this myself
If I do a partnership there are extended regulatory concerns and no benefit over employing her
If I setup a ltd co there are more rigorous procedures and more paperwork involved, so would DEFO need an accountant and he/she would probably pay for themselves within 12 months.
Eric Mc said:
Once you start taking on employees then you may find having a professional looking over your shoulder pays for itself.
If you propose to pay your wife at a level which keeps her salary out of PAYE and NI, then you will not really need to register your business for PAYE.
However, by doing that, you may be -
underpaying her for the work she does for you
not really saving that much tax on the business profits.
Are your profits high enough to take you into the Higher Rate tax area?
Is your business registered for VAT?
Is it likely to exceed the compulsory VAT registration threshold (currently £79,000) in the near future.
The fact that you are on this forum asking questions like this indicates that you could very well make use of an accountant.
My turnover will be around £30k - £40k on a sustainable basis.If you propose to pay your wife at a level which keeps her salary out of PAYE and NI, then you will not really need to register your business for PAYE.
However, by doing that, you may be -
underpaying her for the work she does for you
not really saving that much tax on the business profits.
Are your profits high enough to take you into the Higher Rate tax area?
Is your business registered for VAT?
Is it likely to exceed the compulsory VAT registration threshold (currently £79,000) in the near future.
The fact that you are on this forum asking questions like this indicates that you could very well make use of an accountant.
Edited by Eric Mc on Tuesday 12th November 12:29
My personal profit will hit around £20k - £25k from next year.
Will not need to register for VAT, will not reach threshold.
I would pay her around £8 per/hour to do all my basic administration tasks involved with my work:
route planning
book keeping
stationary ordering
printing
filing
dealing with correspondence
etc etc
Usually takes around 10- 15 hours per week.
So a salary would be around £4,160 - £6,240 p/a
She has a tax allowance currently not being utilised at all.
Would it not be beneficial to employ her and then she can have money in her own right for the tasks she is completing instead of just paying it directly out of my own allowance, which is what happens at the moment.
One point to add is currently these are the thresholds I reach in my self-eemployment
NI Class 4 - 9% (above £7.5k)
Income Tax - 20% (above £9.4k)
Student Loan (Income Contingent)- 9% (above £16.3k)
So if I reach £16.3k I have an additional 9% to pay on top compared to the 'normal' individual without a SL. By paying my wife I could earn below this threshold, therefore saving an additional 9% on anything that I would receive above this level.
I suppose what I am saying is:
If I earn £20k if pay roughly £3.5k in necessary taxes etc etc
If I earn £15k I pay roughly £1.8k in the same. (due to reduced tax burden and no SL payments)
If my wife is then paid the remaining £5k that she would be entitled to she would have no tax or NI burden.
Therefore
Me - £20k = £3.5k tax, NI, SL
Me £15k + Wife £5k = £1.8k tax and NI
Tax Burden = £1.7k less
I suppose the issue was...do I employ my wife, go into partnership or setup ltd co.
If I employ her, I probably could do this myself
If I do a partnership there are extended regulatory concerns and no benefit over employing her
If I setup a ltd co there are more rigorous procedures and more paperwork involved, so would DEFO need an accountant and he/she would probably pay for themselves within 12 months.
sumo69 said:
Eric has covered most of the bases since my last post but it appears from your figures that you should be paying your "admin" assistant more - give her an annual salary a £1 below the Employers NIC threshold which will save you a tidy sum over your analysis above.
David
Thanks DavidDavid
One quick question, can I pay her an annual salary instead of an hourly rate and if I pay a salary do I have to keep a time sheet? As when I was salaried in my previous role, I never clocked in or out.
Edited by StixUK on Tuesday 12th November 13:20
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


