Police impounded a car and wont give it back!
Police impounded a car and wont give it back!
Author
Discussion

Pappa Lurve

Original Poster:

3,827 posts

313 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
Long and short - I was driving a mates car and got pulled for not having insurance. I could not recall the details of my own insurance so the Police, perfectly fairly although annoyingly, impounded the car.

I went to get ti with all my paperwork in order but was told it was not in order so I could not get the car. They would not tell me why! The car has since been sold on by the Police but despite multiple attemots to get the car back before and after to get the market value, nothing.

Initially I was informed I could not make a complaint, then the Police lied about timelines and finally have simply stopped responding to emails despite promising to be back to me with a resolution last week.

So I am pretty much left with taking them to court. Anyone done such a thing? Any advice / suggestions?

The really sad thing is up until this I actually felt the Police got a raw deal but having tried to complain and been blocked at every turn, being told the Police do not need to adhere to the Data Protection Act and various other bits of rubbish I am sadly loosing my confidence in the BiB which is very sad as I know a few very good, very hardworking cops.

Defcon5

6,479 posts

222 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
Got to be more to this that you are saying.

You couldn't remember your VRM or insurance company or address in order for them to check your insurance details?

Why didn't your mate pick it up with his docs?

How long did you leave the car there for?

kiethton

14,672 posts

211 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
Were you charged with driving with no insurance - If you weren't/had it quashed it would put you in a far better position.

Have they offered any compensation to date? If so how does it compare to the published guides? - what was it - high/low value?

How long was the car left for? - how many attempts were made to collect it?

Edited by kiethton on Monday 11th November 16:04

AndrewEH1

4,922 posts

184 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
We are not getting the full picture here.

I'm assuming this all happened in England?

Pappa Lurve said:
The really sad thing is up until this I actually felt the Police got a raw deal but having tried to complain and been blocked at every turn, being told the Police do not need to adhere to the Data Protection Act and various other bits of rubbish I am sadly loosing my confidence in the BiB which is very sad as I know a few very good, very hardworking cops.
Well this is complete bks...you should be able to complain.




As an aside in Scotland they can't dispose of the vehicle before 3 months has passed in this situation. Although you might be liable for the storage costs...

Edited by AndrewEH1 on Monday 11th November 16:05

Pappa Lurve

Original Poster:

3,827 posts

313 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
Defcon5 said:
Got to be more to this that you are saying.

You couldn't remember your VRM or insurance company or address in order for them to check your insurance details?

Why didn't your mate pick it up with his docs?

How long did you leave the car there for?
VRM or insurance company - Oddly, they did not check against my address thinking about it.

Went to get the car about 7 days later, and again a few days after that.

Mate was unwell, hence I had his car and his full permission in writting to deal with this.

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
How long after they confiscated it did they sell it?

Pappa Lurve

Original Poster:

3,827 posts

313 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
kiethton said:
Were you charged with driving with no insurance - If you weren't/had it quashed it would put you in a far better position.

Have they offered any compensation to date? If so how does it compare to the published guides? - what was it - high/low value?

How long was the car left for? - how many attempts were made to collect it?

Edited by kiethton on Monday 11th November 16:04
I have not had any charges through yet so I guess not. If they do charge me I can prove I was insured so not hard to get that solved.

Nothihng been offered to date - they refused to even take the complaint on several occasions.

Went to the pound once on day 7, again a few days later, multiple calls and emails through this period to find why documentation that absolutly meets the criteria was refused, and I still have no answer to that!

I know the Police have to stick to the DPA and the law in general, but they seem to have an attitude of "whatever son, try it!" so unless I can think of another way forward, I am going to summons them.

Feel sorry for the decent cops as they are totally let down by the amusingly, and I assume ironically, named Professional Standards Directorate!!!

Pappa Lurve

Original Poster:

3,827 posts

313 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
mondeoman said:
How long after they confiscated it did they sell it?
Approx 21 days, which does appear to be legal. TO be honest, I couldn't care less about the car per se, as long as I get the value of it.

PurpleMoonlight

22,362 posts

188 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
For your insurance to cover you driving someone elses vehicle doesn't that other vehicle need to be insured?

The fact that you were pulled for no insurance suggests it wasn't.

Was there any valid insurance when you went to collect it?

Kapenta

1,842 posts

227 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
Did your mate have a valid Insurance Policy on the car when you were stopped, or were you driving it on your Insurance Policy under the condition that you use it to drive someone else's car, which was uninsured?

Pappa Lurve

Original Poster:

3,827 posts

313 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
PurpleMoonlight said:
For your insurance to cover you driving someone elses vehicle doesn't that other vehicle need to be insured?

The fact that you were pulled for no insurance suggests it wasn't.

Was there any valid insurance when you went to collect it?
The car should have its own policy but that does not need to insure anyone oddly! I was driving it on my own policy.

The car had been SORN and not insured for several months until the day before so it would be picked up on ANPR as illegal as those data bases in the cars are not up to date.

There was valid insurance when I went to collect it!

Megaflow

11,674 posts

256 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
I thought only the registered keeper could collect a car once it's impounded.

Pappa Lurve

Original Poster:

3,827 posts

313 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
Megaflow said:
I thought only the registered keeper could collect a car once it's impounded.
Not if you have written, signed permission and a very good reason why the owner can't.

Pappa Lurve

Original Poster:

3,827 posts

313 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
Kapenta said:
Did your mate have a valid Insurance Policy on the car when you were stopped, or were you driving it on your Insurance Policy under the condition that you use it to drive someone else's car, which was uninsured?
I think the latter. I am not aware he had a policy but certainly any driving by me was done under my own, which does allow that.

kiethton

14,672 posts

211 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
Pappa Lurve said:
Kapenta said:
Did your mate have a valid Insurance Policy on the car when you were stopped, or were you driving it on your Insurance Policy under the condition that you use it to drive someone else's car, which was uninsured?
I think the latter. I am not aware he had a policy but certainly any driving by me was done under my own, which does allow that.
In that case (and you are confident that your insurance provides adequate cover in that situation) suggest you sue them, after first providing them with a period to acknowledge your claim.

I would personally ask for the cost of a comparable car being sold by a dealer. Advise them that if you do not hear from them within say 14 days you will initiate proceedings and also look to cover costs.

I would send the letter by both e-mail and also as a PDF attachment to the e-mail address you have been attempting to send correspondence to with both delivery and read receipts enabled.

I'd only do this because if everything you have said is true they have really overstepped the mark and I personally am a rather vindictive sod who likes causing the most annoyance (on the right side of the law) who continue to piss me off despite offering an amenable get out option.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
Pappa Lurve said:
I think the latter. I am not aware he had a policy but certainly any driving by me was done under my own, which does allow that.
It sounds like the car was uninsured.
You might be allowed to drive any car on third party insurance, but that car also needs to be insured as the main car on a policy.

To collect the car you would have needed insurance documents for the car - not just your documents showing 'drive any car'.



Exige77

6,523 posts

222 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
Doesn't a car need to be SORN or covered by continuous insurance ?

So maybe they wont prosecute the OP as he was insured but didn't let the car out as it was not insured ?

If the car had been sorned until the day before the incident then a new policy must have been started the day before or the car wasn't insured.

kiethton

14,672 posts

211 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
It sounds like the car was uninsured.
You might be allowed to drive any car on third party insurance, but that car also needs to be insured as the main car on a policy.

To collect the car you would have needed insurance documents for the car - not just your documents showing 'drive any car'.


In my understanding not every policy's T+C's specify this as a condition, although the police like to think of it as such.

However, if left on the road (as opposed to stopped when driving) it would be more of a consideration.

OP have you checked you insurance small print T+C's regarding this to the letter? - may be worth requesting a letter from them for clarity?

Also how does this reflect on the multiple attempts to collect following the original stop?

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
Megaflow said:
I thought only the registered keeper could collect a car once it's impounded.
Close, but no cigar. smile

If the owner was driving when stopped the vehicle can be released to a nominated person provided all the documents are in order. However, if the driver stopped was not the owner, there is a caveat.
https://www.askthe.police.uk/content/Q362.htm

Example of a specific force's policy on release
http://www.kent.police.uk/about_us/policies/p/p33....

We need more precise details than the OP has provided so far to know whether or not a grave error has occurred.

Pappa Lurve said:
TO be honest, I couldn't care less about the car per se, as long as I get the value of it.
Oh, really? It's not even your car, so:

a) Your 'couldn't care less' attitude seems somewhat off.
b) You most certainly won't get any compensation because only the owner can sue for value.

Pappa Lurve said:
I think the latter. I am not aware he had a policy but certainly any driving by me was done under my own, which does allow that.
The leading case on driving under DOC cover is Pryor v Chief Constable of Greater Manchester Police.
The key question is whether your insurance certificate includes a clause requiring the vehicle you are driving to have its own current policy in force for your DOC cover to be operative. Many, but not all, now do (for instance I know mine does).


Edited by Red Devil on Monday 11th November 17:10

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Monday 11th November 2013
quotequote all
The insurers t+c might mean the drivers insurance is valid in the event of a crash.

But, it still doesn't mean the car doesn't have continuous insurance and isn't illegally on the road.

Lots of double negatives there, but I think you'll see what I mean.

An uninsured car is still an uninsured car, even if the driver is insured by other means.

I think trade plates have some exceptions to this.