Sales of Goods Act question
Discussion
Within 24 hours of what - delivery? IANAL but expecting a customer to commence construction of self-assembly furniture (without which it would be impossible to discover the fault) within that time frame would seem to me unreasonable. However they can't use that as a get out for an item being not fit for purpose. That brings us to the question of whether the assembly difficulties could be remedied by replacement parts. If their QC is
it won't, but you may have to give them the opportunity to try. I would, but with the clear proviso that if it doesn't work then I reserve my right to reject. YMMV.
it won't, but you may have to give them the opportunity to try. I would, but with the clear proviso that if it doesn't work then I reserve my right to reject. YMMV.Sounds like you've got multiple reasons to reject for a refund.
the oft website said:
Customers do have a legal right to a refund, repair or replacement if an item they purchased
• does not match the description
• is not of satisfactory quality
• is not fit for purpose
Each of these circumstances would mean that the item does not conform to contract and therefore it can be described as faulty
• does not match the description
• is not of satisfactory quality
• is not fit for purpose
Each of these circumstances would mean that the item does not conform to contract and therefore it can be described as faulty
MrsMiggins said:
Sounds like you've got multiple reasons to reject for a refund.
Just to clarify, the right to reject ends after a "reasonable" period at which point you are deemed to have accepted the goods. I think 24 hours could be argued as too short, but also, you've notified them on the first working day after delivery. Arguably within the 24 hours they've suggested.the oft website said:
Customers do have a legal right to a refund, repair or replacement if an item they purchased
• does not match the description
• is not of satisfactory quality
• is not fit for purpose
Each of these circumstances would mean that the item does not conform to contract and therefore it can be described as faulty
• does not match the description
• is not of satisfactory quality
• is not fit for purpose
Each of these circumstances would mean that the item does not conform to contract and therefore it can be described as faulty
That said, if they are offering to replace the items to correctly drilled and correct mattress I would do that, as you get what you want and don't have the faff of shopping for replacements.
Again from
the oft said:
reasonable time – this depends on the item and the circumstances. What is reasonable is determined by taking
everything into account and considering what an impartial person would think is reasonable.
So the definition of "reasonable" is up for debate, but I think the shop would be hard pressed to convince many people that complaining within 48 hours was not reasonable.everything into account and considering what an impartial person would think is reasonable.
Note also section 35(2) and (3) of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 (as amended by the Sale and Supply of Goods Act 1994):
"(2)Where goods are delivered to the buyer, and he has not previously examined them, he is not deemed to have accepted them under subsection (1) above until he has had a reasonable opportunity of examining them for the purpose—
(a)of ascertaining whether they are in conformity with the contract, and
(b) [...]
(3)Where the buyer deals as consumer ... the buyer cannot lose his right to rely on subsection (2) above by agreement, waiver or otherwise."
Thus a buyer who has not examined goods before they are delivered, is entitled to a "reasonable opportunity" to examine them - and that right cannot be exlcuded (so, in a consumer sale, a delivery note in which someone signs to confirm that goods they have not had an opportunity to inspect are in good order is not worth the paper it is written on).
Here, a seller of unassembled furniture would hard pressed to say that 24 hours is not a "reasonable" time to inspect.
Finally, the OP should put the rejection in clear terms in writing.
"(2)Where goods are delivered to the buyer, and he has not previously examined them, he is not deemed to have accepted them under subsection (1) above until he has had a reasonable opportunity of examining them for the purpose—
(a)of ascertaining whether they are in conformity with the contract, and
(b) [...]
(3)Where the buyer deals as consumer ... the buyer cannot lose his right to rely on subsection (2) above by agreement, waiver or otherwise."
Thus a buyer who has not examined goods before they are delivered, is entitled to a "reasonable opportunity" to examine them - and that right cannot be exlcuded (so, in a consumer sale, a delivery note in which someone signs to confirm that goods they have not had an opportunity to inspect are in good order is not worth the paper it is written on).
Here, a seller of unassembled furniture would hard pressed to say that 24 hours is not a "reasonable" time to inspect.
Finally, the OP should put the rejection in clear terms in writing.
Think you're getting a pretty good result here a replacement bed put together by the shop in a decent time period. I'm not sure you can expect a refund unless the replacement is faulty or doesn't turn up in a reasonable timeframe. I would think court proceedings at this stage may well go against you.
Trying to force someone to 'accept' within a short period of time would be an ufnair contract term
48 hours would certainly be too shrot for such an expensive item - taking into accoutn it may not be the type of thing people open straight away (i.e if moving to a new house or chucking out an old bed).
48 hours would certainly be too shrot for such an expensive item - taking into accoutn it may not be the type of thing people open straight away (i.e if moving to a new house or chucking out an old bed).
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


