Exhaust Gas recirculation valve
Exhaust Gas recirculation valve
Author
Discussion

ChrisW.

Original Poster:

8,166 posts

286 months

Tuesday 12th November 2013
quotequote all
How many PH'ers have had this fail on their Bluemotion or other diesels ??

Just out of warranty with FMDSH and being quoted £450 to repair ?

Deerfoot

5,259 posts

215 months

Tuesday 12th November 2013
quotequote all
I had one fail on my Polo GT TDI at around 80,000 miles and 7 years old.

I can`t remember how much it cost to replace but it was a lot less than you`ve been quoted. If I were you I`d find a decent VW specialist and get them to do the work.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 12th November 2013
quotequote all
Remove it and blank it off

SKC

50 posts

162 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
Hi,
What symptoms do you get when this fails. I've just bought an 07 TDI GT Sport Golf that appears to be a bit Smokey on idle. Awesome car just need to sort this. Turbo condition looks good and car has full service history so has had regular oil changes.

Regards
SKC

ChrisW.

Original Poster:

8,166 posts

286 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
On the Polo Bluemotion it's suggested that to replace it is a four hour job ...

The silly thing is that this equates to over 3000 miles of Diesel.

As such the proposed cost massively undermines the fuel savings ---

ezakimak

1,871 posts

267 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
ChrisW. said:
On the Polo Bluemotion it's suggested that to replace it is a four hour job ...

The silly thing is that this equates to over 3000 miles of Diesel.

As such the proposed cost massively undermines the fuel savings ---
how do you expect to get a fuel saveing by have a EGR valve working? not helping you with your original question, sorry.

ChrisW.

Original Poster:

8,166 posts

286 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
You are not understanding smile

I bought the car for it's cheap running and fuel economy.

The cost of this repair has single handedly depth charged my low running costs !

Actually my daughter and I both have these cars --- hers has just gone --- this time out of warranty, and the main dealer says it's a six hour job for them --- but VW may contribute the component --- which they say costs £250.

Their labour rate is £100 per hour ...

Hence my question, who else has had this ?

For us it is two out of two, both within a week of each other ...

SmithyAG

300 posts

159 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
EGR valve went on my A3 2.0TDI 140PD.

Part was £65 from andrew page. Fitted myself in about an hour. How accessible yours is will determine how many hours labour are required. Have you got an engine code so someone can look up the diagram for where it is?

mk1fan

10,919 posts

256 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
Cars out of warranty?

Delete the EGR including getting the ECU to ignore the resultant 'error code'.

Various ways of doing it. Darkside Developments do a kit with a replacement pipe and blanking plate. Alternatively, you can just block off the vacuum hose that controls the valve.


ChrisW.

Original Poster:

8,166 posts

286 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for that.

An indie has quoted three hours, no charge for the OPC diagnostics to be sure of the fault --- they will do this to check they are doing the right job, but still the best part of £400.

That's a lot of diesel at 60 mpg ... but Xmas has been saved.

Why should VW Carlisle quote 5+ hours ?

VW Leeds did mine in 4 ...

Nick1point9

3,920 posts

211 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
As far as I'm aware I've had no trouble with mine on my 100+k golf bluemotion (1.9 pd).

But, to be wholly honest, I have no idea what issues would point to EGR issues. Lots of people discuss them being problematic but for the life of me I don't think I've come across the symptoms that indicate a problem.

It must be said my golf gets an easy life, it does over 2k a month so it's usually roasting hot, it gets a fair mix of economy and pressing on and AFAIK it's done 1 DPF regen so maybe it will never have an EGR problem.

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Sunday 24th November 2013
quotequote all
Nick1point9 said:
As far as I'm aware I've had no trouble with mine on my 100+k golf bluemotion (1.9 pd).

But, to be wholly honest, I have no idea what issues would point to EGR issues. Lots of people discuss them being problematic but for the life of me I don't think I've come across the symptoms that indicate a problem.

It must be said my golf gets an easy life, it does over 2k a month so it's usually roasting hot, it gets a fair mix of economy and pressing on and AFAIK it's done 1 DPF regen so maybe it will never have an EGR problem.
EGR's "generally" fail because they get sludged up and can't move. Without re-starting the Diesel v Petrol. Looking inside a knackered EGR from a Diesel will have black oily sludge inside it. An equivalent Petrol will be far cleaner. Essentially it's because Diesels don't burn as cleanly as Petrol so there's more soot/oil going out the exhaust. (As you'll be aware because of the emisions) Or in this case back through the EGR system.

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Sunday 24th November 2013
quotequote all
There seems to be a correlation between failing EGRs and cars constantly used for short runs. Higher mileage cars mainly used for long journeys don't seem to suffer.

jagracer

8,248 posts

267 months

Sunday 24th November 2013
quotequote all
I've just spent the best part of three hours stripping and cleaning the egr and inlet pipe on a Clio DCi. It hasn't cured the problem I had but I'm surprised the car ran as the inlet pipe and egr block were nearly closed up with gunge. Luckily for me It's a 10 minute job to strip the egr and pipe off the car, cleaning them isn't so easy.