judgement of speed
Author
Discussion

Who me ?

Original Poster:

7,455 posts

243 months

Tuesday 12th November 2013
quotequote all
Come on then, BIB- has anything changed ( and no doubt el plonko of the depths will be along to try and scupper any decent opinions), on the persons judged fit to form an opinion of the speed of a vehicle.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
Not defined at law.

Would be a question of fact and degree for Mags to decide if raised.


dvd

agtlaw

7,443 posts

237 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
They go through police training - which gives them superhuman powers. E.g.



Tango13

10,203 posts

207 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
agtlaw said:
They go through police training - which gives them superhuman powers. E.g.

1551.5 feet = 472.8972 metres or just over 1/4 of a mile, yup that's superhuman powers.


JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
As above.

In my case, when I cross examined the officer, I asked how exactly he gains an evidential standard opinion of speed of a car nearly half a mile away, on a dead straight road going directly towards him.

It does seem superhuman, and the mags were happy to accept that.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
I was sceptical until I had a go and they are very easy to aim.

delboy735

1,656 posts

233 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
La Liga said:
I was sceptical until I had a go and they are very easy to aim.
I suspect that the OP was wondering how the officer has decided you are speeding prior to deployment of speed gun....I always thought that they had to suspect you of speeding prior to said deployment, however, it seems not. If you're on the road, you are fair game to them.

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
delboy735 said:
If you're on the road, you are fair game to them.
This is the reality. I suspect others will come along and suggest reference points, etc, etc. That might be the 'defence' that is swallowed whole in the name of 'Public Interest.'

To spot a car doing nearly double the limit in a 30 or iro 100 on a 70 is not that hard even at such a distance, but 33 in a 30 or 76 in a 70? Sorry, try the other, it has bells on it.

agtlaw

7,443 posts

237 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
Tango13 said:
1551.5 feet = 472.8972 metres or just over 1/4 of a mile, yup that's superhuman powers.
If you can accurately judge the speed of an oncoming car at 472 metres (5 football pitch lengths) then you've powers that I simply don't possess.

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

275 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
agtlaw said:
Tango13 said:
1551.5 feet = 472.8972 metres or just over 1/4 of a mile, yup that's superhuman powers.
If you can accurately judge the speed of an oncoming car at 472 metres (5 football pitch lengths) then you've powers that I simply don't possess.
{devil's advocate} They don't have to be accurate, merely sure that the victim is in excess of the prevailing limit. {/devil's advocate}

LocoCoco

1,433 posts

207 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
Einion Yrth said:
agtlaw said:
Tango13 said:
1551.5 feet = 472.8972 metres or just over 1/4 of a mile, yup that's superhuman powers.
If you can accurately judge the speed of an oncoming car at 472 metres (5 football pitch lengths) then you've powers that I simply don't possess.
{devil's advocate} They don't have to be accurate, merely sure that the victim is in excess of the prevailing limit. {/devil's advocate}
Also, the officer only needs to have the opinion that the car is speeding. As I've learnt on this forum, it is impossible for an opinion to be incorrect.

Tango13

10,203 posts

207 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
agtlaw said:
Tango13 said:
1551.5 feet = 472.8972 metres or just over 1/4 of a mile, yup that's superhuman powers.
If you can accurately judge the speed of an oncoming car at 472 metres (5 football pitch lengths) then you've powers that I simply don't possess.
The Police don't possess them either but the Magistrates have such a tenuous grip on reality that the Police can get away with it.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
delboy735 said:
La Liga said:
I was sceptical until I had a go and they are very easy to aim.
I suspect that the OP was wondering how the officer has decided you are speeding prior to deployment of speed gun....I always thought that they had to suspect you of speeding prior to said deployment, however, it seems not. If you're on the road, you are fair game to them.
I think you'd be surprised. We all have thousands of hours of experience of watching vehicles at various speeds relative to static surroundings and other moving vehicles. There's also the sound of tyre / road noise, the sound of the engine, rate of change of the revs, the way the car is moving etc that all give us little familiar sub-conscious indications that a vehicle is travelling at excess speed. Instinct is pattern recognition with quick feedback. Speeding vehicles fit into this very well.

I can't comment on the 400 metres scenario and the circumstances of that case, but I couldn't rule out forming the necessary prior opinion at 'any' distance when a vehicle can be seen.

GTIR

24,741 posts

297 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
Why do people whinge about what the police should and shouldn't do with regard to speed. It's always the ones who've been done and bang to rights that cry like babies.

Don't speed and you won't get nicked. Speed and take it like a man.

Simple.

agtlaw

7,443 posts

237 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
Einion Yrth said:
{devil's advocate} They don't have to be accurate, merely sure that the victim is in excess of the prevailing limit. {/devil's advocate}
How do they form an opinion that an oncoming vehicle speed is over, for example, 70 mph at 500 meters without being accurate?

The word 'victim' in this context is correct.

340600

611 posts

174 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
La Liga said:
I think you'd be surprised. We all have thousands of hours of experience of watching vehicles at various speeds relative to static surroundings and other moving vehicles. There's also the sound of tyre / road noise, the sound of the engine, rate of change of the revs, the way the car is moving etc that all give us little familiar sub-conscious indications that a vehicle is travelling at excess speed. Instinct is pattern recognition with quick feedback. Speeding vehicles fit into this very well.
Indeed. When I've been on speed enforcement with RPU officers they're usually able to estimate the speed of a vehicle to within 3-5mph and have it backed up by a calibrated device. Quite impressive/sad depending on which way you look at it.

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
GTIR said:
Why do people whinge about what the police should and shouldn't do with regard to speed. It's always the ones who've been done and bang to rights that cry like babies.

Don't speed and you won't get nicked. Speed and take it like a man.

Simple.
So what you are saying is that in order to secure a conviction it is unnecessary for the Police to follow the rules.

Yes, I also agree that if you are caught speeding and you know you are guilty of the offence you should suck it up subject to it being a true reflection of the offence you have committed, but if the officer who has reported you for the offence has committed breaches in obtaining evidence of this then the basis of the prosecution is flawed and should fail.

Without wishing to sound all tin foil about it if standards are allowed to slip here then where does it stop? Leaving people in prison long after they have served their sentence? Oh...

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
Rude-boy said:
So what you are saying is that in order to secure a conviction it is unnecessary for the Police to follow the rules.

Yes, I also agree that if you are caught speeding and you know you are guilty of the offence you should suck it up subject to it being a true reflection of the offence you have committed, but if the officer who has reported you for the offence has committed breaches in obtaining evidence of this then the basis of the prosecution is flawed and should fail.

Without wishing to sound all tin foil about it if standards are allowed to slip here then where does it stop? Leaving people in prison long after they have served their sentence? Oh...
Yes this is exactly the same as leaving someone in prison too long isn't it...

This whole topic is a perfect example of trying to find a loophole in speeding enforcement, or at least that's how it comes across.

Other than trying to find a defence against being caught speeding I really don't see the value in this kind of discussion.



Toltec

7,179 posts

254 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
There is a fairly simple way to see how good they are at telling if a vehicle is speeding.

Every activation of the gun is logged, ideally without the user knowing. It will be quite obvious if the user is good at estimating speed before activating the equipment.


Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
Yes this is exactly the same as leaving someone in prison too long isn't it...
Okay, please then tell me what rules and legislation it is acceptable for a Police Officer to break in the commission of their duties? How serious does the offence the accused is alleged to have committed or suspected to have committed, have to be before the Police have to start to ensure that they are within the law themselves?

Devil2575 said:
This whole topic is a perfect example of trying to find a loophole in speeding enforcement, or at least that's how it comes across.

Other than trying to find a defence against being caught speeding I really don't see the value in this kind of discussion.
I've already gone on record on this thread as saying that if you are guilty and have committed the offence you should hold you hands up if caught - Don't do the crime if you can't do the time. It is more worrying that the only reason a some of these people who have been found guilty is on the basis of flawed investigations.

"Oh but it is only speeding and they were guilty anyway" may be true in your mind but as above, where does one draw the line? When a possible custodial sentence is on the cards or before?

I know that you do not like to see people caught speeding get away with it on a technicality, but I also dislike seeing rapists and murderers get off on such technicalities. Perhaps we should ignore breaches there as well? “Yes, yes I see it now, murder and rape are [i]just[i/] like speeding” I can hear you type. Well actually you are right, they are. Those cases should also fail if the evidence was obtained illegally and if you don’t stop the rot where it first appears it does spread.


Edit for format.





Edited by Rude-boy on Wednesday 13th November 13:52