Is this legal?
Discussion
I have comprehensive insurance on my own vehicle, which also gives me 3rd party cover on other vehicles (see policy wording below).
I want to use a friend’s car over the winter but that vehicle won’t be insured as they have transferred their insurance on to their new car.
I’ve read through my policy wording several times and cant see anything excluding it.
The car is taxed but wont have vehicle specific insurance is it legal to have a car taxed and not insured as a primary vehicle and does my insurance cover me?
Policy Wording;
The policyholder may also drive any private motor car not owned or hired to him/her under a hire purchase or lease agreement.
Driving other cars cover (Section C)
Only applies if shown on your Certificate of Motor Insurance (under “Persons or classes of person entitled to drive”). If it applies, this gives third party only cover, for you only, to drive other cars (not belonging to you). Cover only applies in the UK, the Isle of Man and the Channel Islands and you must have the owners permission to drive their car. Other limitations apply to this benefit.
Driving other cars cover may not be used to obtain the release of vehicles impounded by the police/authorities.
Driving Other Cars
We will provide cover under this section (but only if stated in your Certificate of Motor Insurance) while you are driving with the owner’s consent, any private motor car which is not owned by you or hired to you under a hire purchase agreement, provided that you are not covered by any other insurance and the car you are driving is in a roadworthy condition.
Driving Other Cars cover cannot be used to obtain the release of cars which have been seized by, or on behalf of, any government or public authority.
Additionally Driving Other Cars cover will not operate:
• if the policy is issued in the name of a company or firm; or
• if the insured vehicle is sold or disposed of, or declared a total loss; or
• if the car you are driving is owned by or provided by an employer or business partner; or
• outside the geographical limits of this policy.
Exceptions to Section C
What is not covered?
We shall not be liable:
• If the person claiming is otherwise;insured; or
• For loss or damage to property belonging to or in the care of any person insured under this section or for not being able to use any such property; or
• For damage to the insured vehicle or property in it or being conveyed in it or for not being able to use any such property; or
• For loss or damage to any trailer or caravan being towed by the insured vehicle or for not being able to use any such trailer or caravan; or
• if the death of or bodily injury to any person covered under this section arises out of or in the course of his/her employment except where such liability must be covered under the Road Traffic Acts; or
• for death or bodily injury to any person being carried in or on any trailer or caravan; or
• if a person who was not driving makes a claim and he/she knew that the person driving did not hold a valid driving licence.
I want to use a friend’s car over the winter but that vehicle won’t be insured as they have transferred their insurance on to their new car.
I’ve read through my policy wording several times and cant see anything excluding it.
The car is taxed but wont have vehicle specific insurance is it legal to have a car taxed and not insured as a primary vehicle and does my insurance cover me?
Policy Wording;
The policyholder may also drive any private motor car not owned or hired to him/her under a hire purchase or lease agreement.
Driving other cars cover (Section C)
Only applies if shown on your Certificate of Motor Insurance (under “Persons or classes of person entitled to drive”). If it applies, this gives third party only cover, for you only, to drive other cars (not belonging to you). Cover only applies in the UK, the Isle of Man and the Channel Islands and you must have the owners permission to drive their car. Other limitations apply to this benefit.
Driving other cars cover may not be used to obtain the release of vehicles impounded by the police/authorities.
Driving Other Cars
We will provide cover under this section (but only if stated in your Certificate of Motor Insurance) while you are driving with the owner’s consent, any private motor car which is not owned by you or hired to you under a hire purchase agreement, provided that you are not covered by any other insurance and the car you are driving is in a roadworthy condition.
Driving Other Cars cover cannot be used to obtain the release of cars which have been seized by, or on behalf of, any government or public authority.
Additionally Driving Other Cars cover will not operate:
• if the policy is issued in the name of a company or firm; or
• if the insured vehicle is sold or disposed of, or declared a total loss; or
• if the car you are driving is owned by or provided by an employer or business partner; or
• outside the geographical limits of this policy.
Exceptions to Section C
What is not covered?
We shall not be liable:
• If the person claiming is otherwise;insured; or
• For loss or damage to property belonging to or in the care of any person insured under this section or for not being able to use any such property; or
• For damage to the insured vehicle or property in it or being conveyed in it or for not being able to use any such property; or
• For loss or damage to any trailer or caravan being towed by the insured vehicle or for not being able to use any such trailer or caravan; or
• if the death of or bodily injury to any person covered under this section arises out of or in the course of his/her employment except where such liability must be covered under the Road Traffic Acts; or
• for death or bodily injury to any person being carried in or on any trailer or caravan; or
• if a person who was not driving makes a claim and he/she knew that the person driving did not hold a valid driving licence.
The wording of your policy is irrelevant. Under the CIE rules
"As part of Continuous Insurance Enforcement (CIE) it is a legal offence to keep a vehicle without insurance unless you have notified DVLA that your vehicle is being kept off the road by means of a Statutory Off Road Notice (SORN)". (my bold)
http://www.mib.org.uk/Motor+Insurance+Database/en/...
If it's on the road it must be insured by the keeper
Therefore the question of whether or not you can drive other cars without the keeper insuring it is already answered, it cannot be on the road unless the keeper insures it.
"As part of Continuous Insurance Enforcement (CIE) it is a legal offence to keep a vehicle without insurance unless you have notified DVLA that your vehicle is being kept off the road by means of a Statutory Off Road Notice (SORN)". (my bold)
http://www.mib.org.uk/Motor+Insurance+Database/en/...
If it's on the road it must be insured by the keeper
Therefore the question of whether or not you can drive other cars without the keeper insuring it is already answered, it cannot be on the road unless the keeper insures it.
karona said:
The wording of your policy is irrelevant. Under the CIE rules
"As part of Continuous Insurance Enforcement (CIE) it is a legal offence to keep a vehicle without insurance unless you have notified DVLA that your vehicle is being kept off the road by means of a Statutory Off Road Notice (SORN)". (my bold)
http://www.mib.org.uk/Motor+Insurance+Database/en/...
If it's on the road it must be insured by the keeper
Therefore the question of whether or not you can drive other cars without the keeper insuring it is already answered, it cannot be on the road unless the keeper insures it.
But the OP could legally drive it under his own policy via the driving other cars extension as it's only the owner who commits and offence"As part of Continuous Insurance Enforcement (CIE) it is a legal offence to keep a vehicle without insurance unless you have notified DVLA that your vehicle is being kept off the road by means of a Statutory Off Road Notice (SORN)". (my bold)
http://www.mib.org.uk/Motor+Insurance+Database/en/...
If it's on the road it must be insured by the keeper
Therefore the question of whether or not you can drive other cars without the keeper insuring it is already answered, it cannot be on the road unless the keeper insures it.
dacouch said:
karona said:
The wording of your policy is irrelevant. Under the CIE rules
"As part of Continuous Insurance Enforcement (CIE) it is a legal offence to keep a vehicle without insurance unless you have notified DVLA that your vehicle is being kept off the road by means of a Statutory Off Road Notice (SORN)". (my bold)
http://www.mib.org.uk/Motor+Insurance+Database/en/...
If it's on the road it must be insured by the keeper
Therefore the question of whether or not you can drive other cars without the keeper insuring it is already answered, it cannot be on the road unless the keeper insures it.
But the OP could legally drive it under his own policy via the driving other cars extension as it's only the owner who commits and offence"As part of Continuous Insurance Enforcement (CIE) it is a legal offence to keep a vehicle without insurance unless you have notified DVLA that your vehicle is being kept off the road by means of a Statutory Off Road Notice (SORN)". (my bold)
http://www.mib.org.uk/Motor+Insurance+Database/en/...
If it's on the road it must be insured by the keeper
Therefore the question of whether or not you can drive other cars without the keeper insuring it is already answered, it cannot be on the road unless the keeper insures it.
Nigel Worc's said:
You absolutely need to ask your insurers, not us.
Different companies have very different rules regarding this, if you are unsure of anything to do with your policy, please ask them.
And the rules are set out in the policy documentation and (at least from the parts posted) don't require the other car to have an insurance policy in place.Different companies have very different rules regarding this, if you are unsure of anything to do with your policy, please ask them.
Remember, whether or not you're insured is a question of what your insurance contract says - not on what a bloke in your insurer's call centre thinks it says.
I would check with the DOC Insurers and get their authority one way or the other.
As I understand it Badger owns a car and insures it. The Insurance lapses so he SORNs it.
Mole has Insurance for his own car which contains the DOC clause. It is OK with Badge if Mole drives the badgermobile so Mole does so covered by the DOC clause on his own Insurance.
Legal.
(Remember you can use a SORNED untaxed car to go to Test)
Now the bit I suspect the DOC Insurers will not like is the continuous use by Mole of Badger's car. As I understand it the DOC is virtualy to cover emergency not continuous use as it could cover use of two cars which is why I suggest contact with Insurers.
If Mole does use Badger's car and stops to get a paper or go shopping, some will say car not covered parked on a road during his absence. Not so for I understand that there is a stated case somewhere that Mole stays the driver until journey completed and hence covered under DOC.
Toad does not feature in this at all as he is still disqualified.
(apologies to that Wind in Willows chappie)
dvd
As I understand it Badger owns a car and insures it. The Insurance lapses so he SORNs it.
Mole has Insurance for his own car which contains the DOC clause. It is OK with Badge if Mole drives the badgermobile so Mole does so covered by the DOC clause on his own Insurance.
Legal.
(Remember you can use a SORNED untaxed car to go to Test)
Now the bit I suspect the DOC Insurers will not like is the continuous use by Mole of Badger's car. As I understand it the DOC is virtualy to cover emergency not continuous use as it could cover use of two cars which is why I suggest contact with Insurers.
If Mole does use Badger's car and stops to get a paper or go shopping, some will say car not covered parked on a road during his absence. Not so for I understand that there is a stated case somewhere that Mole stays the driver until journey completed and hence covered under DOC.
Toad does not feature in this at all as he is still disqualified.
(apologies to that Wind in Willows chappie)
dvd
dacouch said:
But the OP could legally drive it under his own policy via the driving other cars extension as it's only the owner who commits and offence
It is an absolute offense for that car to be on the road, whoever is driving it, unless the keeper has insured it.The offense is keeping an uninsured, unsorned vehicle.
1 said:
Thanks for the replies. Seems ridiculous that you can't keep a taxed but uninsured car even if it's not on the road.
It is. Subject to the car in question though i would have said for the IP of £200ish it is money well spent to avoid any issues. (£200 on basis of £600 for policy, cancel after 3 months and allow a little for charges/round the month up/etc)Dwight VanDriver said:
Now the bit I suspect the DOC Insurers will not like is the continuous use by Mole of Badger's car. As I understand it the DOC is virtually to cover emergency not continuous use as it could cover use of two cars which is why I suggest contact with Insurers.
The intention may well have been that DOC would be used in emergencies, but that's not a condition of the cover, at least not on any policy I've ever seen. The insurers might not like the idea of Mole driving Badger's car on a regular basis, but they've agreed that he can do it, unless there's actually clause in the policy restricting it to emergency or occasional use only. And if there was, it would have to use terms a lot more precise than "emergency" or "occasional".Dwight VanDriver said:
Now the bit I suspect the DOC Insurers will not like is the continuous use by Mole of Badger's car. As I understand it the DOC is virtualy to cover emergency not continuous use as it could cover use of two cars which is why I suggest contact with Insurers.
Although I get what you mean fully here, the definition of 'continuous' is just to vague. Is this 2 days or a week whilst Moles car is off road for repair and Badger as a good mate lends him his car. Is it 2 weeks because Mole is taking Mrs Mole and the Mole pups on holiday and Badger lends them his 4x4 (they have a lot of luggage) etc.Dwight VanDriver said:
Toad does not feature in this at all as he is still disqualified.
Did he get grassed up by Rat - remember this is PH and no-one likes a grass (Willows and Rushes are OK though)Also if using DOC it would be wise to carry a copy of the insurance docs with you as the car will/might flag up as uninsured on ANPR - see the current thread on 'Police Impounded Car' under similar circumstances
over_the_hill said:
Also if using DOC it would be wise to carry a copy of the insurance docs with you as the car will/might flag up as uninsured on ANPR - see the current thread on 'Police Impounded Car' under similar circumstances
Unless the car is insured by the keeper he might as well be carrying a signed letter from the Queen. The keeper is committing the offense of being the keeper of an uninsured vehicle on the road, regardless of what the borrower's insurance documents say. The Continuous Insurance Enforcement regulations say insure it or SORN it, so if it's not insured by the keeper ANPR will flag it as uninsured, and the borrower's documents are irrelevant, he will just watch helplessly as it gets towed away.
In case you don't believe the MIB site I quoted up thread, here's the Gov.uk site. It cannot get any clearer:
https://www.gov.uk/vehicle-insurance/uninsured-veh...
4. Uninsured vehicles
Rules in England, Wales and Scotland
The rules for insuring vehicles are called ‘continuous insurance enforcement’. They mean that if you’re the registered keeper of a vehicle it must be insured or declared as off the road (SORN).
If not, you could:
get a fixed penalty of £100
have your vehicle wheel-clamped, impounded or destroyed
face a court prosecution, with a possible maximum fine of £1,000
It doesn’t matter who is driving the car - if you’re the registered keeper, you could get penalised.
You will also still have to pay for your insurance on top of any fines received.
Edited by karona on Thursday 14th November 10:56
Dwight VanDriver said:
If Mole does use Badger's car and stops to get a paper or go shopping, some will say car not covered parked on a road during his absence. Not so for I understand that there is a stated case somewhere that Mole stays the driver until journey completed and hence covered under DOC.
I think that would be Secretary of State for Transport v. Richards (1998) JP 682 QBD.Although Richards was done for no tax rather than no insurance.
karona said:
over_the_hill said:
Also if using DOC it would be wise to carry a copy of the insurance docs with you as the car will/might flag up as uninsured on ANPR - see the current thread on 'Police Impounded Car' under similar circumstances
Unless the car is insured by the keeper he might as well be carrying a signed letter from the Queen. The keeper is committing the offense of being the keeper of an uninsured vehicle on the road, regardless of what the borrower's insurance documents say. The Continuous Insurance Enforcement regulations say insure it or SORN it, so if it's not insured by the keeper ANPR will flag it as uninsured, and the borrower's documents are irrelevant, he will just watch helplessly as it gets towed away.
In case you don't believe the MIB site I quoted up thread, here's the Gov.uk site. It cannot get any clearer:
https://www.gov.uk/vehicle-insurance/uninsured-veh...
4. Uninsured vehicles
Rules in England, Wales and Scotland
The rules for insuring vehicles are called ‘continuous insurance enforcement’. They mean that if you’re the registered keeper of a vehicle it must be insured or declared as off the road (SORN).
If not, you could:
get a fixed penalty of £100
have your vehicle wheel-clamped, impounded or destroyed
face a court prosecution, with a possible maximum fine of £1,000
It doesn’t matter who is driving the car - if you’re the registered keeper, you could get penalised.
You will also still have to pay for your insurance on top of any fines received.
There are two distinct separate offences here. CIE relates to the keeper. The issue for the OP is whether as the driver he is committing an offence under RTA s143. The RK and the driver are different people which is where things get messy.
Neither the MIB site nor Gov.uk are law. The latter site in particular is notorious for giving incomplete and misleading statements especially on motoring issues. It is what Acts and Statutory Instruments say that matter and those are interpreted by the courts.
AFAIK the Pryor case is definitive re s143. CIE has simply muddied the waters. I suspect this is why some (but by no means all) insurers add a clause to their DOC cover which requires the vehicle to have its own current policy in force. The fact that not all do suggests to me that the lower courts are still bound by the Pryor judgement.
My reading of it is that the RK might have a case to answer under CIE but not the driver under s143. I reckon the police would need to think twice before proceeding to seize the vehicle.
Red Devil said:
My reading of it is that the RK might have a case to answer under CIE but not the driver under s143.
You're correct. Also, enforcement of CIE is generally done by the DVLA, not by the police. The law does indeed make provision for an untaxed, unsorned, vehicle to be clamped or seized, this can only be done by someone authorised by the Secretary of State (ie the DVLA - linky). Are police officers even authorised for this purpose? If they're not, they'd have no power to seize a vehicle driven by someone with appropriate DOC cover, even if the vehicle itself was uninsured.Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


