Business rates lowered but future savings % paid to firm!?!?
Discussion
Bit of an odd question here but thought I'd ask as you never know who browses these forums!
Stiles Harold Williams helped us get a reduction in our business rates and refund from the local council for our past overpayment which was a good 6 figure sum. Stiles Harold Williams took a good 25% commission of this figure for the pleasure of doing so.
At the time this was happening, the whole of our town were using numerous different companies to do the same thing as it seems we were all being heavily overcharged business rates in all hotels.
What we didnt realise (although apparantly paperwork was signed with small print detailing this - havent had a chance to look over this with a magnifying glass myself yet as my father signed it in good faith) that all our FUTURE SAVINGS must be paid quaterly to Stiles Harold Williams also!?
So for example... Business rates for a hotel is £20,000 per year.
Have been paying this rate for 5 years.
Stiles Harold Williams get reduction to £12,000 and business gets refunded by local council £40,000 (5 years x £8000 overpayments).
Stiles Harold Williams takes 25% of said £40,000 so £10,000 ...
Business rates for future years now £12,000 however £2,000 (which is 25% of the savings) must continue to be paid to Stiles Harold Williams for next 10 years!?!
Does this sound right??
Has anyone had remote experiences like this?
Figures I've used above are not accurate and just an example but surely the future savings things is grossly unfair? Especially when very few if any other business rates savings companies impose such a thing?
Stiles Harold Williams helped us get a reduction in our business rates and refund from the local council for our past overpayment which was a good 6 figure sum. Stiles Harold Williams took a good 25% commission of this figure for the pleasure of doing so.
At the time this was happening, the whole of our town were using numerous different companies to do the same thing as it seems we were all being heavily overcharged business rates in all hotels.
What we didnt realise (although apparantly paperwork was signed with small print detailing this - havent had a chance to look over this with a magnifying glass myself yet as my father signed it in good faith) that all our FUTURE SAVINGS must be paid quaterly to Stiles Harold Williams also!?
So for example... Business rates for a hotel is £20,000 per year.
Have been paying this rate for 5 years.
Stiles Harold Williams get reduction to £12,000 and business gets refunded by local council £40,000 (5 years x £8000 overpayments).
Stiles Harold Williams takes 25% of said £40,000 so £10,000 ...
Business rates for future years now £12,000 however £2,000 (which is 25% of the savings) must continue to be paid to Stiles Harold Williams for next 10 years!?!
Does this sound right??
Has anyone had remote experiences like this?
Figures I've used above are not accurate and just an example but surely the future savings things is grossly unfair? Especially when very few if any other business rates savings companies impose such a thing?
sumo69 said:
I am sure you know the answer - what was in the contract you or your father signed?
Trying to be sympathetic but who in business doesn't review a contract before signing?
David
You equally signed somewhere along the line for Payment Protection Insurance for a credit card, insurance or overdraft you may have had... and I'm sure you equally also im sure enjoyed a refund from the Bank at some point so signing or not if its unreasonable, unclear, uncommon practise - there is always a way around or to argue against. In my (quite large) hotel circle of contacts no one else is in this predicament!Trying to be sympathetic but who in business doesn't review a contract before signing?
David
The contracts that I used to see when I worked in the Rating department of a large national practice usually were a % of savings over the life of the list.
The life of the list was then five years. We would not have looked to include anything further than that (in the way suggested), and I don't think any of our competitors would have either.
The government have of course postponed the reval to 2017, and I've got no idea how firms have dealt with that as it's extended the life of the list.
Read the contract would be a start, but I'm not convinced that someone has not got confused. SHW are not one of the cowboys, as far as I am aware.
The life of the list was then five years. We would not have looked to include anything further than that (in the way suggested), and I don't think any of our competitors would have either.
The government have of course postponed the reval to 2017, and I've got no idea how firms have dealt with that as it's extended the life of the list.
Read the contract would be a start, but I'm not convinced that someone has not got confused. SHW are not one of the cowboys, as far as I am aware.
Gulzar said:
You equally signed somewhere along the line for Payment Protection Insurance for a credit card, insurance or overdraft you may have had... and I'm sure you equally also im sure enjoyed a refund from the Bank at some point so signing or not if its unreasonable, unclear, uncommon practise - there is always a way around or to argue against.
Fair logic but the difference is that PPI miselling has been outlawed, and your situation has not. I suppose you can put up a fight and withold payment and see how ugly they get. You could gamble a thousand or two on a solicitor and see...Ultimately if someone had said 'I can save you £6,000 a year' you'd have been very happy...
Share of future savings is entirely normal practice and as far as I've gome across it's as stated above normally to the next list date which is now 2017. 10 years if correct does seem abnormally long. Are you sure the 10 years isn't the backdated period plus the future period = 10 years?
Gulzar said:
You equally signed somewhere along the line for Payment Protection Insurance for a credit card, insurance or overdraft you may have had... and I'm sure you equally also im sure enjoyed a refund from the Bank at some point so signing or not if its unreasonable, unclear, uncommon practise - there is always a way around or to argue against. In my (quite large) hotel circle of contacts no one else is in this predicament!
Actually no PPI refund for me as I never paid any - I checked the smallprint first before signing 
David
surveyor said:
The contracts that I used to see when I worked in the Rating department of a large national practice usually were a % of savings over the life of the list.
The life of the list was then five years. We would not have looked to include anything further than that (in the way suggested), and I don't think any of our competitors would have either.
The government have of course postponed the reval to 2017, and I've got no idea how firms have dealt with that as it's extended the life of the list.
Read the contract would be a start, but I'm not convinced that someone has not got confused. SHW are not one of the cowboys, as far as I am aware.
Yes sounds to me as if something has gone wrong in the translation somewhere. Stiles Harold Williams are NOT a cowboy oufit.The life of the list was then five years. We would not have looked to include anything further than that (in the way suggested), and I don't think any of our competitors would have either.
The government have of course postponed the reval to 2017, and I've got no idea how firms have dealt with that as it's extended the life of the list.
Read the contract would be a start, but I'm not convinced that someone has not got confused. SHW are not one of the cowboys, as far as I am aware.
Most firms will work on a percentage of the savings in rates payable over the life of a revaluation. It is worth checking what your contract says as a number of firms will have said for 2010-2015 and then get caught out when the revaluation date changed to 2017 but not sure how relevant that is in this case.
What we do is we calculate what the projected saving is until 2017 and bill on that basis. So we just issue a one off invoice. I have heard rumours that one company having billed clients on an estimated saving to 2015 has now issued invoices for the additional savings from the revaluation being postpned to 2017. Not something I am doing.
I suspect what has happened is that the OP signed up for SHW to act for both the 2005 and 2010 lists. They have got a reduction on the 2005 List which has generated a fee based on 25% (or whatever) of the saving. That reduction has in turn lead to a consequential reduction on the 2010 list because the facts used to determine the assessment were incorrect and they have therefore billed you for a percentage reduction of the saving from 2010 to 2017.
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


