Help needed, legal advice on car repair post sale
Discussion
Hi there guys after a small bit of advice with an impending court case.
I buy and sell cars for a living from a smallish unit. I sold a car one sunday morning and took in a part exchange (a 55 reg Jaguar s type)for the sum of £6000. I was due to meet up with some relatives (my mums cousin) that day and as the guy left this Jaguar 3/4 full with diesel i decided i may aswell use it.
Upon arrival at my families, my Mums cousin, who ill refer to as Mr C, looked out of the window and discussed with me how much he loved the S type and had always wanted one. I was going out for a few drinks with his daughter and a few friends, so i flicked him the key and said if his insurance covered it he was welcome to have a spin in it.
The next morning he asked if he could buy it off me, i explained i'd taken it in as a part exchange and that he could have it at my purchase cost £6000 which was way below any sort of retail value. I have glasses guide from April 2012 (the date he took it) showing retail at £7825. It was slightly above trade but it was an immaculate example (i have pics) and had lots of options. Mileage was 85000.
He ended up picking the car up a week later as he sorted funds. Paid me on his debit card over the phone on the 18th April 2012 for ease of use but no invoice given. He collected on the 21st of April 2012.
Had a text message on the 24th telling me he was enjoying the car. All evidence referred to i have kept evidence inc txts.
He did advise me a week later that the engine management light came on after he had filled it with diesel. I offered for him to stop by and id plug it into diagnostic FOC. He let me know it had gone out and not reappeared. This was never mentioned again in the other couple of visits i made across the next 2 months.
On the 9th August at 22.30 i received a call from Mr C telling me he was being towed home by the RAC as the engine started to make a noise and the RAC had said the bottom end was 'knocking'.
The car was delivered to Owner at an Independent garage. At this stage I thought my family were just after my help rather than financial assistance. They never spoke about any financial thing at this stage. I had this confirmed by 2 of Mr C'S COUSINS (ONE MY MOTHER)
I loaned him a cheap px car so he could get to work and back (a 53 reg mg zt £1200 value) At this point, just incase i txt saying i was loaning the MG FOC but he would be liable for any damage or breakages and he must sort his own suitable insurance to which he replied ok. (have txt messages still)
Owner-Guy who owns independant garage (not inserting names)
I spoke to Owner at the Independant who informed me the car ran and drove albeit the bottom end was knocking. He did inform me that the driver from RAC had left the vehicle running on the truck for at least 10mins while he removed others first. This could have had a further detrimental effect to the engine. The car sat at the independent for quite a while despite having spoken to Owner who said he was going to remove the head and have a look at the bottom end to see what the issue may be. Obviously without looking there was no way of knowing the extent of the damage. He also informed me that Mr C had been continually driving the vehicle with a fault. The car had been overboosting. He had been meaning to take it to Owner but never got the time and had been turning the car on and off to try trick the car into thinking there was no fault. This had been ignored and continued to run doing 600miles a week on his trip to and from work(he works over 200 miles away)! He also informed me it had overgone a scheduled service.
For some reason the car was then moved to another garage unbeknownst to me called Jag Specialist on 24th August (name undisclosed but were a Jag Specialist). Once it arrived here it apparently didn’t run at all. I spoke to The Owner Of Jag specialist who told me the engine needed to be replaced with a brand new item and wern't interested in stripping the engine to find a fault and they had informed Mr C that a brand new engine was the best move forward, to which I disagreed due to the cost. They then started some work on a problem with the transmission as they told me they couldn’t get it into the workshop as they couldn’t select neutral. However the car must have selected neutral when it arrived with them as they rolled it off the truck from Owner at Independent. This is a further expense added to the bill.
On the 5th September i had a rude and aggressive phone call from Mr C's wife, Mrs C, who demanded that i pay for the fit of a new engine and acossiated parts at a cost of £6000. I explained that i had done them a great favour in selling them a car at a vastly reduced cost, that they had the car 3.5 months and also travelled a distance of 10256 miles in the vehicle prior to failure. (about 12 months of average miles!) I advised that they would be best stripping the engine as this would be the cheapest option but as the Jag specialist said it was a bad idea and a new lump was the way froward they refused. I left it there. They had the car fixed and sent me a bill for just over £6200.
On the 7th September i got a call after midnight to tell me the MG was on its way back to me on the back of an RAC wagon, which i had to meet at 3am. Sure enough the engine had gone so badly that the as you filled the radiator, water literally poured out of the exhaust and inlet manifolds! They refused to accept any liability from it, not even saying they would reduce that from there £6200 bill. I ended up selling the vehicle as is for £400 as it wasn't viable to fix. Engines were £300, approx £400 to switch them in labour plus other costs like new oil etc.
They ended up taking me to small claims court over the above matter. They did however reduce their claim to £5000 so we would be liable for our own costs only. I believe. I have a letter stating a court hearing of 13th December.
Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks
I buy and sell cars for a living from a smallish unit. I sold a car one sunday morning and took in a part exchange (a 55 reg Jaguar s type)for the sum of £6000. I was due to meet up with some relatives (my mums cousin) that day and as the guy left this Jaguar 3/4 full with diesel i decided i may aswell use it.
Upon arrival at my families, my Mums cousin, who ill refer to as Mr C, looked out of the window and discussed with me how much he loved the S type and had always wanted one. I was going out for a few drinks with his daughter and a few friends, so i flicked him the key and said if his insurance covered it he was welcome to have a spin in it.
The next morning he asked if he could buy it off me, i explained i'd taken it in as a part exchange and that he could have it at my purchase cost £6000 which was way below any sort of retail value. I have glasses guide from April 2012 (the date he took it) showing retail at £7825. It was slightly above trade but it was an immaculate example (i have pics) and had lots of options. Mileage was 85000.
He ended up picking the car up a week later as he sorted funds. Paid me on his debit card over the phone on the 18th April 2012 for ease of use but no invoice given. He collected on the 21st of April 2012.
Had a text message on the 24th telling me he was enjoying the car. All evidence referred to i have kept evidence inc txts.
He did advise me a week later that the engine management light came on after he had filled it with diesel. I offered for him to stop by and id plug it into diagnostic FOC. He let me know it had gone out and not reappeared. This was never mentioned again in the other couple of visits i made across the next 2 months.
On the 9th August at 22.30 i received a call from Mr C telling me he was being towed home by the RAC as the engine started to make a noise and the RAC had said the bottom end was 'knocking'.
The car was delivered to Owner at an Independent garage. At this stage I thought my family were just after my help rather than financial assistance. They never spoke about any financial thing at this stage. I had this confirmed by 2 of Mr C'S COUSINS (ONE MY MOTHER)
I loaned him a cheap px car so he could get to work and back (a 53 reg mg zt £1200 value) At this point, just incase i txt saying i was loaning the MG FOC but he would be liable for any damage or breakages and he must sort his own suitable insurance to which he replied ok. (have txt messages still)
Owner-Guy who owns independant garage (not inserting names)
I spoke to Owner at the Independant who informed me the car ran and drove albeit the bottom end was knocking. He did inform me that the driver from RAC had left the vehicle running on the truck for at least 10mins while he removed others first. This could have had a further detrimental effect to the engine. The car sat at the independent for quite a while despite having spoken to Owner who said he was going to remove the head and have a look at the bottom end to see what the issue may be. Obviously without looking there was no way of knowing the extent of the damage. He also informed me that Mr C had been continually driving the vehicle with a fault. The car had been overboosting. He had been meaning to take it to Owner but never got the time and had been turning the car on and off to try trick the car into thinking there was no fault. This had been ignored and continued to run doing 600miles a week on his trip to and from work(he works over 200 miles away)! He also informed me it had overgone a scheduled service.
For some reason the car was then moved to another garage unbeknownst to me called Jag Specialist on 24th August (name undisclosed but were a Jag Specialist). Once it arrived here it apparently didn’t run at all. I spoke to The Owner Of Jag specialist who told me the engine needed to be replaced with a brand new item and wern't interested in stripping the engine to find a fault and they had informed Mr C that a brand new engine was the best move forward, to which I disagreed due to the cost. They then started some work on a problem with the transmission as they told me they couldn’t get it into the workshop as they couldn’t select neutral. However the car must have selected neutral when it arrived with them as they rolled it off the truck from Owner at Independent. This is a further expense added to the bill.
On the 5th September i had a rude and aggressive phone call from Mr C's wife, Mrs C, who demanded that i pay for the fit of a new engine and acossiated parts at a cost of £6000. I explained that i had done them a great favour in selling them a car at a vastly reduced cost, that they had the car 3.5 months and also travelled a distance of 10256 miles in the vehicle prior to failure. (about 12 months of average miles!) I advised that they would be best stripping the engine as this would be the cheapest option but as the Jag specialist said it was a bad idea and a new lump was the way froward they refused. I left it there. They had the car fixed and sent me a bill for just over £6200.
On the 7th September i got a call after midnight to tell me the MG was on its way back to me on the back of an RAC wagon, which i had to meet at 3am. Sure enough the engine had gone so badly that the as you filled the radiator, water literally poured out of the exhaust and inlet manifolds! They refused to accept any liability from it, not even saying they would reduce that from there £6200 bill. I ended up selling the vehicle as is for £400 as it wasn't viable to fix. Engines were £300, approx £400 to switch them in labour plus other costs like new oil etc.
They ended up taking me to small claims court over the above matter. They did however reduce their claim to £5000 so we would be liable for our own costs only. I believe. I have a letter stating a court hearing of 13th December.
Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks
Blimey what a mess. So they broke the MG as well?
As a trader you are required to sell cars fit for purpose, and you would normally expect a car to last for more than 3.5 months before breaking so badly.
On the other side, two other garages dabbled with it before you had a chance to fix it. That is not the right way of doing things. Neither can they just get someone else to fix it and send you the bill (Sale of Goods Act). You must be given the opportunity to fix the car first. Because they have done things in the wrong order you could use this as part of your defence and get away with it. It seems you have acted in a fair and reasonable manner and have evidence to prove it. Therefore I think you might win IF you keep calm and don't let them wind you up. No doubt they will make up plenty of lies about how horrible you were; don't let this rattle you - courts only want proveable facts and will ignore unevidenced bluster.
The counter claim is of course your MG which they broke - why not sue them for the value of it? Then perhaps they will wind their necks in.
As a trader you are required to sell cars fit for purpose, and you would normally expect a car to last for more than 3.5 months before breaking so badly.
On the other side, two other garages dabbled with it before you had a chance to fix it. That is not the right way of doing things. Neither can they just get someone else to fix it and send you the bill (Sale of Goods Act). You must be given the opportunity to fix the car first. Because they have done things in the wrong order you could use this as part of your defence and get away with it. It seems you have acted in a fair and reasonable manner and have evidence to prove it. Therefore I think you might win IF you keep calm and don't let them wind you up. No doubt they will make up plenty of lies about how horrible you were; don't let this rattle you - courts only want proveable facts and will ignore unevidenced bluster.
The counter claim is of course your MG which they broke - why not sue them for the value of it? Then perhaps they will wind their necks in.
Yup they broke the mg aswell and i have counterclaimed for this. I know 3.5 months may not seem a long time but they have done over 10,000 miles. As much as expected from someone in a year. Does that not count for anything?
My thoughts are the following and unsure which gives me good leverage.
They used it for 10k miles
They used it with a fault they turned a blind eye to which could have contributed or even caused the failure
The rac left it running which may have caused further damage
They refused to strip the engine to see the fault therefore i couldn't deem whether it was like that at time of sale
They got the car at trade money
They missed a service
If it wasn't possible to 'win' then mitigating it under above but aswell as
They didn't mitigate their loses by spending more than the cars value on a repair. A bottom end could have been repaired for 1k.
Further things were asked for within the bill, new cambelt etc, other things broken after it went to first garage
My thoughts are the following and unsure which gives me good leverage.
They used it for 10k miles
They used it with a fault they turned a blind eye to which could have contributed or even caused the failure
The rac left it running which may have caused further damage
They refused to strip the engine to see the fault therefore i couldn't deem whether it was like that at time of sale
They got the car at trade money
They missed a service
If it wasn't possible to 'win' then mitigating it under above but aswell as
They didn't mitigate their loses by spending more than the cars value on a repair. A bottom end could have been repaired for 1k.
Further things were asked for within the bill, new cambelt etc, other things broken after it went to first garage
coxy1 said:
Yup they broke the mg aswell and i have counterclaimed for this. I know 3.5 months may not seem a long time but they have done over 10,000 miles. As much as expected from someone in a year. Does that not count for anything?
I would say so, fair point. coxy1 said:
My thoughts are the following and unsure which gives me good leverage....
Everything you say may be true BUT can you prove it? You must try to blot out the rage and sense of injustice and just line up the facts calmly. Get as much advice as you can - eg CAB and Trading Standards - to find out exactly what your responsibilities were and were not. You should have received a copy of the other party's claim and all their evidence/facts. Compare this with what you were legally required to do, and what you did do, and then you can start to build your case. Don't lose on a technicality or careless oversight; have answers for everything.
At the hearing each party will have a chance to ask questions of the other. Hence prepare some killer questions - but be aware that if the other party is sharp they can use their answers to support their case. Expect the unexpected.
I'm not au fait with the car trade so can't help on specifics, but best of luck

coxy1 said:
I buy and sell cars for a living from a smallish unit.
As such, what warranty was implied or given? If it was outside the warranty terms (time and/or miles) they will get nowhere. If it was inside the warranty terms your strongest cards are 1,the missed service, 2, the way that they handled the complaint in not giving you the opportunity to correct it. They reduced to a £5k claim because that is the upper limit to small claims court, more than that it's county court and associated legal costs.
Maz_uk said:
I would be very surprised if you didn't win this, have they actually taken you to court yet or just sent you a claim via small courts?
He has a hearing date so he has chosen to defend the case and the claimant will have had to pay a hearing fee. They started the roller coaster in motion and now they are going to have to ride it.If they didn't know the small claims limit I don't think they will be much opposition, but never underestimate the enemy. Possibly they thought they could just send in a claim form and get a cheque for £6,000...
10,000 miles! Hardly a car which wasn't 'fit for purpose' was it?
Also, you weren't given any opportunity to sort out the issue until 2 other garages had buggered about with it. I doubt you'd be able to prove, unless you can get a statement from the garage, that the owner drove it around knowing it was faulty. I can't see how any of this is your fault or you are to blame.
Best of luck.
Also, you weren't given any opportunity to sort out the issue until 2 other garages had buggered about with it. I doubt you'd be able to prove, unless you can get a statement from the garage, that the owner drove it around knowing it was faulty. I can't see how any of this is your fault or you are to blame.
Best of luck.
Makes me laugh how people think that a second hand trader is forever responsible for any faults that occur ages after purchase. There was a thing on the radio recently saying second hand cars keep trading standards and small claims courts busy. Some of this is no doubt due to dodgy sellers but more I think like this where someone's expectations of how responsible you can be for a car have limits.
If you want aftercare for 3 years that's what new cars are for. Want to pay 6k instead of 46k? But second hand and accept there will be liabilities.
Best of luck op
If you want aftercare for 3 years that's what new cars are for. Want to pay 6k instead of 46k? But second hand and accept there will be liabilities.
Best of luck op
Had a meeting with a solicitor today who said litigation is difficult and couldn't advise on whether i have a strong case or not. He didn't really tell me anything i didn't know already! So stuck on what to do with regards the matter. Mr C has offered mediation through courts, so if i knew how strong my case is i may be best to settle when we go here. If i knew my case was very strong i'd decline it and fight them to the end. If law wasn't a factor i don't feel they are deserving even on a moral scale due to me doing them a favour, them abusing the car, me helping with another which they ruined and take no action for, and then trying to give me a ridiculous bill! Had the bill just been a repair to the bottom end and cost 1k i'd probably have just paid up!
coxy1 said:
Had a meeting with a solicitor today who said litigation is difficult and couldn't advise on whether i have a strong case or not. He didn't really tell me anything i didn't know already! So stuck on what to do with regards the matter. Mr C has offered mediation through courts, so if i knew how strong my case is i may be best to settle when we go here. If i knew my case was very strong i'd decline it and fight them to the end.
It's a game of possible bluff. He may be going for mediation because he knows he can't win the case in a straight fight... but can you? I don't know; you can only look at all the facts (yours and his) and see which stacks up best. Presume you have a copy of the evidence he intends to present? Does it add up? Can you disprove any of it?NB: IMHO solicitors are pointless in small claims cases and will just cost you more money (their fees cannot be claimed). Small Claims is designed for Joe Public direct, like two boys scrapping in the playground while the Beak looks on.
Simpo Two said:
It's a game of possible bluff. He may be going for mediation because he knows he can't win the case in a straight fight... but can you? I don't know; you can only look at all the facts (yours and his) and see which stacks up best. Presume you have a copy of the evidence he intends to present? Does it add up? Can you disprove any of it?
NB: IMHO solicitors are pointless in small claims cases and will just cost you more money (their fees cannot be claimed). Small Claims is designed for Joe Public direct, like two boys scrapping in the playground while the Beak looks on.
We haven't had an exchange of evidence yet. I'm thinking the hearing in December is a directions hearing but i'm going to call tomorrow to find out. He has already reduced the claim from £6200 to £5000 to go small claims track, which he needn't have done as they increased it to 10k anyway. But he is being represented at court, and his solicitor will be attending all the hearings. That in itself will cost them a small fortune i'd imagine! I'm unsure whether to be represented at the final hearing, or go myself and state that they are using 'bullying' tactics as its unusual to be represented at small claims. NB: IMHO solicitors are pointless in small claims cases and will just cost you more money (their fees cannot be claimed). Small Claims is designed for Joe Public direct, like two boys scrapping in the playground while the Beak looks on.
They have asked for mediation, i wasn't fussed but i felt i had nothing to lose and depending on what they were asking for i may decide to settle just to get rid of them. I can't personally see them coming out too well from this. Spent £6200 on repair, asking £5000, i'v a solid counterclaim as we had a contract, so possible less £1200. Leaves only £3800 if they win their side but minus their solicitors costs, bearing in mind they live at least 90mins from the court its been assigned to!
Its one of the reasons i'm considering giving the trade up. Im very very decent and probably look after people too well, but people expect far too much. I recently sold an mx5 to a customer. The person who part exchanged it had put 4 new tyres on recently. Maybe they had a puncture that was irreparable but one tyre was of a different brand. He wanted a brand new tyre so they matched. One was an infinity the other a dunlop. Of course he wanted a new dunlop. I paid him the cost of a new infinity despite this.
The claimant has to prove that you are in breach of S14 SOGA.
This is an objective test - would a reasonable person, taking account of the age, price, description, used nature of the car think it was of 'satisfactory quality' for an 85k mile, £6k used car?
Photo evidence and services history evidence wold be useful for you here, to show that cosmetically it was in good condition and had been maintained etc.
In addition, the car ran a further 10k miles before failure - contributed to by the buyer's failure to maintain he car or respond to engine warning lights.
Even if he was succesful in showing breach (and I very much doubt he can), consider his damages. I am not convinced he is entitled to a new engine. He is entitled to the costs of repair or replacement with a used engine of similar age. I expect there would be an element of unjust enrichment to consider if he was to claim a brand new engine. Then there is his own contribution to the damage to consider. Did he give you an opportunity to repair the damage? (though I don't think you were under a duty to do so).
Honestly, if I were your would to to court.
When he filed the claim, did you file a defence?
The damaged MG counterclaim is a bit trickier. You might struggle to show any contractual relationship between you and the claimant - so you would probably be making a claim for,property damage.
This is an objective test - would a reasonable person, taking account of the age, price, description, used nature of the car think it was of 'satisfactory quality' for an 85k mile, £6k used car?
Photo evidence and services history evidence wold be useful for you here, to show that cosmetically it was in good condition and had been maintained etc.
In addition, the car ran a further 10k miles before failure - contributed to by the buyer's failure to maintain he car or respond to engine warning lights.
Even if he was succesful in showing breach (and I very much doubt he can), consider his damages. I am not convinced he is entitled to a new engine. He is entitled to the costs of repair or replacement with a used engine of similar age. I expect there would be an element of unjust enrichment to consider if he was to claim a brand new engine. Then there is his own contribution to the damage to consider. Did he give you an opportunity to repair the damage? (though I don't think you were under a duty to do so).
Honestly, if I were your would to to court.
When he filed the claim, did you file a defence?
The damaged MG counterclaim is a bit trickier. You might struggle to show any contractual relationship between you and the claimant - so you would probably be making a claim for,property damage.
johnfm said:
The claimant has to prove that you are in breach of S14 SOGA.
This is an objective test - would a reasonable person, taking account of the age, price, description, used nature of the car think it was of 'satisfactory quality' for an 85k mile, £6k used car?
Photo evidence and services history evidence wold be useful for you here, to show that cosmetically it was in good condition and had been maintained etc.
In addition, the car ran a further 10k miles before failure - contributed to by the buyer's failure to maintain he car or respond to engine warning lights.
Even if he was succesful in showing breach (and I very much doubt he can), consider his damages. I am not convinced he is entitled to a new engine. He is entitled to the costs of repair or replacement with a used engine of similar age. I expect there would be an element of unjust enrichment to consider if he was to claim a brand new engine. Then there is his own contribution to the damage to consider. Did he give you an opportunity to repair the damage? (though I don't think you were under a duty to do so).
Honestly, if I were your would to to court.
When he filed the claim, did you file a defence?
The damaged MG counterclaim is a bit trickier. You might struggle to show any contractual relationship between you and the claimant - so you would probably be making a claim for,property damage.
I think its satisfactory mainly due to the mileage they have covered. I have photos of the cars condition but no records of the service history. He did give me an opportunity to repair, their garage was going to strip the engine but they moved it to another garage themselves and chose to fit a new engine which i told them at the time was daft considering the cost of the work vs cost of the car. This was all via telephone though. This is an objective test - would a reasonable person, taking account of the age, price, description, used nature of the car think it was of 'satisfactory quality' for an 85k mile, £6k used car?
Photo evidence and services history evidence wold be useful for you here, to show that cosmetically it was in good condition and had been maintained etc.
In addition, the car ran a further 10k miles before failure - contributed to by the buyer's failure to maintain he car or respond to engine warning lights.
Even if he was succesful in showing breach (and I very much doubt he can), consider his damages. I am not convinced he is entitled to a new engine. He is entitled to the costs of repair or replacement with a used engine of similar age. I expect there would be an element of unjust enrichment to consider if he was to claim a brand new engine. Then there is his own contribution to the damage to consider. Did he give you an opportunity to repair the damage? (though I don't think you were under a duty to do so).
Honestly, if I were your would to to court.
When he filed the claim, did you file a defence?
The damaged MG counterclaim is a bit trickier. You might struggle to show any contractual relationship between you and the claimant - so you would probably be making a claim for,property damage.
I filed a defence and also a counterclaim for the mg. I have a contract via txt, along the lines of, "I am loaning you this car FOC, any damages or breakages are to be picked up by yourself aswell as suitable insurance" to which he responded "ok". As i say i have this as hard evidence still.
coxy1 said:
I think its satisfactory mainly due to the mileage they have covered. I have photos of the cars condition but no records of the service history. He did give me an opportunity to repair, their garage was going to strip the engine but they moved it to another garage themselves and chose to fit a new engine which i told them at the time was daft considering the cost of the work vs cost of the car. This was all via telephone though.
I filed a defence and also a counterclaim for the mg. I have a contract via txt, along the lines of, "I am loaning you this car FOC, any damages or breakages are to be picked up by yourself aswell as suitable insurance" to which he responded "ok". As i say i have this as hard evidence still.
S48a of SOGA is the interesting one. Ordinarily, if a fault develops within 6 months it is deemed to have been unsatisfactory at he time of delivery (s48A(3)) and the burden falls on the dealer (you) to prove that the fault was not already present.I filed a defence and also a counterclaim for the mg. I have a contract via txt, along the lines of, "I am loaning you this car FOC, any damages or breakages are to be picked up by yourself aswell as suitable insurance" to which he responded "ok". As i say i have this as hard evidence still.
BUT, you may be able to rely on the exemption in s48A(4)(b) - a car (as in this case) can do a year's 'normal' mileage in less than 6 months, such that the 6 month rule may be 'incompatible with the nature of the goods'.
Re: the MG, you may struggle to prove a contract was formed by text. The buyer is a friend of the family, no? As such, a text about the use of the car might not support an intention to be bound, or agreement to the terms. Not to mention the seeming lack of consideration on is part.
In any event, good luck.
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



tish relatives!