Witnessed an accident today - fault?
Discussion
Interested in opinions on this.
Queuing towards a small roundabout in an urban environment today, my side of the road split into two lanes, LH is a bus lane, traffic queung in RH lane, and one lane of oncoming traffic. I am sitting in the queue and have left a gap in front of me as there is a road just to my left.
A car coming towards me indicates right, and turns across me to take the side road, and before I know it a van coming down the bus lane on my left has hit its near side. No serious injury but both vehicles write offs.
Police happen to be around so details taken, etc. Most people seem to think van is to blame - sure enough, he was in the bus lane (although he protested that he was turning left rather than jumping the queue to the roundabout - having spent a lot of time queueing here I'm not convinced, and irrelevant I should think), and I suspect as many others did, that he was doing in excess of the speed limit - certainly more than was wise given the proximity of schools and the time of day.
However, the car did turn across in front of him, and whether he was indicating or not, he had priority. I would imagine that the van would have been visible.
So how do we think this would go? 50/50? 100% van driver's fault? My dash camera footage is bloody useless unfortunately...
Queuing towards a small roundabout in an urban environment today, my side of the road split into two lanes, LH is a bus lane, traffic queung in RH lane, and one lane of oncoming traffic. I am sitting in the queue and have left a gap in front of me as there is a road just to my left.
A car coming towards me indicates right, and turns across me to take the side road, and before I know it a van coming down the bus lane on my left has hit its near side. No serious injury but both vehicles write offs.
Police happen to be around so details taken, etc. Most people seem to think van is to blame - sure enough, he was in the bus lane (although he protested that he was turning left rather than jumping the queue to the roundabout - having spent a lot of time queueing here I'm not convinced, and irrelevant I should think), and I suspect as many others did, that he was doing in excess of the speed limit - certainly more than was wise given the proximity of schools and the time of day.
However, the car did turn across in front of him, and whether he was indicating or not, he had priority. I would imagine that the van would have been visible.
So how do we think this would go? 50/50? 100% van driver's fault? My dash camera footage is bloody useless unfortunately...
ging84 said:
hard to tell, but if it was a taxi with permission to use the bus lane who's fault would it be?
shouldn't make that much difference that he didn't have permission
This.shouldn't make that much difference that he didn't have permission
IMO, in an ideal world, the van driver would be fined for using the bus lane and the idiot who pulled in front of him should take 100% of the claim on his/her insurance.
I was in a car hit by another car doing something wrong; both cars were at fault but it went 100% against us. We turned left at the same point a car undertook us in a bus lane. A combination of poor visibility blind spot (soft top with roof up and no rear quarter window) and not expecting the car to be in the bus lane. Plus the other car being in a bus lane, and overtaking a car indicating left and slowing by a junction.
The point at the time, was whether or not the other car was supposed to be there, it was and our driver should have seen it. I imagine the same applies to the crash you saw.
The point at the time, was whether or not the other car was supposed to be there, it was and our driver should have seen it. I imagine the same applies to the crash you saw.
dreamer75 said:
I was in a car hit by another car doing something wrong; both cars were at fault but it went 100% against us. We turned left at the same point a car undertook us in a bus lane. A combination of poor visibility blind spot (soft top with roof up and no rear quarter window) and not expecting the car to be in the bus lane. Plus the other car being in a bus lane, and overtaking a car indicating left and slowing by a junction.
The point at the time, was whether or not the other car was supposed to be there, it was and our driver should have seen it. I imagine the same applies to the crash you saw.
In that instance it would have been the same outcome if a bus was (legally) travelling down the bus lane then ?The point at the time, was whether or not the other car was supposed to be there, it was and our driver should have seen it. I imagine the same applies to the crash you saw.
scorcher said:
Was the bus lane in operation? Baffles me that people don't / won't use bus lanes outside of their operational hours and would rather queue instead?
Had this in Chiswick High Street a few years ago, driving down the bus lane at about 3.50pm. Car coming from the opposite directions turns right in front of me causing us both to swerve and narrowly miss each other, he and another driver start yelling at me for driving in the bus lane. When I point out that the bus lane doesn't come into operation until 4.00pm the chap who turned in front of me admitted that he lived very close and apologised leaving the other chap slightly red faced.Actus Reus said:
Van isn't at fault at all unless his speed could be taken into account. Driving down a bus lane when you shouldn't isn't the same as, say, driving the wrong way down a one way street. All IMHO of course.
+1. Got to ask what would have happened if the van had been a taxi or cyclist. If the turning car hasn't seen a van there isn't much hope for cyclists. Should be 100% to blame and be made to take an eye test. Vipers said:
scorcher said:
Was the bus lane in operation? Baffles me that people don't / won't use bus lanes outside of their operational hours and would rather queue instead?
I love those who have no idea when bus lanes are not bus lanes, I can cruise past all that traffic feeling smug.
Regardless whether the van was in the wrong or not for using the bus lane (that's a council/police matter endorsable with a fine), the driver of the vehicle which pulled across in front of the van should perhaps have been more aware of the incoming vehicle as for all they knew, a bus/bike/motorbike/taxi could have been travelling down the lane at that point resulting in the same scenario.
Insurance wise, best case for the car driver is 50/50 (unless the police chime in) after many days/weeks/months arguing the point but could more than likely have full fault brought against them if the bus lane was utside operational hours for example. I doubt that the Insurance Co's will penalise the van driver fully for entering a resticted lane and if not restricted it's totally the other guy's fault.
Insurance wise, best case for the car driver is 50/50 (unless the police chime in) after many days/weeks/months arguing the point but could more than likely have full fault brought against them if the bus lane was utside operational hours for example. I doubt that the Insurance Co's will penalise the van driver fully for entering a resticted lane and if not restricted it's totally the other guy's fault.
Edited by Panda P on Thursday 14th November 12:42
Along similar note, near where I live is this roundabout:
https://maps.google.co.uk/maps?q=Meir&hl=en&am...
(road changes are still under construction in the pic, hence the taxi van on the wrong side of the road) In rush hour the majority of cars are in the right hand lane to go straight on and the left lane, the one I use, is almost always empty. On the rare occasion someone leaves the box junction free and I've come down the left hand lane I've had several cars turn across my path. Fortunately I'm wise to this now and find myself inching over the box junction to make 100% sure I'm not taken out by someone turning right.
I've seen several very near misses there now from people who don't know the junction as well I assume. Who's fault would it be though?
https://maps.google.co.uk/maps?q=Meir&hl=en&am...
(road changes are still under construction in the pic, hence the taxi van on the wrong side of the road) In rush hour the majority of cars are in the right hand lane to go straight on and the left lane, the one I use, is almost always empty. On the rare occasion someone leaves the box junction free and I've come down the left hand lane I've had several cars turn across my path. Fortunately I'm wise to this now and find myself inching over the box junction to make 100% sure I'm not taken out by someone turning right.
I've seen several very near misses there now from people who don't know the junction as well I assume. Who's fault would it be though?
Here's where it happened:
http://goo.gl/maps/65oYo
Unfortunately my dashcam glitches and you see the car swing across but nothing after that.
Bloke was clearly a bell end cutting down the bus lane too fast, and he got his - seen enough people saving themselves a 10 minute queue at others' expense.
But the woman was properly horrible, screaming and shouting while her kid just stood there, and the guy was defensive, understandably. Nobody seemed to be saying that she pulled in front of him!
Both as bad as each other IMHO, especially as they were so vile.
http://goo.gl/maps/65oYo
Unfortunately my dashcam glitches and you see the car swing across but nothing after that.
Bloke was clearly a bell end cutting down the bus lane too fast, and he got his - seen enough people saving themselves a 10 minute queue at others' expense.
But the woman was properly horrible, screaming and shouting while her kid just stood there, and the guy was defensive, understandably. Nobody seemed to be saying that she pulled in front of him!
Both as bad as each other IMHO, especially as they were so vile.
Edited by NiceCupOfTea on Thursday 14th November 13:22
AlfaRSpider said:
This.
IMO, in an ideal world, the van driver would be fined for using the bus lane and the idiot who pulled in front of him should take 100% of the claim on his/her insurance.
Is the correct answer. Just because the van is doing something wrong that does not absolve the turning car driver of their responsibility to see him and drive accordingly. IMO, in an ideal world, the van driver would be fined for using the bus lane and the idiot who pulled in front of him should take 100% of the claim on his/her insurance.
Pulliptears said:
Along similar note, near where I live is this roundabout:
https://maps.google.co.uk/maps?q=Meir&hl=en&am...
(road changes are still under construction in the pic, hence the taxi van on the wrong side of the road) In rush hour the majority of cars are in the right hand lane to go straight on and the left lane, the one I use, is almost always empty. On the rare occasion someone leaves the box junction free and I've come down the left hand lane I've had several cars turn across my path. Fortunately I'm wise to this now and find myself inching over the box junction to make 100% sure I'm not taken out by someone turning right.
I've seen several very near misses there now from people who don't know the junction as well I assume. Who's fault would it be though?
If you're turning left there you're going to have slowed right down for the turn so I don't see how you clash with someone turning right in front of you as you would be able to stop easily.https://maps.google.co.uk/maps?q=Meir&hl=en&am...
(road changes are still under construction in the pic, hence the taxi van on the wrong side of the road) In rush hour the majority of cars are in the right hand lane to go straight on and the left lane, the one I use, is almost always empty. On the rare occasion someone leaves the box junction free and I've come down the left hand lane I've had several cars turn across my path. Fortunately I'm wise to this now and find myself inching over the box junction to make 100% sure I'm not taken out by someone turning right.
I've seen several very near misses there now from people who don't know the junction as well I assume. Who's fault would it be though?
Edited by herewego on Thursday 14th November 14:19
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


