Difference between false advertising and misrepresentation
Discussion
seen product advertised on this site stated original parts then made a visit to the shop to enquire, been told by the sales person parts were OEM so made a purchase then realised that there was a model number on the package box so googled it, turns out to be replicas.
Shall i use "false advertisement " or "misrepresentation"please help .
Shall i use "false advertisement " or "misrepresentation"please help .
OEM doesn't mean original manufacturer?
Depending on the item this is probably absolutely fine, if it's a car related item an OEM part is a term used for a part made to original manufacturer specs, regardless of the technical meaning of the term (which should be as an example a Bosch Alternator branded for BMW and sold by BMW parts would be sold as an original BMW part, the same Bosch part but not in a BMW box would be sold as OEM.) it tends to be used to describe a part designed to the same spec as the original, loosely gets around the terminology by being a manufacturer who does produce Original Equipment for a manufacturer, not necessarily the same part you are buying, thus you buy a part to the same specs FROM an OEM manufacturer.
It's murky and unless we are talking a Rolex with a fake bracelet, or an Apple computer with an aftermarket screen or some other similar heavily branded "premium" item with a grossly poorer quality replacement part I'd say you have little chance of redress here, it's such a murky area, using one of those examples who is to say that the Folex bracelet is poorer quality, some fakes are very good, you would need to prove for instance that the material used was an inferior grade of stainless, if it was to all intents and purposes the same quality but made by ding dong enterprises, if they also make bracelets for Orient watches they are an OEM manufacturer selling an identical/original spec bracelet for a Rolex watch. Not an original Rolex bracelet.
So in short were you sold said item as refurbed with OEM parts or original parts (these could be used by the way).
And yes I know what OEM means, but in the real world rightly or wrongly it just doesn't mean that in most industries, go and buy electronic or vehicle components and you will see they are listed as OEM but are not at all, doesn't automatically mean they are inferior, although it can do.
Depending on the item this is probably absolutely fine, if it's a car related item an OEM part is a term used for a part made to original manufacturer specs, regardless of the technical meaning of the term (which should be as an example a Bosch Alternator branded for BMW and sold by BMW parts would be sold as an original BMW part, the same Bosch part but not in a BMW box would be sold as OEM.) it tends to be used to describe a part designed to the same spec as the original, loosely gets around the terminology by being a manufacturer who does produce Original Equipment for a manufacturer, not necessarily the same part you are buying, thus you buy a part to the same specs FROM an OEM manufacturer.
It's murky and unless we are talking a Rolex with a fake bracelet, or an Apple computer with an aftermarket screen or some other similar heavily branded "premium" item with a grossly poorer quality replacement part I'd say you have little chance of redress here, it's such a murky area, using one of those examples who is to say that the Folex bracelet is poorer quality, some fakes are very good, you would need to prove for instance that the material used was an inferior grade of stainless, if it was to all intents and purposes the same quality but made by ding dong enterprises, if they also make bracelets for Orient watches they are an OEM manufacturer selling an identical/original spec bracelet for a Rolex watch. Not an original Rolex bracelet.
So in short were you sold said item as refurbed with OEM parts or original parts (these could be used by the way).
And yes I know what OEM means, but in the real world rightly or wrongly it just doesn't mean that in most industries, go and buy electronic or vehicle components and you will see they are listed as OEM but are not at all, doesn't automatically mean they are inferior, although it can do.
The usual distiction is OEM and Pattern this may be a gross simplification but: OEM the design is done from the drawings and is to a standard it could be fitted by the orignal manufacturer, Pattern tend to be reverse engineered so while it may fit it's not 100% the same and may be a close but not perfect match.
Engineer1 said:
The usual distiction is OEM and Pattern this may be a gross simplification but: OEM the design is done from the drawings and is to a standard it could be fitted by the orignal manufacturer, Pattern tend to be reverse engineered so while it may fit it's not 100% the same and may be a close but not perfect match.
Thanks IANAL but I would say with wheels you have to be extra careful. Lots of cheap copies around, especially on ebay. I would say you can claim OEM if they are manufactured by a company that supplies the car company in question. If it's a copy then I think that's misrepresenting the item.
For example Ronal make a lot of Ford wheels so if they were made by them but not branded Ford that's fair enough.
For example Ronal make a lot of Ford wheels so if they were made by them but not branded Ford that's fair enough.
Are they really replica Lexus F sport wheels? Is there such a thing? I'm not taking the P I'm genuinely interested, I can see a market for say an M3 replica but that market seems a bit limited to me to go to the effort of faking a wheel for.
OE fitment would likely have been Enkei, a large proportion of Jap wheels are, I'm assuming what's happened here is you've bought a car from a dealer and asked for a set of wheels to be fitted, in this case I assume Lexus sport wheels.
If that's the case in my experience of working at car dealers which was a fair while ago now but I don't imagine it's changed much, the first choice would be to fit the nastiest cheapest wheel available to maximise profit, if the buyer specified an exact manufacturer wheel then parts would just order it in. What are the wheels fitted if they don't match the invoice?
OE fitment would likely have been Enkei, a large proportion of Jap wheels are, I'm assuming what's happened here is you've bought a car from a dealer and asked for a set of wheels to be fitted, in this case I assume Lexus sport wheels.
If that's the case in my experience of working at car dealers which was a fair while ago now but I don't imagine it's changed much, the first choice would be to fit the nastiest cheapest wheel available to maximise profit, if the buyer specified an exact manufacturer wheel then parts would just order it in. What are the wheels fitted if they don't match the invoice?
Wasn't this one was it?
If so it's pretty clear what they are.
http://www.pyspeed.com/LX520-OEM-Replica-LFA-Style...
Even if not that website and it doesn't make it as clear as that one they are a replica wheel, to be honest it should be common sense that a lexus LFA wheel isn't going to be genuine unless it's coming from manufacturer and expensive. It's back to the fake Rolex argument again.
If so it's pretty clear what they are.
http://www.pyspeed.com/LX520-OEM-Replica-LFA-Style...
Even if not that website and it doesn't make it as clear as that one they are a replica wheel, to be honest it should be common sense that a lexus LFA wheel isn't going to be genuine unless it's coming from manufacturer and expensive. It's back to the fake Rolex argument again.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




