Coolant loss and potential porous head issues
Discussion
I've had my 56-plate 2.0 TDI GT Golf for almost exactly 5 years now and, whilst not the most reliable in that time with sensors giving up the ghost on 4 or 5 occasions it's been - and continues to be - a great drive.
In recent months I've noticed the coolant level dropping to the minimum over the course of a few weeks accompanied with a substantial steam cloud on warm restarts from time to time. Internet research suggests a common problem on this engine of porous cylinder heads and a potential £1500+ repair bill. As keen as I am to fix the problem I'm not overly enthusiastic about the prospect of handing over THAT much folding stuff and I was interested to see a forum post - not on PH I might add - that someone had claimed some success in resolving this exact problem by using some of Halfords Radweld in the cooling system.
As reluctant as I am to resort to Halfrauds technology I did some investigation at my local independent motor factors and found a product called K-Seal which promises to address the same problem. With some promising sales videos on the 'net I decided to give it a go. After all, a £10 investment seems chicken feed compared to the potential cost of a proper repair.
Bearing in mind the warnings given by most manufacturers about using such additives - they are obviously keen to get the repair business - I went ahead and put the contents of the 8 fl oz bottle into the header tank. I am pleased to report that within 15 minutes of doing so the engine felt distinctly smoother running and there has been no sign of the steam cloud on ANY warm restarts since. I appreciate that it's early days and I'd be a fool if I thought this was a permanent solution - although K-Seal do promote it as such - it seems a £10 investment, even if it's repeated every few months, might be a viable alternative to that big bill.
Dave
In recent months I've noticed the coolant level dropping to the minimum over the course of a few weeks accompanied with a substantial steam cloud on warm restarts from time to time. Internet research suggests a common problem on this engine of porous cylinder heads and a potential £1500+ repair bill. As keen as I am to fix the problem I'm not overly enthusiastic about the prospect of handing over THAT much folding stuff and I was interested to see a forum post - not on PH I might add - that someone had claimed some success in resolving this exact problem by using some of Halfords Radweld in the cooling system.
As reluctant as I am to resort to Halfrauds technology I did some investigation at my local independent motor factors and found a product called K-Seal which promises to address the same problem. With some promising sales videos on the 'net I decided to give it a go. After all, a £10 investment seems chicken feed compared to the potential cost of a proper repair.
Bearing in mind the warnings given by most manufacturers about using such additives - they are obviously keen to get the repair business - I went ahead and put the contents of the 8 fl oz bottle into the header tank. I am pleased to report that within 15 minutes of doing so the engine felt distinctly smoother running and there has been no sign of the steam cloud on ANY warm restarts since. I appreciate that it's early days and I'd be a fool if I thought this was a permanent solution - although K-Seal do promote it as such - it seems a £10 investment, even if it's repeated every few months, might be a viable alternative to that big bill.
Dave
I had very similar issues to this on my 04 plate VW Touran 2.0 TDI. The coolant would disapear over a matter of a week.
VW main stealer wouldnt comment until they got the car in and tore half the engine apart to check what was going on. Earlier visits they had replaced various pipes, expansion tank etc.
This time, they told me that the cylinder head was porus and it would be about £3k to repair inc labour and ancilaries.
I contacted VW HQ and told them that i was not prepared to pay for this and that the car was supplied as new with a porus cylinder head. Basically, it must have left the factory like this as they just dont go porus overnight.
Eventually, after much agro and nearly a month of having a VW Fox (oh god) as a loan car, they settled at 50/50. I paid around £1500.
There were various oil leaks and issues with the turbo boost pressures after this, which they all corrected for free. But it was a night mare.
Oh and a few months after the clutch and flywheel needed replacing....I will not be buying another VW any time soon.
ETA: Edited to answer your question - I guess it all depends on how long you plan to keep the car and how many miles a year you do.
VW main stealer wouldnt comment until they got the car in and tore half the engine apart to check what was going on. Earlier visits they had replaced various pipes, expansion tank etc.
This time, they told me that the cylinder head was porus and it would be about £3k to repair inc labour and ancilaries.
I contacted VW HQ and told them that i was not prepared to pay for this and that the car was supplied as new with a porus cylinder head. Basically, it must have left the factory like this as they just dont go porus overnight.
Eventually, after much agro and nearly a month of having a VW Fox (oh god) as a loan car, they settled at 50/50. I paid around £1500.
There were various oil leaks and issues with the turbo boost pressures after this, which they all corrected for free. But it was a night mare.
Oh and a few months after the clutch and flywheel needed replacing....I will not be buying another VW any time soon.
ETA: Edited to answer your question - I guess it all depends on how long you plan to keep the car and how many miles a year you do.
Edited by Ray Singh on Thursday 14th November 09:31
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


