58 plate golf TDi 140 - dreaded dual mass flywheel issues??
58 plate golf TDi 140 - dreaded dual mass flywheel issues??
Author
Discussion

911ked

Original Poster:

40 posts

166 months

Friday 15th November 2013
quotequote all
Hi all, help/advice/personal experience please:-

I have a 58 plate Mk5 2.0 tdi Sport 140 Golf. Its lovely - only now done 20k miles from new. I brought 18 months ago on 12k miles from a VW main dealer (who are less lovely but thats another story....). Ever since I have had it - particularity in the colder months it shows the following two issues:-

1 - It always starts fine but NOT like any other car I know - petrol or diesel - it doesn't really turn over for a few seconds then fire, it always seems to start instantly with a rough sounding surge of vibration - it will then run and drive fine until:-

2 - If you coast up to a junction when the engines part warm, slow down and stop with your foot on the clutch it runs really rough to the point it feels like it might stall as you slow, but doesn't actually stall - it then idles really rough once you have come to a halt - the vibrations/lumpiness can be felt through the car. If you left it be, it would stay the same until it warms up fully and smooths out a bit.

When the cars fully warm it restarts more normally - smoother - and also idles a lot better, but still not as smoothly as I would expect for such a low mileage car on idle. Power delivery etc when you put your foot down is always fine - its actually petty quick to be honest - fuel consumption on run is pretty good - 50 - 60mpg. No signs of smoke etc

To me its either potentially fuel/injectors or maybe fuel pump but its been suggested it could be due to the dual mass flywheel starting to break up and running out of balance. Anyone experienced this or got any ideas what I can do to try and work out whats causing it?? VW "could find anything wrong with it" - certainly from the injector/fuel side of things in March when they serviced it and its now driving me mad.... Thank you

Super Slo Mo

5,374 posts

229 months

Friday 15th November 2013
quotequote all
A slightly lumpy/rough idle could be down to the alternator pulley. Apparently they are a ratchet type arrangement as in, they only drive the alternator in one direction, so any difference in engine speed per revolution (which is quite a bit at idle), doesn't snatch at the alternator.

If this pulley seizes, which it's prone to do, it makes the idle feel a lot rougher.

Not sure I've explained it very well, but it happened to my Polo some years back.

74merc

602 posts

223 months

Friday 15th November 2013
quotequote all
Doesn't sound like a pending DMF failure to me. We had a 58 plate Tiguan until recently and it's DMF started to go, that was at 85K miles. It is characterised by a chattering sound at startup. I suspect your issues are due to low mileage.