Lexus IS 250 or Alfa GT 2.0JTS Forum views
Lexus IS 250 or Alfa GT 2.0JTS Forum views
Author
Discussion

Tannedbaldhead

Original Poster:

3,210 posts

162 months

Sunday 17th November 2013
quotequote all

SidewaysSi

10,742 posts

264 months

Sunday 17th November 2013
quotequote all
I would go for the Lexus. Quite different cars but the Lexus is probably less disappointing than the Alfa i.e. actually does what you expect from it.

You expect the Alfa to be sporty and exciting when it really isn't. You expect the Lexus to be reliable, nicely made and but perhaps a little dull. Which it is.

And to these eyes, the Lexus is actually the nicer looking car.

Escy

4,130 posts

179 months

Sunday 17th November 2013
quotequote all
I'd go for the Alfa. They drive well and look much nicer than the Lexus. I have to say, the 2.0 JTS would be my last choice of engine, i'd even have the diesel over it.

Otispunkmeyer

13,819 posts

185 months

Sunday 17th November 2013
quotequote all
Lexus

probably not going to go wrong and even with the diesel is nicely refined place to be. Depends what you are looking for of course, but I'd be having an IS250 + slush box and heated seats and just wafting everywhere. The suspension is somewhat firm, but feels sufficiently damped. It doesn't crash into pot holes, but can be a bit pitter-pattery on some knobbly surfaces. I can only speak from experience of the diesel though which likely has different spring settings to cope with the anvil in the front.

It is very pokey inside though, I thought the windscreen was especially small to look out of. Like looking out of a post box.

lexusboy

1,101 posts

173 months

Sunday 17th November 2013
quotequote all
Otispunkmeyer said:
Lexus

probably not going to go wrong and even with the diesel is nicely refined place to be. Depends what you are looking for of course, but I'd be having an IS250 + slush box and heated seats and just wafting everywhere. The suspension is somewhat firm, but feels sufficiently damped. It doesn't crash into pot holes, but can be a bit pitter-pattery on some knobbly surfaces. I can only speak from experience of the diesel though which likely has different spring settings to cope with the anvil in the front.

It is very pokey inside though, I thought the windscreen was especially small to look out of. Like looking out of a post box.
I'm 99.9% certain they share the same spring rates as the diesel is a 4 pot all aluminium engine and the 250 is an all aluminium V6

Captain Cadillac

2,974 posts

217 months

Sunday 17th November 2013
quotequote all
If you get the Lexus (And I wouldn't) get the water pump changed ASAP!

They all seem to leak, but the leak is difficult to see. My GS350 blew its' seal on the highway and I simply had no idea it was blowing out coolant until the engine started to rattle and then failed 6 seconds later. These cars lack a low coolant warning and the temp gauge never read high.

Tannedbaldhead

Original Poster:

3,210 posts

162 months

Sunday 17th November 2013
quotequote all
Captain Cadillac said:
If you get the Lexus (And I wouldn't) get the water pump changed ASAP!

They all seem to leak, but the leak is difficult to see. My GS350 blew its' seal on the highway and I simply had no idea it was blowing out coolant until the engine started to rattle and then failed 6 seconds later. These cars lack a low coolant warning and the temp gauge never read high.
Am very used to coolant level paranoia. My other car is an MG TF.

Captain Cadillac

2,974 posts

217 months

Sunday 17th November 2013
quotequote all
I like TFs, shame we never got them over here.

As a side note the car broke down 20 miles after we stopped for fuel and I noticed it was full of coolant (I added washer fluid at the stop).

Also worry about valve springs and VVT-I actuators. IMO that's a terrible engine.