Unreasonable Clauses and Breach all in one Happy Bundle!
Unreasonable Clauses and Breach all in one Happy Bundle!
Author
Discussion

Randomthoughts

Original Poster:

917 posts

164 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
http://www.ibtimes.com/kleargearcom-woman-hit-3500...

Questions, if anyone has US experience please feel free but also interesting from a UK perspective:

Is the restriction of making public comment about your experience a reasonable or an unreasonable clause in a Sale of Goods contract?

Would the clause likely hold up in court?

Is the clause even applicable as the contract was voided by the supplier's non-delivery within a reasonable timeframe?

IMHO this has immense repercussions if this proves to be watertight, because it effectively prevents anyone from being able to warn others of businesses that are unable to deliver goods or services they offer and that's scary given how many online stores go bump with people's money.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
I doubt any such clause would be compatible with the freedom of expression provisions of the ECHR.

Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
I doubt any such clause would be compatible with the freedom of expression provisions of the ECHR.
ECHR wouldn't apply unless the seller was a state body. I suspect any attempt to enforce such a clause in the UK would be found to be incompatible with consumer protection legislation. In any event if a seller took offence to a published review they could always try to sue for defamation.

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
Why would the review website sting them for $2,000 to remove the negative review?

y2keable

116 posts

163 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
Ok, so they've comitted fraud by taking money in exchange for a non-existant product and in an effort to protect against the consumer warning other potential marks about them, they've devised a way to damage the mark's credit record (a channel providing means of businesses warning other businesses about an individual's risk) with the same impact that if she were a fraudster.

I'm not sure about US law but here in the UK, I know enough to know that I'd love to do business with them and I'd love to take them through the court. I don't even know where I want to begin...

Odie

4,187 posts

213 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
None of this makes any sense,

He tried to make a purchase. Goods never arrived so transaction cancelled, so as no transaction was completed no terms of sale apply. Also how can a company 'fine' someone?

I don't understand how they have fked with his credit rating, surely the only time your credit rating is affected is when you authorise someone to check your credit or take out credit in your name.

America is fked up is it.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
Andy_GSA said:
ECHR wouldn't apply unless the seller was a state body. I suspect any attempt to enforce such a clause in the UK would be found to be incompatible with consumer protection legislation. In any event if a seller took offence to a published review they could always try to sue for defamation.
Perhaps I should have said s12 of the HRA? I don't see anything in the legislation restricting the consideration only to actions involving the State.

y2keable

116 posts

163 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
Andy_GSA said:
ECHR wouldn't apply unless the seller was a state body. I suspect any attempt to enforce such a clause in the UK would be found to be incompatible with consumer protection legislation. In any event if a seller took offence to a published review they could always try to sue for defamation.
...but it doesn't sound like the review was deformative. How could they sue for deformation/libel if it's true?

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
y2keable said:
...but it doesn't sound like the review was deformative. How could they sue for deformation/libel if it's true?
Defamation.

Truth is not necessarily a defence unless telling it is in the public interest.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
Incorrect. Truth is an absolute defence to any defamation claim.

Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
y2keable said:
...but it doesn't sound like the review was deformative. How could they sue for deformation/libel if it's true?
I didn't say they'd win wink

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
what seems strange about this story to me is it suggest that any company, or at least the company in the story is able to report an unpaid invoice directly to credit reference agencies, in this country unless it's part of a credit agreement with a company licensed to give credit an unpaid bill will not affect your credit rating without the claim first going through the court and still remaining unpaid.
if this is not the case in america and companies can report an unpaid invoice to the credit ratings agency it would seem way to open to abuse

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
y2keable said:
Ok, so they've comitted fraud by taking money in exchange for a non-existant product and in an effort to protect against the consumer warning other potential marks about them, they've devised a way to damage the mark's credit record (a channel providing means of businesses warning other businesses about an individual's risk) with the same impact that if she were a fraudster.

I'm not sure about US law but here in the UK, I know enough to know that I'd love to do business with them and I'd love to take them through the court. I don't even know where I want to begin...
God help you, if this is the way you'd approach it:

y2keable said:
...but it doesn't sound like the review was deformative. How could they sue for deformation/libel if it's true?

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Firstly, the supplier is in breach of its contract and therefore would be unable to enforce any non-disparagement clause due to its own continuing breach. This is likely to be the case in the US, but you would need a court to enforce this (but see my next point).

Secondly, it would seem that the fee or fine (or whatever you want to call it), would be an unenforceable penalty at common law. This may be the case in the US (although they are generally more willing to allow anything in a contract to be enforceable and less concerned with matters such as public policy except where there is express legislation to address an issue).

Thirdly, in the UK we have the Unfair Contract Terms Act that would exclude clauses like that straight of the bat. US consumer contracts allow mandatory arbitration or mediation clauses, which would fall foul of UCTA, meaning that this contract may not on its face fall within the jurisdiction of any court, so that the common law remedies at point 1 or 2 might not be available. There may be ways around that, but it significantly increases the risk and complexity of any litigation.

Fourthly, we have data protection legislation that requires credit reference agencies, etc., to carry out checks on the veracity of information held and to make corrections, and more extensive legislation restricting and limiting the activities of debt collectors. There is much less regulation in this area in the US and therefore it is permissible for any company/two-bit landlord etc., to refer any alleged debt to a debt collection agency and to take the alleged creditor at its word regarding the validity of a debt. (In the UK, a disputed debt must be placed on hold to allow for litigation to take place). This also means that credit ratings are used more extensively in the US as it's easier to share that information with companies.

Additionally, while the HRA/ECHR is not directly binding on private entities, the Courts are a public body and they need to exercise their functions in a way that is compatible with human rights legislation, so it is likely that they could apply those rules (if necessary). The reality of the situation is however that there are so many other express provisions relating to contract law in the UK that would make this fail, it would be unnecessary to get as far as human rights legislation - though it would be a valid backstop if we didn't have the contractual provisions.

In summary, this contract would be completely useless in the UK for four reasons above, whereas in the US, the light touch of federal legislation (delegating those rights to the states, which have a much less cohesive body of law and may be more susceptible to lobbying than the federal government, perhaps not overall but certainly more of a patchwork of lobbying successes).

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
Incorrect. Truth is an absolute defence to any defamation claim.
Thank you. I've obviously been misled.

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
Breadvan72 said:
Incorrect. Truth is an absolute defence to any defamation claim.
Thank you. I've obviously been misled.
However (Breadvan72 knows this) it is not necessarily a defence to a claim for breach of contract, which is what this would be, or breach of confidence - i.e., it's not defamation.

(Amended because BV72 has rightly picked up my sloppy wording).

Edited by CYMR0 on Wednesday 20th November 15:45

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
There is no basis for a breach of confidence claim here, and for most of the reasons you have identified above and for a further reason the restraint on free speech would be unenforceable in this context. The further reason is that an onerous or unusual clause should be drawn to the attention of the contracting party, and burying it in standard terms is not the way to do this.

I add that breach by party A does not automatically disentitle it from enforcing the contract, but will do so where the breach is repudiatory and party B terminates the contract.

A non disparagement clause can sometime be valid, but this one wouldn't be.

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
I add that breach by party A does not automatically disentitle it from enforcing the contract, but will do so where the breach is repudiatory and party B terminates the contract.
Party B's repudiation being evidenced further by their comments which they would not otherwise have made if the contract had been in force?

So far off my base I am but a punter looking in but seems to me more a question of aggressive retailer facing up a poorly represented individual.

What was that Red Adair quote going round the other day?

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 21st November 2013
quotequote all
Some terminology. The party in breach is the party that repudiates the contract, if the breach is of a sufficiently serious nature. The wronged party can "accept" the repudiation and end the contract.

mcflurry

9,192 posts

284 months

Thursday 21st November 2013
quotequote all
Can the couple not countersue the company, based on the US equivalent rules, thus removing the bad mark?

Plus, as it's in the USA, receive eleventy million dollars compensation too wink