Car clubs....what would you do differently?
Car clubs....what would you do differently?
Author
Discussion

MrH

Original Poster:

484 posts

239 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Been having an interesting discussion with someone recently about yearly membership car clubs, of which many exist at different levels, general krux being yearly fee £xxxx for xxxx points in so many cars.

Conversation went on to talk about the points system being a bit confusing, so thought it would be interesting to see what you guys would do if you had a car club? What would you change if anything? Keep the points system? Change it? Do something completely different and new with the setup?

Cheers, M.

Lawbags

1,074 posts

159 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Having never been part of a car club, what is the points system all about?

Or do you only need suggestions from people who are part of clubs already?

Voguely

412 posts

189 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
The points system seems fairly logical to me. Unless you have a pool of cars which are idenitcal or very similar then you couldn't simply do X number of days/hours per membership as everyone would want to most expensive/rare/exotic car. A points system accounts for this, so say 1000 points per year, where using a lower end car might use 100 points for a weekend, the top end stuff might be 300 points. This allows you as the company to flex points required to ensure supply=demand for all the cars you have in the collection. Given most people who would be members are likely to be fairly bright (an assumption based on the fact they have managed to be sucessful enough to earn the required income in the first place), I'm sure it wouldn't be beyond most of them to figure this simple system out.

nsa

1,704 posts

259 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
A way to simplify it would be to express membership in terms of days in the cheapest car in the fleet. 30 days in a Fiat 500 say. All other cars are priced off this base (eg E-Type is 5 days) and fractions of a day are allowed.


BoRED S2upid

21,135 posts

271 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
To me these are very expensive with yearly membership / points starting at thousands of pounds (I may be wrong) what I would do differently is cap the most expensive car at say £25k. With the cheapest say a £1500 MK1 MX5 availabel for £100 per day, 205GTI or a classic Mini £150 per day anyone? they would fly out you would need a fleet of the lower end cars.

mattdaniels

7,362 posts

313 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
BoRED S2upid said:
To me these are very expensive
BoRED S2upid said:
cheapest say, a £1500 MK1 MX5 availabel for £100 per day
FYI, Avis Prestige will do an Audi A3 cab in London for £102 for 24 hours.

I think 1500 quids worth of Mx5 snotter needs to be buttons not 100 quid a day laugh

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
BoRED S2upid said:
To me these are very expensive with yearly membership / points starting at thousands of pounds (I may be wrong) what I would do differently is cap the most expensive car at say £25k. With the cheapest say a £1500 MK1 MX5 availabel for £100 per day, 205GTI or a classic Mini £150 per day anyone? they would fly out you would need a fleet of the lower end cars.
I think you'd attract the "wrong type" of customers and your overheads would become very expensive as you kept having to fork out to fix (or replace) fubared older cars.

chris7676

2,685 posts

251 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
point = £

Anything else is just stupid as it only confuses the customer which still has to pay for the membership in £, hence I cannot see a 'marketing' reason to 'engineer' the points.

chris7676

2,685 posts

251 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
BoRED S2upid said:
To me these are very expensive with yearly membership / points starting at thousands of pounds (I may be wrong) what I would do differently is cap the most expensive car at say £25k. With the cheapest say a £1500 MK1 MX5 availabel for £100 per day, 205GTI or a classic Mini £150 per day anyone? they would fly out you would need a fleet of the lower end cars.
Club GT has quite many 'cheaper' cars, although not that extreme. I'm not a member, just aware of them.

strattonkillick

146 posts

246 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
mattdaniels said:
FYI, Avis Prestige will do an Audi A3 cab in London for £102 for 24 hours.

I think 1500 quids worth of Mx5 snotter needs to be buttons not 100 quid a day laugh
Except Avis Prestige will not do one day rentals for the weekend, and the price for the weekend is £272. Plus it's an auto which may not really appeal to the driver in you (although the whole car might not either!). I'd agree that an MX-5 needs to be pretty cheap though.

LooneyTunes

9,517 posts

189 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
MrH said:
What would you change if anything?
Delivery and collection always seems to be overlooked (outside London at least).

I looked at one a couple of years ago and came to the conclusion that the time spent getting to and from the cars (at either end of the weekend) would dramatically reduce the benefits to the extent that it no longer seemed worth pursuing.

madras

329 posts

240 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
BoRED S2upid said:
To me these are very expensive with yearly membership / points starting at thousands of pounds (I may be wrong) what I would do differently is cap the most expensive car at say £25k. With the cheapest say a £1500 MK1 MX5 availabel for £100 per day, 205GTI or a classic Mini £150 per day anyone? they would fly out you would need a fleet of the lower end cars.
ClubGT have an E39 M5 and E36 M3 for <£40 day and miles at 33pence.

SpeckledJim

34,574 posts

284 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
chris7676 said:
point = £

Anything else is just stupid as it only confuses the customer which still has to pay for the membership in £, hence I cannot see a 'marketing' reason to 'engineer' the points.
Divorcing the points from the £ is exactly the reason. You don't want people thinking in pounds.

Especially when you're putting prices up.

whythem

773 posts

208 months

Sunday 16th March 2014
quotequote all
Instead of points use colours or some other designation.

Loyalty/reward points discount system.

Fractional ownership

sider

2,061 posts

252 months

Monday 17th March 2014
quotequote all
Perhaps look to extend regions covered?

My brother in law looked a while back and most of the decent looking clubs he found were London based.

We're in the North West and despite only just getting running water and internet, we like cars too and some folk have a bit of money. There was a place he found near us but it had a Ferrari F355 and 360, that was it. Hardly much choice.

chris7676

2,685 posts

251 months

Monday 17th March 2014
quotequote all
whythem said:
Instead of points use colours or some other designation.

Loyalty/reward points discount system.

Fractional ownership
From complicated to ultracomplicated?
(I will go for purpley blue anyway, in the meantime I'm out wink

whythem

773 posts

208 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
How about reversing the "club" idea. A club for supercar owners who wish to offset their ownership costs buy being able to offer thier cars for hire. (which is sort of what Mr H is doing anyway) A national register of owners cars with an eBay style auction of hire days.

Owner places car for hire on the website, clics accept when the money and dates are right.

Buyer gets to choose from a national database of cars at a price they want to pay.

Supercar owner gets his car hired with insurance issues arranged and managed by the website (broker)

Website gets commission from both sides, and a registration fee from the owner and could also, once the fleet is big enough then offer owners cheap servicing/valeting/consumables through being able to bulk buy, and nick a bit more margin. Ensuring a fleet of clean well maintained cars with owners given a feedback rating for good service.

You could offer this to the trade also.

Acutally!!!!!smile

MrH

Original Poster:

484 posts

239 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
whythem said:
How about reversing the "club" idea. A club for supercar owners who wish to offset their ownership costs buy being able to offer thier cars for hire. (which is sort of what Mr H is doing anyway) A national register of owners cars with an eBay style auction of hire days.

Owner places car for hire on the website, clics accept when the money and dates are right.

Buyer gets to choose from a national database of cars at a price they want to pay.

Supercar owner gets his car hired with insurance issues arranged and managed by the website (broker)

Website gets commission from both sides, and a registration fee from the owner and could also, once the fleet is big enough then offer owners cheap servicing/valeting/consumables through being able to bulk buy, and nick a bit more margin. Ensuring a fleet of clean well maintained cars with owners given a feedback rating for good service.

You could offer this to the trade also.

Acutally!!!!!smile
This is exactly what we do already as a business (hiring owners sports/supercars), and literally in the process of forming a club for owners in exactly this way! Spooky! I did press on with a club format for anyone to join, but from feedback decided to change this to something involving our current owners, and new ones, with the option to add their cars into the fleet. Just in the process of changing things now on the club side, and have a good list of owners already.

DSLiverpool

16,577 posts

233 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
sider said:
Perhaps look to extend regions covered?

My brother in law looked a while back and most of the decent looking clubs he found were London based.

We're in the North West and despite only just getting running water and internet, we like cars too and some folk have a bit of money. There was a place he found near us but it had a Ferrari F355 and 360, that was it. Hardly much choice.
http://www.northernferrarihire.com/cars_and_tariffs.htm

chris7676

2,685 posts

251 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
whythem said:
How about reversing the "club" idea. A club for supercar owners who wish to offset their ownership costs buy being able to offer thier cars for hire. (which is sort of what Mr H is doing anyway) A national register of owners cars with an eBay style auction of hire days.

Owner places car for hire on the website, clics accept when the money and dates are right.

Buyer gets to choose from a national database of cars at a price they want to pay.

Supercar owner gets his car hired with insurance issues arranged and managed by the website (broker)

Website gets commission from both sides, and a registration fee from the owner and could also, once the fleet is big enough then offer owners cheap servicing/valeting/consumables through being able to bulk buy, and nick a bit more margin. Ensuring a fleet of clean well maintained cars with owners given a feedback rating for good service.

You could offer this to the trade also.

Acutally!!!!!smile
Good idea, I know there is already general 'rental' service website that, I cannot remember the name but definitely looked at their WWW sometime ago...