Is there a principle of fairness in British law?
Is there a principle of fairness in British law?
Author
Discussion

ED209

Original Poster:

6,031 posts

275 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
Without going into specifics does anybody with a legal knowledge have any idea if there is an over riding principle of fairness in british law?

My specific query is in relation to pensions really but say for example a person joins a pension scheme that has protection in law, the wording of the law means that if that particular law is changed but the government then it would be unlawful and open to a court challenge. Now the government has enacted a new law that whilst not changing the old law overrides it meaning that people who should have been legally protected loose out hugely whilst others are not disadvantaged at all.

Now in my opinion the government has acted cunningly and unfairly is side stepping a piece of existing legislation in order to disadvantage a group of people.

I don't want the usual argument over pensions, i am more interested if there is any principle of "fairness" in british or eurpoean law that might be used as an avenue to challenge the government.

trashbat

6,318 posts

184 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
An easier question back at you first: is there a contract?

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
The simple answer to your question is "No."

That doesn't mean that you have no case, that the government's actions are lawful, or that this is legal advice.

The government will be bound by specific provisions to be non-discriminatory, to apply any powers lawfully and may have a duty to take into account the rights of all concerned, but it does not expressly have to be 'fair.' For instance, there is a qualified right to enjoyment of property under Article 23 and a right to family life under Article 8 of the ECHR that may be engaged.

In any event, pensions law would apply first (and then the general constitutional principle that no Parliament may bind its successors) and only then will human rights law kick in as a constitutional provision. You can't simply say that this wasn't fair and therefore the law was invalid; you have to be much, much more specific in that. Typically this is the sort of thing that unions are very good at.

By the way, this is a public law question, not a contractual one, as far as I can see: which is not to say that you might not be able to achieve the result you want by contract law, but there's no indication of that coming into play as it is currently worded. In general, it would be easier to enforce a contractual right than to challenge legislation, but that's no good if (for instance) a particular company that should have funded a pension scheme is insolvent and therefore you're relying on statutory bodies to make up the shortfall.

ED209

Original Poster:

6,031 posts

275 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
I am talking about the police pension scheme 1986 and in particular section of the relevant act (now i know this will start the usual argument about public sector gold plated pensions blah blah blah) i am not interested in that argument but about are the changed being forced upon some people 100% legal.

I am talking about section 2 (1) and (4) which reads

(1)Any regulations made under section 1 above shall be so framed as to secure, for existing members of police forces, the results—

(a)as to compulsory age of retirement, and

(b)as to scale of pensions payable under the regulations, specified respectively in subsections (2) and (3) below.


(4)Regulations made under section 1 above shall not be invalid by reason that in fact they do not secure the results specified in subsections (2) and (3) above, but if the Secretary of State is satisfied, or it is held by the High Court or by the Court of Session, that any such regulations have failed to secure those results, the Secretary of State shall so soon as may be make under section 1 the necessary amending regulations, and any such amending regulations shall have effect as from the date of the coming into force of the regulations which they amend.

Basically this means that even if the scheme changes after you join an individual should not be negatively affected by those changes in terms of scale of pension or time needed to serve to get that pension. What the government however appears to have done in new public sector pensions bill is not to change the 1986 act but to override it thereby avoiding the possibility of any legal challenge ( well according to the police federation anyway) To me this seems unfair, avoiding a piece of legislation that was put in place to avoid people who have no industrial rights being shafted.


i am also interested in other possible avenues too such as age discrimination. For example i joined the police when i was 19, others who started on the same day as me were 36. Under the reforms they will get exactly the pension they signed unto whereas i will have to serve until i am 60 (or 55 with a substantially reduced pension) which means working 5 to 10 years more to get a lot less out. Could this be age discrimination?

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
I think (and you'll really want a lawyery type to speak on this) what that says is that the regulations are valid regardless of whether they meet the above tests, but if either the Secretary of State or a Court decide that the regulations do change the rules for new members then the Secretary of State must amend them. So if the Secretary of State is happy (and presumably she would be since she was responsible for the regulation change) then the avenue of appeal is through judicial review.

ED209

Original Poster:

6,031 posts

275 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
davepoth said:
I think (and you'll really want a lawyery type to speak on this) what that says is that the regulations are valid regardless of whether they meet the above tests, but if either the Secretary of State or a Court decide that the regulations do change the rules for new members then the Secretary of State must amend them. So if the Secretary of State is happy (and presumably she would be since she was responsible for the regulation change) then the avenue of appeal is through judicial review.
I knew this however, such a judicial review is apparently not possible because whilst the new pensions act does not change section 2 it side steps it.

Jonleeper

664 posts

260 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
I’ve not been involved in the police side of this but have had numerous discussions, with both those involved in drafting and implementing the changes, about the changes to the military pensions.

In essence what I have been told is that whatever you earned under the existing pension arrangements cannot be touched and is effectively frozen on the date that the changes come into place. You then effectively start to accrue a new pension under the new scheme. It was explained that they could force me onto the new scheme but could not backdate it to change what I had already gained. This means that if I serve past the change I can still retire at the old pension point and will be given the amount I earned under that scheme but will have to wait to get the rest earned under the new one. Overall this is less than I would have gained if the change had not taken place but is not as bad as if they did a calculation based solely on the new scheme.

ED209

Original Poster:

6,031 posts

275 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
Jonleeper said:
I’ve not been involved in the police side of this but have had numerous discussions, with both those involved in drafting and implementing the changes, about the changes to the military pensions.

In essence what I have been told is that whatever you earned under the existing pension arrangements cannot be touched and is effectively frozen on the date that the changes come into place. You then effectively start to accrue a new pension under the new scheme. It was explained that they could force me onto the new scheme but could not backdate it to change what I had already gained. This means that if I serve past the change I can still retire at the old pension point and will be given the amount I earned under that scheme but will have to wait to get the rest earned under the new one. Overall this is less than I would have gained if the change had not taken place but is not as bad as if they did a calculation based solely on the new scheme.
yes this is true however this means that retiring at 50 after 30 years service as i should have is not an option because then the pension accrued under the new pension will not be payable until state pension age (67) and the old pension will simply not be enough to retire as at 50 as i will not be entitled to 40/60ths that i signed up to but only to around 18/60ths. This 18/60ths will be enhanced to approx 24/60ths if i work to 55 to compensate for the double accrual i will miss out on due to the change.

I can then claim the new pension at 55 however the 17/55ths approx i will have accrued by then will be reduced by approx 25% because i would be retiring before 60.

To sum up i loose out hugely by taking any option. Working a lot more(5 to 10 years), paying in a lot more to receive a lot less than the supposedly legally protected pension I signed up for at 19 years of age.


I am not a person who doesn't accept the need for change but I due to my young joining age and length of service I will be one of the worst affected by this.
I would accept working another 2 or 3 years to get what i signed up for no problem but another 5-10 to get a lot less is a bit much to stomach.

Could there be an age discrimination case? like i said others who were 36 when they started on the same day as me will get exactly what they signed up for when they expected it whilst i will be shaftet all ends up for joining young and spending my youth rolling round with drunks on a weekend instead of enjoying time with my friends/family as a young man should. This was done with the knowledge that i could make up for it when i hit 50 but that has been taken away from me.

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
Consider that much smarter & more informed folks than us will have already looked at this- were there a case to put forward then it would have been proclaimed very loudly.

Also consider that the unspoken part of your original agreement appertained to longevity; the circumstances surrounding this have changed significantly, with all that this would imply.

CTE

1,524 posts

271 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
Yes it is a very unfair situation and technically wrong, and I sympathise, and there are lots of people who are in the same situation as you. There is however we are told not enough money, so thats it really. Got any ideas? There is no majic wand.
If anything could usefully be done, it would be to find out why it has all gone wrong....where has the money gone that was invested over the years, who is responsible, who was incompetant etc, so hopefully lessons can be learned for the future. Oh yes, and do not forget politics, i.e. promises made to buy votes, knowing full well the promises would be the responsibility of others.
However wrong it might all be, look on the positive side, you are a lot better off than most.

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
The Act is not a regulation and therefore the specific prior legislation is not relevant as to whether the actions are lawful.

A regulation is a statutory instrument (i.e., secondary legislation) made under powers devolved to the Secretary of State (in practice the Civil Service). The legislation introduced to amend the Scheme is an Act, i.e., primary legislation. It does not expressly repeal the earlier legislation but as this is new primary legislation, it does not need to follow the rules for secondary legislation.

To the extent that there is a conflict between the two Acts, the 'doctrine of implied repeal' applies and (if strictly necessary) the new legislation would take precedence.

The partial exception to this is the Human Rights Act. All legislation must be interpreted in line with the HRA 1998 and, if it is not possible to do so, the Court may make a declaration of incompatibility pertaining to the legislation. It is not possible to judicially review Parliament, as it would be a decision of the Secretary of State in making secondary legislation. However, the UK could be ordered by the ECHR to pass amending legislation in order to meet its treaty obligations.

Whatever you think of the politics and the practical situation, unless you can argue that the new law is in breach of either specific European legislation (I can't think of any) or the HRA (more of a chance, but not an especially appealing argument) it appears to be entirely within Parliament's powers to legislate for this outcome.

pitmansboots

1,372 posts

218 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
I guess the Home Secretary will be enjoying her pension while police chiefs and commissioners are trying to work out what the fu*k to do whith 55-60 year-old officers when there is no room at the bottom for new officers to fill spots when Saturday night is fight night.
We'll ge there in a decade or so.

Red 4

10,744 posts

218 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
pitmansboots said:
I guess the Home Secretary will be enjoying her pension while police chiefs and commissioners are trying to work out what the fu*k to do whith 55-60 year-old officers when there is no room at the bottom for new officers to fill spots when Saturday night is fight night.
We'll ge there in a decade or so.
It's quite simple - they'll be sacked for failing to meet the required standard on fitness tests, which will be increased from the current quite low standard.

If you are not deployable (which means passing fitness and OST) you'll have a year to get fit then bye bye.

It's part of a master plan - see The Winsor report.

Randy Winkman

22,836 posts

220 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
If it's any help, the same sort of thing is happening to Civil Service pensions. So the people working on it in Government are doing it to themselves as well.

pitmansboots

1,372 posts

218 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
Red 4 said:
pitmansboots said:
I guess the Home Secretary will be enjoying her pension while police chiefs and commissioners are trying to work out what the fu*k to do whith 55-60 year-old officers when there is no room at the bottom for new officers to fill spots when Saturday night is fight night.
We'll ge there in a decade or so.
It's quite simple - they'll be sacked for failing to meet the required standard on fitness tests, which will be increased from the current quite low standard.

If you are not deployable (which means passing fitness and OST) you'll have a year to get fit then bye bye.

It's part of a master plan - see The Winsor report.
We'll see. smile