Falsely accused of using phone when driving
Discussion
I've been accused of using my phone while driving. I was sitting in a queue at traffic lights and the phone lit up after resetting itself. The phone was sitting just behind my gearstick in a part of the centre console. Two orificers were standing nearby and must have seen it light up, who then walked over to the car. As it was about 4.45 pm it was dark outside, so the car was dark inside.
Some of you may say I'm stubborn, but I intend to go to court and fight it. If I was using my phone, I'd put my hands up and accept the three points. I've got nil points just now, although there's a ban for an unrelated offence almost five years ago.
This happened in Glasgow city centre. Can anyone give me an idea of what will happen when it goes to court? I'm going to get legal advice at some point next week if I can get time off work.
Some of you may say I'm stubborn, but I intend to go to court and fight it. If I was using my phone, I'd put my hands up and accept the three points. I've got nil points just now, although there's a ban for an unrelated offence almost five years ago.
This happened in Glasgow city centre. Can anyone give me an idea of what will happen when it goes to court? I'm going to get legal advice at some point next week if I can get time off work.
does your phone have an uptime counter on it? If so put the phone up against the TV and show the time on the TV then take a photo of the two. You can then work out the reboot time of the phone.
Now I know this does not prove you did not handle the phone but it does support your story that the phone rebooted. Of course, if the phone has rebooted since the incident then this won't help.
You need to emphasise that they never actually saw you handle it.
Now I know this does not prove you did not handle the phone but it does support your story that the phone rebooted. Of course, if the phone has rebooted since the incident then this won't help.
You need to emphasise that they never actually saw you handle it.
The phone should have a log of all calls (and texts) - simply show this to the Police (although I believe the offence isn't necessarily "making a call", just "using a hand-held device")
For what its worth, my HTC phone often resets itself, which causes the screen to light up. However, my phone is in a dedicated cradle, so its never "hand-held"
For what its worth, my HTC phone often resets itself, which causes the screen to light up. However, my phone is in a dedicated cradle, so its never "hand-held"
contractor said:
does your phone have an uptime counter on it? If so put the phone up against the TV and show the time on the TV then take a photo of the two. You can then work out the reboot time of the phone.
Now I know this does not prove you did not handle the phone but it does support your story that the phone rebooted. Of course, if the phone has rebooted since the incident then this won't help.
You need to emphasise that they never actually saw you handle it.
I've just googled this and apparently Blackberry's don't have an uptime counter Now I know this does not prove you did not handle the phone but it does support your story that the phone rebooted. Of course, if the phone has rebooted since the incident then this won't help.
You need to emphasise that they never actually saw you handle it.

Digger said:
Phones light up all the time for all sorts of reason. Did they state that they saw you handling it?
When they said that I was using it, I asked how could I possibly be using it if I didn't have it in my hand. Their reply was that they seen it in my hand.In regards to the Brocklebank reference, I hope that isn't something that I would need to use but thanks for mentioning it agtlaw.
daveinaravecave said:
Digger said:
Phones light up all the time for all sorts of reason. Did they state that they saw you handling it?
When they said that I was using it, I asked how could I possibly be using it if I didn't have it in my hand. Their reply was that they seen it in my hand.Streaky
Where's all the resident bib saying their colleges only speak gospel, don't lie and that you must of been on the phone.
Or a case of another couple of bad apples....... Pfffft
For what it's worth op I think you've got f all chance of winning this if they produce 'statements' saying they saw you using the phone.
Or a case of another couple of bad apples....... Pfffft
For what it's worth op I think you've got f all chance of winning this if they produce 'statements' saying they saw you using the phone.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


