Audi Allroad 3.0TDi in trouble
Audi Allroad 3.0TDi in trouble
Author
Discussion

AdamAllroad

Original Poster:

9 posts

159 months

Sunday 24th November 2013
quotequote all
Hi I'm in desperation now with my allroad which has a loud knocking noise. After taking it to Preston Audi, they had it on all diagnostics with no issues showing. Oil pressure fine. Compression fine. No loss of power when driving. No smoke coming from exhausts. Audi swapped injectors but noise didn't move. They said they wanted £2000 to take engine out to further investigate. I declined & took it to a recommended VW/Audi specialist who looked into cylinders & thought he'd found scouring on two cylinders. After taking engine out & stripping head, he now says that the minimal scouring would not have caused the loud knocking noise. He does not want to strip the bottom end and recommends buying a second hand engine!

Problem is it's the 'new' 2007 onwards 3.0TDi and there aren't any engines anywhere. I just can't believe Audi and a 'specialist' could not isolate an obvious knocking noise.

If anyone has any ideas, clues, I would be most grateful otherwise it's a breaker??

It's March 2007 registered Audi Allroad 3.0TDi tipauto, metallic silver, satnav, aero alloys, 127,000 miles, good Continental tyres, tow bar, full leather (have an Audi roofbox & bars).

Raven Flyer

1,645 posts

255 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
It is be possible to measure combined little and big end float using an accurate depth gauge measure and a sucker stuck on the top of the pistons. You can measure the extremes between top and bottom of the travel created by the void around the shells. It won't be a precise measurement but will throw up if one or more cylinders have a big amount of float, compared to the others.

If that shows no major issues, then it wasn't a big or little end problem.

Are you sure the sound wasn't a blowing exhaust manifold gasket? The sound is very similar to an engine on the cusp of letting go.


Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
I've only ever seen a single bottom end problem on one of those that we thought was caused by the owner servicing it on the cheap (he was being charged suspiciously little for the oil).

I didn't hear it myself as we bought the car off him after the engine was replaced but his description of it was a horrible rattle at idle that rose with revs. He also had a dealer exhaust all other avenues as they hadn't heard of one failing either.