Hit a Taxi, What now?
Author
Discussion

Shwar25

Original Poster:

6,565 posts

228 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
On my way to work this morning, while already established on a roundabout a taxi appeared from my left, and stopped over the white line.

I tried scrubbing off as much speed as possible but still hit his drivers door.

He is trying to claim I hit him and he was already on the roundabout before me, no witnesses stopped at the scene.

Any idea how to proceed?

5lab

1,951 posts

227 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
insurance. Taxi driver is entitled to claim for days off work whilst he doesn't have a car (if he can't hire a replacement) so it could get expensive. Did you take photos at the scene to show the car positioning? it should be his fault, but roundabout issues often go 50:50

Gillett66

98 posts

174 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
Shwar25 said:
On my way to work this morning, while already established on a roundabout a taxi appeared from my left, and stopped over the white line.

I tried scrubbing off as much speed as possible but still hit his drivers door.

He is trying to claim I hit him and he was already on the roundabout before me, no witnesses stopped at the scene.

Any idea how to proceed?
He stopped so far over the white line you hit the driver's door? Were you going straight over? Sounds like he was plannign on driving straight through it.

williamp

20,478 posts

304 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
Unfortunantly there will be about 40 witnesses who will appear, fellow taxi drivers who just happen to be there and saw you speeding, swerve nto him, lucky soneone wsnt killed, needs a new taxi from this etc etc

jatopack

179 posts

261 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
Hit the drivers door? - Is this not a clear-cut case of "Failing to give way" - How big was the round-about?

The theory is generally - IF there is a car on your right - then "Give Way"......

creampuff

6,511 posts

174 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
I would have thought that roundabout + damage to driver door of taxi indicates 100% fault on part of taxi.

Was it a Hackney cab (from my observation, usually know how to drive) or private hire vehicle (often NFI about driving or personal hygiene either)?

McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
williamp said:
Unfortunantly there will be about 40 witnesses who will appear, fellow taxi drivers who just happen to be there and saw you speeding, swerve nto him, lucky soneone wsnt killed, needs a new taxi from this etc etc
and his 25 passengers all now have 2 broken necks each and a total of 75 broken legs between them

Shwar25

Original Poster:

6,565 posts

228 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
It's the witness thing that worries me. No one stopped roadside, and the fact his taxi base is about 8 miles away negates the risk of any of his mates been in the area at that time.

The roundabout is the junction of Aberford Road and Bar Lane in Wakefield, I was heading straight over (out of wakefield) and he was coming along Bar Lane to go left onto Aberford Road.

The giveway line is quite far back but he stopped way over it.

I have reported to my insurance already.

Edit: Creampuff, it was a Skoda Octavia (Private Hire)

Gillett66

98 posts

174 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
creampuff said:
I would have thought that roundabout + damage to driver door of taxi indicates 100% fault on part of taxi.

Was it a Hackney cab (from my observation, usually know how to drive) or private hire vehicle (often NFI about driving or personal hygiene either)?
Why would you think that of any car hit in the driver's door?

Guffy

2,372 posts

296 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
It does appeat that unless you were doing silly speeds (in which case you would have thought the impact would have been more sever), then you must have been on the roundabout first?


SimonMaidenhead

2,655 posts

234 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
Gillett66 said:
Why would you think that of any car hit in the driver's door?
Because in England we drive on the left and give way to the right on roundabouts, so therefore the taxi driver couldn't have given way.

SimonMaidenhead

2,655 posts

234 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
Guffy said:
It does appeat that unless you were doing silly speeds (in which case you would have thought the impact would have been more sever), then you must have been on the roundabout first?

Is that redish car at 11 o'clock on the wrong side of the road?

Rick101

7,191 posts

181 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
It doesn't really make any difference to you thats it's a taxi. Just claim through your insurance as usual.


Shwar25

Original Poster:

6,565 posts

228 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
Yeah, I'm very sure I was on the rounabout first, damage isn't too severe, bumper scuffed, wing slightly buckled and the very edge of bonnet is folded over.

I probably entered the roundabout at 20mph, had no throttle as I know it can be greasey there, and obviously I braked before impact.

covboy

2,593 posts

205 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
SimonMaidenhead said:
Is that redish car at 11 o'clock on the wrong side of the road?
Probably a Taxi !

GTIR

24,741 posts

297 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
5lab said:
insurance. Taxi driver is entitled to claim for days off work whilst he doesn't have a car (if he can't hire a replacement) so it could get expensive. Did you take photos at the scene to show the car positioning? it should be his fault, but roundabout issues often go 50:50
Where did you get that from?

He is entitled to a private hire loan car (£180+ per day) until his car is fixed, assuming it does not go 50/50, and that's if a claims company is used. I doubt he would use a loan car if going through his insurance company as they would deal with it and claim the money back after from the third party, if liability is proven.

You can't just claim loss of earnings willy nilly.


Oh, if it's a PH vehicle then you can't legally call it a "taxi" as that is only for Hackney carriage vehicles.

Edited by GTIR on Monday 25th November 11:14

silverfoxcc

8,478 posts

176 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
A question.

you a driving along the major road, and from a side road on your left someone pulls out/overshoots the stop/give way sign and you are unable to stop in time and hit him

Whose fault ins wise?

Now straighten the roundabout out and you have the same scenario

Well thats what i would ask the ins co first

Centurion07

10,395 posts

278 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
silverfoxcc said:
A question.

you a driving along the major road, and from a side road on your left someone pulls out/overshoots the stop/give way sign and you are unable to stop in time and hit him

Whose fault ins wise?

Now straighten the roundabout out and you have the same scenario

Well thats what i would ask the ins co first
It's not the same scenario with a roundabout though is it? Pulling out from a side road onto another road means you have to give way to traffic (from either direction) regardless of positioning. With roundabouts, legally speaking, whoever crosses their line and enters the roundabout first has priority.

Although the roundabout in this case doesn't look all that small, how many times have you seen someone come flying up to a mini roundabout from your right at a speed that means YOU have to stop, even though you could quite clearly enter the roundabout before them?

The rule for roundabouts is you have to give way to traffic ALREADY ESTABLISHED ON THE ROUNDABOUT, so just because someone gets hit in their driver's door, it doesn't automatically mean they're at fault (legally anyway, their observation and speed judgement is another matter!).

covboy

2,593 posts

205 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
Centurion07 said:
It's not the same scenario with a roundabout though is it? Pulling out from a side road onto another road means you have to give way to traffic (from either direction) regardless of positioning. With roundabouts, legally speaking, whoever crosses their line and enters the roundabout first has priority.

Although the roundabout in this case doesn't look all that small, how many times have you seen someone come flying up to a mini roundabout from your right at a speed that means YOU have to stop, even though you could quite clearly enter the roundabout before them?

The rule for roundabouts is you have to give way to traffic ALREADY ESTABLISHED ON THE ROUNDABOUT, so just because someone gets hit in their driver's door, it doesn't automatically mean they're at fault (legally anyway, their observation and speed judgement is another matter!).
Are you arguing with your own arguments there ? biggrin

iva cosworth

44,044 posts

194 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
A customer i deliver to,scraped a cab so lightly but it ended with a world of pain with

whiplash and when the insurance tried to assess the cab damage it was never parked where

it was supposed to be.

Went on for 3 months for a scratch,cost £10K apparently....rolleyes

I have no reason to believe that this is BS.