Parking eye free car park "charge"
Discussion
I know there's been a million threads of this nature, but the advice constantly seems to change and I can't find any general consensus.
My mother recently went to cwmbran retail park, and as she's disabled and finds it difficult to walk long distances she overstayed by 34 minutes.
I've just about managed to convince her she doesn't immediately need to pay up as it's NOT a fine, just an invoice - but could someone advise on the best way to proceed and what to put in an appeal letter?
i've attached a link to the letter
http://i.imgur.com/HZ59LkT.jpg
My mother recently went to cwmbran retail park, and as she's disabled and finds it difficult to walk long distances she overstayed by 34 minutes.
I've just about managed to convince her she doesn't immediately need to pay up as it's NOT a fine, just an invoice - but could someone advise on the best way to proceed and what to put in an appeal letter?
i've attached a link to the letter
http://i.imgur.com/HZ59LkT.jpg
Edited by folos on Monday 25th November 14:46
There is no blanket advice to give because each instance will be specific to its circumstances.
The law changed last year to allow PPCs in certain circumstances to chase the Registered Keeper for unpaid charges.
It is a common misconception that any loss must always be itemised to that individual case and therefore you cannot be held to account for damages.
The law changed last year to allow PPCs in certain circumstances to chase the Registered Keeper for unpaid charges.
It is a common misconception that any loss must always be itemised to that individual case and therefore you cannot be held to account for damages.
Terminator X said:
I wouldn't pay and would rather run it out to its conclusion. Your Old Dear might not want the hassle though?
TX.
PS Remove that link, scrub out the address etc and post it back up!
whoops!!TX.
PS Remove that link, scrub out the address etc and post it back up!
I think she might end up paying it despite everything i've told her, and told her to read up on but £50-£85 for 34 minutes parking in a free car park is quite frankly insane. I think the amount will put her off paying it as it's a piss take - but I think she'd rather it not have to go to court but doesn't know who to appeal to or what to write.
For some reason 10ps would rather everyone paid these speculative invoices from Parking Eye (now part of Capita...).
DO NOT pay it. Get over to http://forums.pepipoo.com/index.php?showforum=60 and post up as much as you can. The fact that your mother is disabled (registered hopefully) will play a large part of this - I suspect there are no special treatments for disabled people and time?
Ignore 10ps's advice, and also fight the 'genuine pre-estimate of loss' argument.
Do raise an initial soft appeal to Parking Eye and collect your Popla code. You/your mother has nothing to lose, PE will pay to defend their case and will probably lose. If you lose at Popla, it cost you nothing - if PE lose, it cost them cash. Play the game!
Source? A recent victory over Parking Eye based on 'genuine pre-estimate of loss'.
ETA - just read the form. First thing to do is actually complain to the manager of the Morrisons store. They can and do quash these speculative invoices.
DO NOT pay it. Get over to http://forums.pepipoo.com/index.php?showforum=60 and post up as much as you can. The fact that your mother is disabled (registered hopefully) will play a large part of this - I suspect there are no special treatments for disabled people and time?
Ignore 10ps's advice, and also fight the 'genuine pre-estimate of loss' argument.
Do raise an initial soft appeal to Parking Eye and collect your Popla code. You/your mother has nothing to lose, PE will pay to defend their case and will probably lose. If you lose at Popla, it cost you nothing - if PE lose, it cost them cash. Play the game!
Source? A recent victory over Parking Eye based on 'genuine pre-estimate of loss'.
ETA - just read the form. First thing to do is actually complain to the manager of the Morrisons store. They can and do quash these speculative invoices.
Edited by Puggit on Monday 25th November 15:38
Puggit said:
For some reason 10ps would rather everyone paid these speculative invoices from Parking Eye (now part of Capita...).
DO NOT pay it
Where people have genuinely and without good reason broken the terms of parking laid down by the land owner (or his agent/contractor), I believe they should pay what they owe. DO NOT pay it
Why shouldn't they?
10 Pence Short said:
Where people have genuinely and without good reason broken the terms of parking laid down by the land owner (or his agent/contractor), I believe they should pay what they owe.
Why shouldn't they?
£85 for 34 minutes overstay?Why shouldn't they?
And yes, she is registered disabled and has a blue badge
10 Pence Short said:
Puggit said:
For some reason 10ps would rather everyone paid these speculative invoices from Parking Eye (now part of Capita...).
DO NOT pay it
Where people have genuinely and without good reason broken the terms of parking laid down by the land owner (or his agent/contractor), I believe they should pay what they owe. DO NOT pay it
Why shouldn't they?
Puggit said:
ne mention of this and Morrisons will have the problem resolved. Imagine this story hitting the press.
ThisI'm not sure if Morrisons own this store themselves? It's not part of the cwmbran retail park which is owned by British Land.
Contact the landlord direct explaining the circumstances and they'll ask the parking company to cancel. I've done just this (as landlord) recently for a lady in exactly the same predicament.
rewc said:
Who determines what a good reason is?
The body controlling the land and then, ultimately if pursued, the courts.I imagine most people who park cars are familiar with the concept of controlled private parking. Equally drivers can generally read and therefore know what the terms and conditions are.
Where PPCs break the rules or the law or behave otherwise unfairly, people should defend their rights. Otherwise, why shouldn't land owners have right to control use of their land?
PurpleMoonlight said:
Huh, you seriously think the press will give a stuff over a blue badge holder being charged for overstaying parking. Councils do it every day of the week ...
I know Morrisons will give a stuff about the threat of such bad publicity. The threat wouldn't even need to be implied by the driver/OP.Puggit said:
I know Morrisons will give a stuff about the threat of such bad publicity. The threat wouldn't even need to be implied by the driver/OP.
I would venture to suggest blackmailing Morrisons over what you view as an extorted parking charge may seem a touch hypocritical, in he circumstances.10 Pence Short said:
Puggit said:
I know Morrisons will give a stuff about the threat of such bad publicity. The threat wouldn't even need to be implied by the driver/OP.
I would venture to suggest blackmailing Morrisons over what you view as an extorted parking charge may seem a touch hypocritical, in he circumstances.As I said above - just write to Morrisons (assuming they're the landlord) and explain the circumstances
10 Pence Short said:
I would venture to suggest blackmailing Morrisons over what you view as an extorted parking charge may seem a touch hypocritical, in he circumstances.
As I pointed out - no blackmail necessary. Morrisons management would be horrified to find out they are treating disabled customers the same as able bodied customers. Disability discrimination act 2002 and all that.Oops - I think I just pointed out that Parking Eye aren't playing by the rules.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



