Accident with Company Van - No Insurance Information Given
Accident with Company Van - No Insurance Information Given
Author
Discussion

lenny007

Original Poster:

1,489 posts

252 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Afternoon all

Just after a bit of advice following an accident last week. Short version is that our company van was hit by a car being driven by a garage employee. Not long after the accident, the employee reversed the car away from the accident and straight back into their workshops.

Luckily we managed to get photos of the incident as well as of the driver. We also have two witnesses to the incident and the garage staff are not contesting that it was their fault. All well and good so far.

However, as of today (4 days after the event) we still have not got the insurance details from them. The driver at the time has been suspended prior to be sacked as he apparently had his licence revoked and did not tell the garage.

Therefore, their insurance company is stating they are not liable as he was not licenced to drive the vehicle. My own insurance brokers have stated that they will be pursuing the garages company no matter what and they'll see what happens.

To make matters worse, the car which hit our van was a customers car and it seems the garage is standing by their obligations to repair said car. They have offered to repair our van but we have turned the offer down as we prefer to sort it out via the insurance company.

Finally, our employee stated he had some discomfort in his collar bone but that he felt ok. As i understand it, should problems develop later on in this area and it is attributable to the accident, if we settle without the insurance company's being involved, he won't be able to make a claim. Is this correct?

So my other query is this - can i proceed with our claim without the insurance policy number being provided and are the garage obliged under law to provide details to us or the insurance company or is it only the police they are obliged to contact?

Thanks in advance, really appreciate it.

anothernameitist

1,500 posts

166 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
I might be totally misleading you here, hope not, but the company should have employee liability insurance and therefore your insurers could claim aganst that rather than the vehicle policy, its just a thought.

Either way its for your insurance company to chase, but don't let them settle 50/ 50.

The employye has been dishonest, but have the garage been negliagent in not checking ona regular basis drivers licences, once again me think out aloud

scdan4

1,299 posts

191 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
more thinking out loud...

If you have evidence of the car that hit your van, can you not take it up with the car owners insurers. That should start the ball rolling I would have thought. (and I would assume something the garage would want to avoid?)

Or have I missed the point?

bltamil1

364 posts

175 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all

As I understand it, it makes no difference whether the other driver was licenced/insured/banned or anything else.

The garage insurance company must effectively stand in the shoes of the garage and, assuming liability is established, will have to settle your claim.

If the company was not operating within the terms of its insurance, this is something for the insurance co to take up with them as a separate issue, one in which you have no interest.

I could, of course, be wrong....

Hope this helps,

NH1

1,333 posts

160 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
If insurance has to pay for damage caused by your car if it is nicked I would imagine it would have to pay out in this scenario.

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
scdan4 said:
more thinking out loud...

If you have evidence of the car that hit your van, can you not take it up with the car owners insurers. That should start the ball rolling I would have thought. (and I would assume something the garage would want to avoid?)

Or have I missed the point?
Is the best course of action.

You can look the details up on www.askmid.com for a small fee.

The Road Traffic Act makes the Insurers of the vehicle liable irrespective of whether the driver was coverd by the policy

lenny007

Original Poster:

1,489 posts

252 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Many thanks for getting back to me.

In my opinion, the garage are trying all ways to get us to settle for the works to be done without insurance company's being involved - for whatever reason. However, for the sake of our employee (who frankly is as genuine as they come), we'd be remiss to settle and leave him hanging if he ever had to make a claim for damages caused by the accident. Furthermore, i suppose it would leave us wide open to having a claim made against us by our employee and frankly, why should we put ourselves in such a situation?

At least it's reassuring to be told that what i initially suspected is correct.

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
If you've not got their insurance details how do you know they are saying they're not liable?

Just leave it to your insurance company to deal with. They'll sort it out.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
The garage and their insurers remain liable for the damage caused by the employee. How they subsequently sort it out amongst themselves is irrelevant.

How you settle your damage claim has no bearing at all on your employees potential Injury claim.

Rubin215

4,201 posts

187 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Frolic and detour.

The garage should have a system in place to ensure that any employee who may be required to drive a vehicle holds the correct licence for it and they may try to argue that the employee's actions were a frolic (he knew he had no licence so knew he should not have been driving a vehicle). However, even if the system is in place, it has failed as the employee was still able to access and operate the vehicle.
If there is no system in place and the garage has relied on the honesty of its employees to declare bans etc, it is more than reasonably foreseeable that he would continue to drive while banned as his employment may have been at stake or he may have been paid less.

Fairly standard tort of negligence; garage (and their insurers) remain liable.

Edited by Rubin215 on Tuesday 26th November 22:45

KelWedge

1,288 posts

216 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Rubin215 said:
Frolic and detour.

The garage should have a system in place to ensure that any employee who may be required to drive a vehicle holds the correct licence for it and they may try to argue that the employee's actions were a frolic (he knew he had no licence so knew he should not have been driving a vehicle). However, even if the system is in place, it has failed as the employee was still able to access and operate the vehicle.
If there is no system in place and the garage has relied on the honesty of its employees to declare bans etc, it is more than reasonably foreseeable that he would continue to drive while banned as his employment may have been at stake or he may have been paid less.

Fairly standard tort of negligence; garage (and their insurers) remain liable.

Edited by Rubin215 on Tuesday 26th November 22:45
What he said smile 100%

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Is it not a legal requirement to provide details of the insurer in such an occurrence?

If so, report to BiB?

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Wednesday 27th November 2013
quotequote all
MrBig said:
Is it not a legal requirement to provide details of the insurer in such an occurrence?

If so, report to BiB?
If the incident happened on private land why would the BiB be interested?
As others have said leave it to the OP's insurer to sort out with the garage.
It should be covered by the garage's traders policy.

If that doesn't suffice they should have public liability cover which might apply.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Wednesday 27th November 2013
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
If the incident happened on private land why would the BiB be interested?
As others have said leave it to the OP's insurer to sort out with the garage.
It should be covered by the garage's traders policy.

If that doesn't suffice they should have public liability cover which might apply.
Are my posts invisible???????

Rubin215

4,201 posts

187 months

Wednesday 27th November 2013
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
Who said that...?


hehe

9mm

3,128 posts

241 months

Wednesday 27th November 2013
quotequote all
General Fluff said:
If you've not got their insurance details how do you know they are saying they're not liable?

Just leave it to your insurance company to deal with. They'll sort it out.
This last piece of advice every time. You are just opening a can of worms by going via any other route. You might also consider your duty of care to your employeee. Play it by the book, which means letting your insurance company sort it out.

lenny007

Original Poster:

1,489 posts

252 months

Wednesday 27th November 2013
quotequote all
Once again, many thanks for the replies. To answer a couple of points raised.

1. Immediately after the accident, the other driver got out of the car, apologised, said the brakes had locked and that it was their fault.

2. The accident was in an industrial estate.

3. I've no intention of doing anything other than going via the insurance company. My initial post was to wonder whether or not the third party was obliged by law to disclose their insurance details to me or not. I understand that they are required to do so if the police are involved but not sure if it's just the parties involved in the accident.


LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Wednesday 27th November 2013
quotequote all
Your broker / insurer will be able to find their insurers with ease.