Steering rack knocking - replace or not? - tame technician
Discussion
When stationary I get a knocking sound if I turn the steering wheel harshly.
Audi main dealer has checked it out with stethescope and says there's some play and it would need a new rack @ £1,680.14 fitted inc vat to resolve the issue, but that it doesn't especially need doing. They weren't sure if it would get worse and said they didn't think it was dangerous. A different Audi dealer didn't pick up on it when it was MOT'd a month ago.
Does anyone have an opinion on this - maybe tame technician?
If it's dangerous or is only going to get worse than I may aswell just get it done.
I should add I only experience the noise when stationary and turn the wheel very quickly. When moving I'd never know there was "play"
Car is a 57 plate 2.0 s tronic s line with 75k on clock.
Audi main dealer has checked it out with stethescope and says there's some play and it would need a new rack @ £1,680.14 fitted inc vat to resolve the issue, but that it doesn't especially need doing. They weren't sure if it would get worse and said they didn't think it was dangerous. A different Audi dealer didn't pick up on it when it was MOT'd a month ago.
Does anyone have an opinion on this - maybe tame technician?
If it's dangerous or is only going to get worse than I may aswell just get it done.
I should add I only experience the noise when stationary and turn the wheel very quickly. When moving I'd never know there was "play"
Car is a 57 plate 2.0 s tronic s line with 75k on clock.
REALIST123 said:
In all seriousness, why would you turn the steering very quickly when stationary? Is this something you do often, which might explain the premature wear in the rack?
I would suggest you stop doing that and see how it goes, a slightly worn rack isn't going to fall apart.
Steering felt different to my previous A3 so I was just testing it. Don't worry this is not something I reguarly do!I would suggest you stop doing that and see how it goes, a slightly worn rack isn't going to fall apart.
If there is no play or very very little, i.e when you turn the steering wheel the road wheels move then I would leave it.
If you rock the steering wheel a few degress left and right and the road wheels dont move then I would consider getting it done.
The new ones from Audi are very expensive, there will be companies out there that can sell you an exchange rebuilt unit, be aware a few sensors need setting up/ calibrating upon replacement so a VAG specialist is much better than any random garage that may not have the equipment to do this.
If you rock the steering wheel a few degress left and right and the road wheels dont move then I would consider getting it done.
The new ones from Audi are very expensive, there will be companies out there that can sell you an exchange rebuilt unit, be aware a few sensors need setting up/ calibrating upon replacement so a VAG specialist is much better than any random garage that may not have the equipment to do this.
Its definatly not going to get better so as time passes / more wear it will get worse.
Based on your description its not damgerous in my opinion, but I havent inspected the car.
http://www.bba-reman.com/index.aspx
Email these guys for a price on an exchange rack if you are that worried about it.
Based on your description its not damgerous in my opinion, but I havent inspected the car.
http://www.bba-reman.com/index.aspx
Email these guys for a price on an exchange rack if you are that worried about it.
Tame Technician said:
Its definatly not going to get better so as time passes / more wear it will get worse.
Based on your description its not damgerous in my opinion, but I havent inspected the car.
http://www.bba-reman.com/index.aspx
Email these guys for a price on an exchange rack if you are that worried about it.
Thanks, have done. £300 plus VATBased on your description its not damgerous in my opinion, but I havent inspected the car.
http://www.bba-reman.com/index.aspx
Email these guys for a price on an exchange rack if you are that worried about it.
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


