Should swearing on oath be abolished?
Discussion
Saw this posted on another forum, thought it would make for an interesting discussion...
"In court, should this outdated act be confined to the history books?
Are witnesses really that bothered about putting their hand on a book written thousands of years ago? I can't imagine any accused would buckle under questioning because they have sworn on the bible?
We already have 'perjury' so anyone giving evidence is legally obliged not to lie so why bother with this tradition.
Then once that has gone we can make a start on getting rid of the wigs/robes!"
"In court, should this outdated act be confined to the history books?
Are witnesses really that bothered about putting their hand on a book written thousands of years ago? I can't imagine any accused would buckle under questioning because they have sworn on the bible?
We already have 'perjury' so anyone giving evidence is legally obliged not to lie so why bother with this tradition.
Then once that has gone we can make a start on getting rid of the wigs/robes!"
littlegreenfairy said:
What is the atheist version? The Daily Mail?
Something along the lines of "I solemnly and sincerely affirm...". I used that one for my jury duty.There was a thread on this a while back about the removal of religion from official process - a good idea in my opinion as I think government and the legal system should be secular. We are becoming a more secular country so I think it will happen over time, but not yet - too many people still describe themselves as "Christian" despite not attending church or participating in any way, so the religious lobbies still have a lot of power.
roboxm3 said:
When I did jury service a few years ago we were given the option, to either swear on the bible / to god or the atheist version.
I believe the choices for Jurors are:1. Swear on a Bible
2. Swear on another religious book of your choosing
3. Non religious "affirmation"
The statements carry equivalent "weight" so far as the court is concerned.
So in conclusion I don't think that swearing on a Bible needs to be abolished. It's there for people who want to do it, and there's equivalent alternatives for people who don't.
Is there a wider question of "what is the point?" because you're assuming that the swearing/affirmation will have zero effect on someone intent on lieing? Maybe, but also maybe it's good to include these aspects of "pantomime" to help remind everyone (lay people who are not so familiar with court) that it's "serious business". Similar to how the pantomime around all the wiring up etc for a polygraph test is actually part of the process of putting pressure on the subject. It may or may not help to have quite such a lengthy set-up process in terms of how the machine works, but the pantomime itself has a subconscious effect. So I think I'm trying to say that whilst it certainly won't affect everyone (i.e. there will be people who are unphased) I think that it WILL affect SOME people. If it makes anyone that bit more nervous it could lead them to either telling the truth, or just being worse liars. This applies not only to the defendant but also witnesses etc.
TLDR: It might work on some people, so don't dump it.
I have to get clients to 'swear' now and again - most aren't bothered with the Bible, but one or two want to do it properly, and one or two noticeably take things more seriously when the Bible is proffered.
There are alternatives though, as listed above, and you can swear (as opposed to 'affirm') without a bible - this is the Scottish version, which has similar wording, but with a raised hand.
The other alternative used quite commonly for day-to-day stuff in England is the 'Statutory Declaration', which is not religious and, I believe, came about as a result of the multi-faith society.
There are alternatives though, as listed above, and you can swear (as opposed to 'affirm') without a bible - this is the Scottish version, which has similar wording, but with a raised hand.
The other alternative used quite commonly for day-to-day stuff in England is the 'Statutory Declaration', which is not religious and, I believe, came about as a result of the multi-faith society.
mrmr96 said:
I believe the choices for Jurors are:
1. Swear on a Bible
2. Swear on another religious book of your choosing
3. Non religious "affirmation"
The statements carry equivalent "weight" so far as the court is concerned.
But not necessarily to any audience (jurors, family of the acused etc.) stay from the norm and people will judge. 1. Swear on a Bible
2. Swear on another religious book of your choosing
3. Non religious "affirmation"
The statements carry equivalent "weight" so far as the court is concerned.
The word Testimony comes from the same Latin roots as Testicle.
In court, Romans would swear on thier nuts they were telling the truth.
If they were found to by lying they were taken off.
This is not a joke.
(Woman couldn't give testimony back then)
I think they should bring it back.
Women could swear on, um.... Something else.
In court, Romans would swear on thier nuts they were telling the truth.
If they were found to by lying they were taken off.
This is not a joke.
(Woman couldn't give testimony back then)
I think they should bring it back.
Women could swear on, um.... Something else.
testis means witnesses (hence 'testify', 'testament')
testicles is the diminutive, little witnesses
in Roman law, evidence from only one witness wasn't enough, you needed two (testis unus, testis nullus - one witness equals no winesses)
so witnesses always came in twos, hence testicles, the two witnesses to your manhood
testicles is the diminutive, little witnesses
in Roman law, evidence from only one witness wasn't enough, you needed two (testis unus, testis nullus - one witness equals no winesses)
so witnesses always came in twos, hence testicles, the two witnesses to your manhood
Snowboy said:
The word Testimony comes from the same Latin roots as Testicle.
In court, Romans would swear on thier nuts they were telling the truth.
If they were found to by lying they were taken off.
This is not a joke.
(Woman couldn't give testimony back then)
I think they should bring it back.
Women could swear on, um.... Something else.
Or not...In court, Romans would swear on thier nuts they were telling the truth.
If they were found to by lying they were taken off.
This is not a joke.
(Woman couldn't give testimony back then)
I think they should bring it back.
Women could swear on, um.... Something else.
Wordorigins said:
There is bit of folklore floating about that the word testify (with its associated forms like testimony and testament) derives from testicle. The legend has it that ancient Romans would hold their testes while swearing oaths. This is not true. The word does not derive from testicle, nor did Romans swear oaths on their private parts.
Testify, et. al., derives from the Latin testis meaning witness. Testicle also derives from testis. The testes are witnesses to a man's virility.
Testify, et. al., derives from the Latin testis meaning witness. Testicle also derives from testis. The testes are witnesses to a man's virility.
A non-thread. You don't have to swear an oath on a bible (or any other religious fiction). In fact, the Christian oath in Scottish courts doesn't use a bible whether for witnesses or for jurors.
Anybody can affirm and this has been the case for a very long time. The penalties for perjury are the same whether you affirm or swear on oath on a copy of (insert fiction of choice).
Anybody can affirm and this has been the case for a very long time. The penalties for perjury are the same whether you affirm or swear on oath on a copy of (insert fiction of choice).
matchmaker said:
A non-thread. You don't have to swear an oath on a bible (or any other religious fiction). In fact, the Christian oath in Scottish courts doesn't use a bible whether for witnesses or for jurors.
Anybody can affirm and this has been the case for a very long time. The penalties for perjury are the same whether you affirm or swear on oath on a copy of Harry Potter and the Philosophers Stone.
?Anybody can affirm and this has been the case for a very long time. The penalties for perjury are the same whether you affirm or swear on oath on a copy of Harry Potter and the Philosophers Stone.
As for the original question, no.
If you are not religious then use the affirmation. To be honest anyone who isn't religious but uses an oath should be done for contempt of court!

It should be abolished because most jurors are thick. When I did jury service, witnesses who chose to affirm were questioned in the jury room as "why didn't he swear on the bible, what has he got to hide?"
Most people are too stupid to understand about atheism etc, and just see it as someone who is scared to swear on the bible because they are about to lie!
All those people on Jeremy Kyle are eligible for jury duty.
Most people are too stupid to understand about atheism etc, and just see it as someone who is scared to swear on the bible because they are about to lie!
All those people on Jeremy Kyle are eligible for jury duty.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


