Unusual issue with my A4, when putting in reverse - advice?
Unusual issue with my A4, when putting in reverse - advice?
Author
Discussion

Gio G

Original Poster:

2,995 posts

240 months

Thursday 28th November 2013
quotequote all
This has been happening over the last 6 months, however does not happen all the time.

I start the car and put it into reverse straight away, to reverse out of my drive. Now the car does not idle that long before I shift it into reverse - maybe a 1 second, when a miss-fire starts to occur, the revs very choppy, I put it back into neutral, then it settles down and idles smoothly.

If I start the car and leave to idle for say 5-10 seconds and then into reverse, there are no issues. It is an S-tronic box and wonder whether the car gets confused, as I immediately selected reverse on ignition.. Strange thing is it does not happen every time.. The miss-fire only happens in the situation described.

Any thoughts?

Thanks G




FUBAR

17,065 posts

269 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
Oh dear frown

See here http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

Im just about to go collect my car with a brand new gearbox in it. Good luck :fingerscrossedsmiley:

blade7

11,311 posts

247 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
Gio G said:
Any thoughts?

Thanks G
Back it onto your drive smile.

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
It's not really a misfire. It's the oil surging in the box, so it feels like a misfire. The pathways for the oil in the gearbox are slightly longer for reverse than for Drive. Hence the delay. And hence if you leave it for a moment before selecting reverse it'll be fine. Zee clever Germans assumed everyone drives off forward first and it wouldn't matter.

What I've heard of before is that people stick in reverse, press the accelerator. Nothing happens (the slight delay) So they press it harder, then launch backwards off their driveway. laugh Then they take it to the dealer and complain there's a fault, when in fact it's more a case of not understanding the technology and how it's supposed to work.

HTH smile

Gio G

Original Poster:

2,995 posts

240 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Rich_W said:
It's not really a misfire. It's the oil surging in the box, so it feels like a misfire. The pathways for the oil in the gearbox are slightly longer for reverse than for Drive. Hence the delay. And hence if you leave it for a moment before selecting reverse it'll be fine. Zee clever Germans assumed everyone drives off forward first and it wouldn't matter.

What I've heard of before is that people stick in reverse, press the accelerator. Nothing happens (the slight delay) So they press it harder, then launch backwards off their driveway. laugh Then they take it to the dealer and complain there's a fault, when in fact it's more a case of not understanding the technology and how it's supposed to work.

HTH smile
Thanks for that!!

Kell

1,708 posts

239 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
blade7 said:
Gio G said:
Any thoughts?

Thanks G
Back it onto your drive smile.
While this might well have been said in jest, I was told years ago that it's a good idea anyway. The oil doesn't really start pumping around your engine until the car is moving and therefore slow speed manoeuvres when it's just started (i.e. reversing out) mean you're causing more damage than simply being able to drive out and away.

No idea if it's true or not, but it helps us on our drive anyway as it's a pain in the arse to see onto the road when you reverse out.

blade7

11,311 posts

247 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Kell said:
blade7 said:
Gio G said:
Any thoughts?

Thanks G
Back it onto your drive smile.
While this might well have been said in jest, I was told years ago that it's a good idea anyway. The oil doesn't really start pumping around your engine until the car is moving and therefore slow speed manoeuvres when it's just started (i.e. reversing out) mean you're causing more damage than simply being able to drive out and away.

No idea if it's true or not, but it helps us on our drive anyway as it's a pain in the arse to see onto the road when you reverse out.
It seemed like an obvious solution to me, I put the smiley in as I was offering help rather than being a smart arse.

Kell

1,708 posts

239 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
blade7 said:
Kell said:
blade7 said:
Gio G said:
Any thoughts?

Thanks G
Back it onto your drive smile.
While this might well have been said in jest, I was told years ago that it's a good idea anyway. The oil doesn't really start pumping around your engine until the car is moving and therefore slow speed manoeuvres when it's just started (i.e. reversing out) mean you're causing more damage than simply being able to drive out and away.

No idea if it's true or not, but it helps us on our drive anyway as it's a pain in the arse to see onto the road when you reverse out.
It seemed like an obvious solution to me, I put the smiley in as I was offering help rather than being a smart arse.
I wasn't being mean, it's just that it's a workaround solution that avoids the problem rather than fixes it. That is assuming there's a problem and it's not just an Audi 'feature'.

blade7

11,311 posts

247 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Kell said:
I wasn't being mean, it's just that it's a workaround solution that avoids the problem rather than fixes it. That is assuming there's a problem and it's not just an Audi 'feature'.
No problem smile.

FUBAR

17,065 posts

269 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
OK, if any of you read my thread I linked to you'll know I had very similar symptoms to Gio WRT reversing off my drive and slipping gears/clutch, and whilst I take on board the advice about oil taking longer in reverse etc., I got my car back yesterday with a new gearbox and all the 'traits' I'd lived with the past couple of years, and in particular the one Gio mentions, have completely disappeared leaving me think that most of the "they all do that sir" banded about is just working around a problem that is there. Like, for example, the 'thump' changing from 2nd to 1st when in stop start traffic? Now gone. My S-tronic is now as smooth as a slush box when in auto mode.

Gio G

Original Poster:

2,995 posts

240 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
FUBAR said:
OK, if any of you read my thread I linked to you'll know I had very similar symptoms to Gio WRT reversing off my drive and slipping gears/clutch, and whilst I take on board the advice about oil taking longer in reverse etc., I got my car back yesterday with a new gearbox and all the 'traits' I'd lived with the past couple of years, and in particular the one Gio mentions, have completely disappeared leaving me think that most of the "they all do that sir" banded about is just working around a problem that is there. Like, for example, the 'thump' changing from 2nd to 1st when in stop start traffic? Now gone. My S-tronic is now as smooth as a slush box when in auto mode.
Thanks FUBAR - just had a read of your thread. Will monitor the situation, have warranty for another 1.5 years, so have some cover if the worst was to happen. Glad your car is sorted now..

Thanks G

FUBAR

17,065 posts

269 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
No problem mate, and I didn't want to come across as scaremongering but, especially if you have warranty, get it looked at smile

Audi haven't gone into too much depth with me over the results, but there was mention by my friendly service chap of metal filings in the oil and upon further inspection a tooth (don't ask me what sort) had sheared off resulting in Audi insisting (thankfully) on a new gearbox.

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
The "thump" gearchanges are not the same fault as the OP. They're related to the mechatronic unit going wrong. smile