Tree Trouble
Author
Discussion

CommanderJameson

Original Poster:

22,096 posts

257 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
I live on a street. It's not a through-road. At the end of the street is a garden. In the corner of the garden (and therefore just at the end of the road) is a farhooking mahoosive willow tree.

When it's in leaf, this behemoth overhangs the street by a good 10-20 feet. Because it's a willow (and therefore a bit weepy), the finest branches extend down to about four feet off the ground.

In autumn, it dumps an immense amount of leaf litter on the street. And my car. And my wife's car. And everyone else's car (who lives on my street, obv). Seriously, this thing has leaves.

Question, then: does the owner of said tree have any responsibility for keeping it a bit better trimmed? Like a French lady's clopper, it's somewhat unkempt. I expect the leaves are something we just have to put up with, but the overhanging branches - surely they need to be kept in check?

I dunno. Tell me things, legal beagles of PH!

Edited by CommanderJameson on Friday 29th November 13:09

Camaro

1,432 posts

206 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
I guess until it causes harm to passing traffic or services (overhead electricity or telecomms cables).

Have you tried having a word with the neighbour to see if they would consider trimming it?

CommanderJameson

Original Poster:

22,096 posts

257 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
Camaro said:
I guess until it causes harm to passing traffic or services (overhead electricity or telecomms cables).

Have you tried having a word with the neighbour to see if they would consider trimming it?
That's the ultimate intention, but I was mildly curious to see what the legal standpoint is, should they get a bit "I know my rights".

Ideally of course, I'll go round and say, "I say, old bean, would you mind awfully giving your giant tree a bit of a trim with the old chainsaw?" and they'll say, "Why of course, good sir! I'll have my man get to it straight away!"

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
If the road is adopted by the local authority and the tree is affecting the highway (which includes pavement), I would have thought they'd be the branch of government (ahem) interested.

Rubin215

4,201 posts

187 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
If it overhangs your property you are allowed to cut back to the boundary line but you should offer the cuttings back to the owner before you dispose of them.

If its roots are damaging the pavement or road the council might get involved, if they are damaging your foundations you have a long legal battle ahead...

As for the leaf mess, it would be nice if the tree owner cleared it all up, but it's very unlikely to happen.
We have a large cherry tree that drops a shedload of leaves all over our street every autumn and we do make a token effort to clear them up, but it's just not practical to get them all.

I might just get my man to fell it come springtime...

jkh112

23,948 posts

189 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
Previously I had a large tree in my front garden which had branches overhanging the road.
Getting it trimmed was always a bit of a hassle because it had a TPO on it so any work had to be cleared in advance by the council. (The council bin lorry did a good job of breaking off the larger branches over the road).
Nevertheless I did try to keep it looked after but no matter how little or much it was trimmed, I always had neighbours complaining it was either too untidy or I had cut it back too far and spoilt the looks of it.
As suggested just go and talk to the owner, I suspect they already know but may have conflicting pressures on what they can/should do about it.

Edited by jkh112 on Friday 29th November 13:51


Edited by jkh112 on Friday 29th November 13:52

Air Support

511 posts

240 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
We've just had some overhanging trees on the opposite side of our road trimmed back by the owners. The trees were encroaching on to the highway (it is a narrow through road though)and starting to cause problems for passing vehicles.
The County Council highways department, once suitably contacted and motivated, served a notice on the owners to trim the trees and bushes back - so there is a duty somewhere for the owners to ensure trees don't interfere with the use of the highway

Willy Holloughby

253 posts

174 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
Call Special Branch.

Rubin215

4,201 posts

187 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
Willy Holloughby said:
Call Special Branch.
Love the user name.

ISWYDT...

base

321 posts

211 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
post a picture up of said tree, will give a better idea of whats what.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
base said:
post a picture up of said tree, will give a better idea of whats what.
I think we've established it's definitely a tree.

XCP

17,764 posts

259 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
Holywow said:
If it's in someone else’s garden you can't do anything except get the council to place a TPO on it.

Best to sneak into their garden in the night or when they’re away on holiday with a very large battery drill fitted with a 20mm x 300mm auger bit drill half a dozen deep holes at the base of the trunk and fill each hole with root out it’ll be dead in a week or so. Problem Solved.

In my experience talking to neighbours about their tree will get you nowhere.
would frozen sausages do the trick?

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
Holywow said:
If it's in someone else’s garden you can't do anything except get the council to place a TPO on it.
And how does that help in any way? My previous property had/has a line of 6 trees all with TPOs (part of an line of 30 the rest of which are on others' land). When the property next door to mine changed hands I had no end of hassle from the new owners about having major tree surgery carried out (why did they buy it if they don't like trees and falling leaves FFS??!!). A TPO severely limits what work you can carry out without permission from the Council. The paperwork involved is a PITA.

Holywow said:
Best to sneak into their garden in the night or when they’re away on holiday with a very large battery drill fitted with a 20mm x 300mm auger bit drill half a dozen deep holes at the base of the trunk and fill each hole with root out it’ll be dead in a week or so. Problem Solved.
Not sure if serious. Could come back to bite you on the arse if someone else sees you. Two wrongs don't make a right.

Holywow said:
In my experience talking to neighbours about their tree will get you nowhere.
As in any other interaction it entirely depends on what sort of person you are dealing with. For 15 years I had no issues until a couple of fruitloops acquired the adjacent property. The guy wasn't too bad but his wife wore the trousers. She was the tree hater, and totally unhinged. When she told him to jump, he always asked "how high?"



aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
Heh, just wait 'til the roots of the tree concerned begin finding the local shared/communal drains and blocking them hehe !

In the case of a Willow tree (about the worst possible tree for this scenario, I am told), imagine the same dimensions of growth underground as above ground plus quite a bit more... The canopy of the Willow tree in our front garden reached out about 8 feet from the trunk all round; a few of the roots reached and blocked a 4" sewer 20 feet away (down the side passage having navigated round the foundations) on a few occasions despite the use of a root cutter by the drainage specialists.

(Said Willow tree is long gone now.)

base

321 posts

211 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
base said:
post a picture up of said tree, will give a better idea of whats what.
I think we've established it's definitely a tree.
you think?

jet_noise

6,111 posts

213 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
Dear CJ,

lots of good advice. Leaves, howoever, are just life IIRC & IANAL. It's a tree wot dun it. There's no legal responsibility for clearing them up. Much like cats,

regards,
Jet

Pip1968

1,400 posts

235 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
I would just speak to them quite cordially and ask them if they could lift its skirt so that you can happily walk underneath it. You will then ascertain if they are too poor to sort it out and additionally if they are likely to play ball. Then you could move to helping physically or financially. They are your neighbours after all.

Alternatively you could bore out the holes as said and pack with PE. Remember you need a kicking charge on the correct side to ensure that when it comes down it does not fall on your neighbours property - think liability!

Why do so many on here start with aggressive solutions to simple problems???? Do petrolheads not get enough sex ????

A female colleague of mine said if men got it every day there would be world peace T/F?

Pip

Bill

58,939 posts

286 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
AFAIK (IANAA) willows are incredibly thirsty, so one tack that might persuade them is pointing out the potential for subsidence if they don't keep it in check.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
Pip1968 said:
A female colleague of mine said if men got it every day there would be world peace T/F?
By that remark she is admitting that women should provide it (gays guys excepted). So the lack of world peace must be their fault. If we men take it without consent it's rape!

I knew it all along. Now we have it from an unimpeachable source. wink

stewjohnst

2,479 posts

192 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
Really don't understand why people can't go knock on a door to ask about this without expecting to find a lunatic neighbour.

When I bought my house it had a couple of trees that had, like the house, been neglected. It was on my list to sort out but my neighbour happened to be out doing his trees with the chainsaw and cherry picker and he asked me if I'd mind him chopping the stuff on his side back a bit.

Hard to believe but not only did I not threaten to sue him, run inside for the frozen sausages, etc. I said of course old bean chop away. I even got him to take a load on my side back to save me a job.