Give me some input on these Logo designs?
Give me some input on these Logo designs?
Author
Discussion

nigelpugh7

Original Poster:

6,527 posts

221 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
I am sure i might regret this but here goes!!

We are using this company to design our business logo for our website and business cards.

https://99designs.co.uk/logo-business-card-design/...

The above link allows you to vote on what we have had submitted so far.

Looking for good business related, and honest opinions please!!

Thanks

Nigel.

nigelpugh7

Original Poster:

6,527 posts

221 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
heres a couple of pics so far:




Tuna

19,930 posts

315 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
Second two are far too busy. First one ok, but a bit meh.

zbc

1,071 posts

182 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
Done, I think none of them are bad, it depends a lot on your target market - presumably not PHers

Wing Commander

2,220 posts

263 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
My input, for what it is worth...

I like the text of the top one, but none of the logos. They are all a bit too fussy for my liking. The first logo doesn't actually say anything to me and looks like it was knocked up in paint with coloured circles. The lower ones look at bit too "clipart" for my liking.

If you could come up with a simpler, more logical logo and pair it up to the text on the top logo, I think you would be onto a winner.

Again, I qualify all this with the facts that I know nothing about datacentres or logos...

ETA: The catchline says nothing more than the company name, just in reverse order. I would be inclined to rework the catchline.

Frimley111R

19,429 posts

265 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
A key issue you have with all of these is that no consideration has been given to online usage. Your logo will, in many cases, be produced in very small sizes on screens making most of the detail nothing more than dots. Have look for something similar.

Also, your logo shouldn't have your strapline in it. And it's particularly pointless given that it simply repeats the working in the company name.

nigelpugh7

Original Poster:

6,527 posts

221 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
thanks for the great feedback so far guys!!

Yes I prefer the more simple one so far too.

As fas as the tag line is concerned, it was requested as part of the design brief, so all of the people submitting have used it.

boyse7en

8,243 posts

196 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
Have you considered where the logos will be used?

For example neither work well in single-colour, which may be required for newspaper ads, or for printing on mugs/t-shirts/pens

How much will they cost to do vinyl cuts if you want them to go on vans or curtain-side lorries? I doubt they could be as the designs are too complex.

Do they look ok tiny (i.e less than 8mm) or huge (side of an artic?) and on that note, are they vector graphics that can be scaled up to huge sizes?

The strapline is a waste of time, and is tells me nothing about your business or skills that your company name does not.


V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
They're all generically immemorable.

What do you want the logo to actually do for your company?

nigelpugh7

Original Poster:

6,527 posts

221 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
i have now filtered out some of the overly complex designs.

please look at the ones remaining in this link:-

https://99designs.co.uk/logo-business-card-design/...

Input again welcomed.

DS3R

13,531 posts

197 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
10 and 11 are awful, no relation to anythng other than clip art

26 bears a striking similarity to I can't remember who but I'll see if I can find it, may not be the same field.

For £20 you could get some fresh opinion here http://www.logobylogo.co.uk/_/19/

Vaud

60,041 posts

186 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
None are stellar.

26 looked the most corporate and clear to me.

bishbash

2,447 posts

228 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
26 or 6

Edited by bishbash on Saturday 30th November 09:37

Davel

8,982 posts

289 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
I think that I'd re-write the tag as it just repeats what you've said in the name...

Akiraprise

271 posts

219 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
They all look 'nice' but instantly forgettable and very generic.

That's one of my biggest problems with 99 Designs, the designers on there enter loads of contests and generally spend not a lot of time on each logo. The logos are generic and safe, with no real thought gone into the idea behind the logo and definitely no thought on how to execute the logos interestingly.

Any of the logos will serve it's purpose, but I think you'd have a much better logo had you given the brief to a designer who would put more effort into your logo - I'm not even talking agencies etc, but students etc are a fantastic source for cheap but amazing work!

In response to your actual question though: #26 but make half of the circle orange and half grey so it looks like an "O" and a "D" combined...

Vaud

60,041 posts

186 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
Akiraprise said:
They all look 'nice' but instantly forgettable and very generic.

That's one of my biggest problems with 99 Designs, the designers on there enter loads of contests and generally spend not a lot of time on each logo. The logos are generic and safe, with no real thought gone into the idea behind the logo and definitely no thought on how to execute the logos interestingly.

Any of the logos will serve it's purpose, but I think you'd have a much better logo had you given the brief to a designer who would put more effort into your logo - I'm not even talking agencies etc, but students etc are a fantastic source for cheap but amazing work!

In response to your actual question though: #26 but make half of the circle orange and half grey so it looks like an "O" and a "D" combined...
But at the end of the day logos aren't that important.

Unless you are creating the next global brand, as long as it looks vaguely professional, works in print and online and there is no comic sans, it really doesn't matter for B2B. They will remember the quality of your engagement, your work delivered and your bill, and do the three match up. The logo is mostly immaterial.

technodup

7,661 posts

161 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
I'd go 26, but I'd echo the comment above. Businesses spend far too much time and effort on this stuff when they could/should be selling.

Unless you are Apple, Coke, McD's etc hardly anyone is going to recognise your logo anyway, so it should play a minor part in your marketing material. So many small business talk about 'brand building' with design work but the best way to build a brand is to go out and sell more, which has the added advantage of making money at the same time.

I work with a marketing business and we don't have any logo to speak of, other than the business name in a specified font/colour.

jammy_basturd

29,778 posts

243 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
Vaud said:
But at the end of the day logos aren't that important.

Unless you are creating the next global brand, as long as it looks vaguely professional, works in print and online and there is no comic sans, it really doesn't matter for B2B. They will remember the quality of your engagement, your work delivered and your bill, and do the three match up. The logo is mostly immaterial.
This. It's extremely hard to come up with a logo design with impact. Especially if you're just paying a few hundred pounds for it!

When I presided over a logo comp on 99 Designs, I choose my finalists not just on the logos they'd submitted, but also on the previous work they had done in their portfolios. I took through one designer who had entered my comp, not because I liked his design the most, but because I saw some truly original and nice work in his portfolio. I wasn't surprised when he was able to take the average looking logo he'd submitted and turn it into something we actually ended up choosing as the winner.

B17NNS

18,506 posts

278 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
Bottom two look like a bit of clip art and a serif font is wrong for what you are/do.

Top one is better.

No. 7 is my favourite.

Edited by B17NNS on Saturday 30th November 13:09

Mobile Chicane

22,029 posts

243 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
26, purely because it will fit well into a 'corner' - eg. letterhead, business card, etc.

The rest only work centred.