Study: Mobile Speedcams Have No Effect, it's all RTM
Study: Mobile Speedcams Have No Effect, it's all RTM
Author
Discussion

turbobloke

Original Poster:

117,603 posts

291 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
From the latest edition of Local Transport Today:



The DfT’s head of statistics has endorsed a new method for measuring the effect of speed cameras on road casualties, which aims to isolate the effect of the cameras from random variations. The ‘four-time period’ method has been used by Slough-based engineer Dave Finney and Professor Richard Allsop of University College London in reports examining camera effects.

Finney explained his method in a report analysing data from mobile speed camera sites in the Thames Valley Safer Roads Partnership area (LTT 23 Nov 12). He separated the casualty data into four time periods:
• a pre-Site Selection Period when no cameras were present
• the Site Selection Period (SSP) – the period of time in which accident/casualty levels influenced the decision that a camera should be sited at the specific location
• ASBiC (After site selection but before installation of the camera)
• after camera installation

Finney ignored the SSP period data because this would contain the influence of selection bias – i.e. an abnormally high numbers of accidents (the ‘regression to the mean’ – RTM – effect). He therefore combined casualty rates in the pre-SSP and ASBiC periods to determine the mean collision rate before the start of speed camera operations. This was then compared with the rate after camera installation.

Finney said the method proved “beyond reasonable doubt that the entire reduction in killed and serious injury casualties at mobile speed camera sites actually occurred due to ‘regression to the mean’, and not as a result of mobile camera operations”.

MrTrilby

1,170 posts

313 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
Can you post a link to the study?

thescamper

920 posts

257 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
Try this link

Edited by thescamper on Saturday 30th November 15:07

Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

217 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
Someone will be along shortly to tell you how wrong you are, but it backs up what I've always thought.

MrTrilby

1,170 posts

313 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
This link seems to be to the report/article in question:

http://www.transportxtra.com/magazines/local_trans...

If you're going to selectively quote from the article, it might be better balanced if in addition to quoting

said:
Finney said the method proved “beyond reasonable doubt that the entire reduction in killed and serious injury casualties at mobile speed camera sites actually occurred due to ‘regression to the mean’, and not as a result of mobile camera operations”.
You also mention

said:
Allsop also used a four-time period method (though with a slightly different treatment of time periods) in a report advising citizens about how to interpret casualty data at speed camera sites, published by the RAC Foundation this summer (LTT 14 Jun). The report included analyses of data from fixed camera sites and concluded that cameras did have an observable effect on cutting personal injury collisions.
So assuming I've understood the article correctly, it's claiming that mobile camera sites have no measurable effect in reducing casualties at the location of the camera, but fixed cameras do?

pitmansboots

1,372 posts

218 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
Allsop also said this:
"Allsop has reworked his calculations with the revised assumption. His estimate of the reduction in personal injury collisions attributable to cameras across the nine partnership areas studied (previously 15%) is now 14%, and the estimate for fatal and serious collisions (previously 27%) is now 22%.

Explaining that the changes bring his method closer to Finney’s, Allsop told LTT: “I stand by my assessment that my method largely allows for regression to the mean. I recognise that some of the reduction my method attributes to the effect of cameras may still stem from RTM, but I don’t believe that this can be more than a small proportion.”

So the title used by the OP is not in any way reflective of the article.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
MrTrilby said:
This link seems to be to the report/article in question:

http://www.transportxtra.com/magazines/local_trans...

If you're going to selectively quote from the article, it might be better balanced if in addition to quoting

said:
Finney said the method proved “beyond reasonable doubt that the entire reduction in killed and serious injury casualties at mobile speed camera sites actually occurred due to ‘regression to the mean’, and not as a result of mobile camera operations”.
You also mention

said:
Allsop also used a four-time period method (though with a slightly different treatment of time periods) in a report advising citizens about how to interpret casualty data at speed camera sites, published by the RAC Foundation this summer (LTT 14 Jun). The report included analyses of data from fixed camera sites and concluded that cameras did have an observable effect on cutting personal injury collisions.
So assuming I've understood the article correctly, it's claiming that mobile camera sites have no measurable effect in reducing casualties at the location of the camera, but fixed cameras do?
Which seems to have a natural logic.

Streaky

Davidonly

1,080 posts

224 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
pitmansboots said:
Allsop also said this:
"Allsop has reworked his calculations with the revised assumption. His estimate of the reduction in personal injury collisions attributable to cameras across the nine partnership areas studied (previously 15%) is now 14%, and the estimate for fatal and serious collisions (previously 27%) is now 22%.

Explaining that the changes bring his method closer to Finney’s, Allsop told LTT: “I stand by my assessment that my method largely allows for regression to the mean. I recognise that some of the reduction my method attributes to the effect of cameras may still stem from RTM, but I don’t believe that this can be more than a small proportion.”

So the title used by the OP is not in any way reflective of the article.
The article contains the exact quote used by the OP. So the title chosen is clearly reflective of the article.

pitmansboots

1,372 posts

218 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
The article contains this words but in now way concludes that.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
pitmansboots said:
The article contains this words but in now way concludes that.
Quoting from the link above: 'Finney said the method proved “beyond reasonable doubt that the entire reduction in killed and serious injury casualties at mobile speed camera sites actually occurred due to ‘regression to the mean’, and not as a result of mobile camera operations”.'

What other conclusions are there in the report?

Streaky

pitmansboots

1,372 posts

218 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
streaky said:
pitmansboots said:
The article contains this words but in now way concludes that.
Quoting from the link above: 'Finney said the method proved “beyond reasonable doubt that the entire reduction in killed and serious injury casualties at mobile speed camera sites actually occurred due to ‘regression to the mean’, and not as a result of mobile camera operations”.'

What other conclusions are there in the report?

Streaky
Allsop also said this:
"Allsop has reworked his calculations with the revised assumption. His estimate of the reduction in personal injury collisions attributable to cameras across the nine partnership areas studied (previously 15%) is now 14%, and the estimate for fatal and serious collisions (previously 27%) is now 22%.

Explaining that the changes bring his method closer to Finney’s, Allsop told LTT: “I stand by my assessment that my method largely allows for regression to the mean. I recognise that some of the reduction my method attributes to the effect of cameras may still stem from RTM, but I don’t believe that this can be more than a small proportion.”

Finney is a keen amateur with a mission Allsop is a professor who specialises in traffic data analysis and as far as I can see approached his work objectively...you figure it out.

Who me ?

7,455 posts

243 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
"Finney is a keen amateur with a mission Allsop is a professor who specialises in traffic data analysis and as far as I can see approached his work objectively...you figure it out."

I have- you don't like the conclusions ,so again in true SCP fashion try to ridicule them . You don't get it. Cameras address nothing. Cameras only see that someone has exceeded the statutory limit. Cameras don't take into account that visibility is poor/ road surface is slippery ,or hazard density high. Cameras advertise that any speed in any condition is safe, up to the limit. if I can't see to read ,i wear my glasses. If I can't see a decent distance in front,I slow down. If I have poor control due to snow/ice,I slow down . You advocate that up to the limit ,in all conditions you are safe. That's the SCP manifesto?

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
pitmansboots said:
Allsop also said this:
"Allsop has reworked his calculations with the revised assumption. His estimate of the reduction in personal injury collisions attributable to cameras across the nine partnership areas studied (previously 15%) is now 14%, and the estimate for fatal and serious collisions (previously 27%) is now 22%.

Explaining that the changes bring his method closer to Finney’s, Allsop told LTT: “I stand by my assessment that my method largely allows for regression to the mean. I recognise that some of the reduction my method attributes to the effect of cameras may still stem from RTM, but I don’t believe that this can be more than a small proportion.”

Finney is a keen amateur with a mission Allsop is a professor who specialises in traffic data analysis and as far as I can see approached his work objectively...you figure it out.
We've seen "experts in their field" altering and reworking their calculations to fit in with the findings of other "experts" in attempts to reinforce certain assertions in particular areas of 'research'* before, and look how well that worked out rolleyes ...




* Ref. "climate change".hehe


MrTrilby

1,170 posts

313 months

Saturday 30th November 2013
quotequote all
[quote=Who me ?]You don't get it. Cameras address nothing. Cameras only see that someone has exceeded the statutory limit. Cameras don't take into account that visibility is poor/ road surface is slippery ,or hazard density high. Cameras advertise that any speed in any condition is safe, up to the limit.
[/quote]
Are you talking about fixed or mobile cameras?

Mill Wheel

6,149 posts

227 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Richard Allsop said:
but I don’t believe that this can be more than a small proportion.
He doesn't believe... but he cannot offer any proof... but he is prepared to stake other peoples lives on his beliefs being right.

All good, as he has the Truthbender General to back up his words and express them as facts!

You can tell when the Truthbender General is rattled by the number of typos in his posts, and when he has to edit even short posts...!

pitmansboots said:
The article contains this words but in now way concludes that.
smile

Richard Allsop has in the past also identified camera sites where accidents have risen significantly since the installation of the cameras - enough to raise concern that the cameras might have contributed to the increase.
http://www.racfoundation.org/media-centre/speed-ca...

In 2011 instruction from government that speed camera data going back to 1990, detailing accident statistics before and after fixed speed cameras were installed, be made publically available.

Since 2011 (as of June 2013) only a third (12 out of 36) of the organisations (a mixture of councils, police forces and safer roads partnerships) responsible for the figures have published the information in a format which complies with official Department for Transport guidance.

Is this because of cuts to their budgets, or do they have something to hide? scratchchin

Variomatic

2,392 posts

192 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
pitmansboots said:
Finney is a keen amateur with a mission Allsop is a professor who specialises in traffic data analysis and as far as I can see approached his work objectively...you figure it out.
Appeal to authority like that is one of the classic fallacies in logic / science.

If Finney's study is faulty then you have to identify how it's wrong, not simply discount it because "someone who's better qualified" - and has also failed to identify a fault with it - "believes" it must be wrong.

Guybrush

4,364 posts

237 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
From the latest edition of Local Transport Today:



The DfT’s head of statistics has endorsed a new method for measuring the effect of speed cameras on road casualties, which aims to isolate the effect of the cameras from random variations. The ‘four-time period’ method has been used by Slough-based engineer Dave Finney and Professor Richard Allsop of University College London in reports examining camera effects.

Finney explained his method in a report analysing data from mobile speed camera sites in the Thames Valley Safer Roads Partnership area (LTT 23 Nov 12). He separated the casualty data into four time periods:
• a pre-Site Selection Period when no cameras were present
• the Site Selection Period (SSP) – the period of time in which accident/casualty levels influenced the decision that a camera should be sited at the specific location
• ASBiC (After site selection but before installation of the camera)
• after camera installation

Finney ignored the SSP period data because this would contain the influence of selection bias – i.e. an abnormally high numbers of accidents (the ‘regression to the mean’ – RTM – effect). He therefore combined casualty rates in the pre-SSP and ASBiC periods to determine the mean collision rate before the start of speed camera operations. This was then compared with the rate after camera installation.

Finney said the method proved “beyond reasonable doubt that the entire reduction in killed and serious injury casualties at mobile speed camera sites actually occurred due to ‘regression to the mean’, and not as a result of mobile camera operations”.
This aspect of the speed camera (scamera) con has of course been well know for years, but it's good to have it highlighted again for a newer audience.

Also for those newer in webland, this site has a lot of detail on the subject of the speed camera con: http://www.safespeed.org.uk/

jbsportstech

5,069 posts

210 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
were i live they are mostly sited at the bottom of hills and not accident black spots just the nearest hill.

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
pitmansboots said:
So the title used by the OP is not in any way reflective of the article.
As a proven liar, you might have a credibility problem, especially on subjects where you have a vested interest.

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
is this a whole study missing the point that people don't know where mobile speed cameras are going to be, the fact they are in use and people know it reduces thier likeliness to speed anywhere, not where the cameras actually happen to be used