Advice - neighbour says ive hit his car, but I havent!
Advice - neighbour says ive hit his car, but I havent!
Author
Discussion

Mad Dave

Original Poster:

7,158 posts

294 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Evening,

I'm after advice on behalf of my dad - he's got a new neighbour who moved in a few months ago and recently he bought a nice nearly-new Lexus. The other day he came over and mentioned that there was new damage on the offside rear corner (caused sometime over the last 2-3 weeks, during which time he's only used the car once to go shopping) and he believes my dad is responsible. My dad's car has very sensitive rear parking sensors and he's adamant that he didn't cause the damage. He's very honest and if he'd hit it, he'd have gone straight round to apologise and make recompense.

Tonight, I've been out with a tape measure and measured the height of both areas from the ground - the damage on my dad's car is about an inch higher at the top and ends an inch higher at the bottom end, there are areas where there is clear damage on the neighbours car where there is none on my dads. Added to that, the damage on the Lexus is quiet severe, whereas the damage on my dad's is very minor and superficial and looks to me to be old. When presented with this, the neighbour is firmly of the belief that there's no other explanation other than my dad hitting his car, so we even lined up both cars next to each other - the damage is very close, but is still clearly about an inch out. The neighbour still won't accept this, saying that the car may have been parked slightly differently on the driveway, accounting for the difference (I pointed out that whatever gradient it was on, both would have to be on the same gradient as they're as near as dammit occupying the same piece of ground in order to collide. It's a very smooth, level, tarmac shared driveway).

He's now saying that he'll call his insurance company and name my dad as the culprit, and inform the police (who he thinks will take paint samples!). My question really, is even if my dad informs his insurance that he is NOT the culprit, will he still lose his NCB? I'm aware that insurance companies are notoriously weak and may just settle it 50/50, despite my dad not being responsible. He's also tempted to report the incident to the police in case he tries make a complaint of fail to report. The neighbour wants £210 to fix the damage - dad is considering paying this just to prevent loss of NCB, even though he didn't cause the damage.

Any advice appreciated,

Dave

Rick101

7,191 posts

181 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Be careful with this.

Had a similar situation with someone alledging I scraped a motorbike down their car.

I had an assessor round about 6 moths afer the alleged incident for him to simply report the bike had damage consistent with being in an accident.
The bike was a 12 owner D reg FZR that had been down the road more times than the milkman.

No proper investigation at all, just a very simple tickbox exercise.

The insurance company were actually going to pay out until I advised them the matter had already been through the courts.

Agrilla

834 posts

214 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
The neighbours insurance company will probably remind your neighbour that the burdon of proof rests with him to provide evidence that on the balance of probabilities, your Dad was a) involved in the accident, and b) that he was negligent.

Your Dad does not need to prove that he wasn't involved, although if you happened to take photographs of the damage at e relative heights, then that may make he process smoother.

If the neighbour has no evidence, he needs to just jog on, and his insurance company are unlikely to fight it.

That said, neighbourly relations can sour and go down a route that you really don't want to have to deal with - in light of this, can a without prejudice compromise be made to smooth things out?

nipsips

1,167 posts

166 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Alert your insurer - they can send out an assesor to both yours and his vehicles to prove that the damage wasn't caused by his vehicle. Bit of a toughie im afraid!

tme015

4 posts

157 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Your dad should also point out that if (big if) the cars did come together at some point, then it may have been the neighbour's car that was moving and your dad's car that was stationary, and that your dad will be considering calling the police and his insurance company to report said neighbour for damaging his car.

Even if paint matches, still does not prove that your dad hit neighbour's car, as could very easily be the other way round!

Before pointing this out, I'd ask if he has any witnesses to alleged event, just so he can't invent one once you point the above out to him.

Ultimately, probably best to seek advice from your insurer, but not sure if that will affect NCB OR future premiums even if claim goes away.

Good luck.
G.




Edited by tme015 on Sunday 1st December 17:58

williredale

2,866 posts

183 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Have a go on the insurance comparison websites with your dad's current NCB and with it adjusted to reflect a claim. See how much difference it makes.

It sounds like the neighbour's being a bit of a mong but for the sake of good relations it may be worth offering something.

Edit. What I'm trying to say is that if the difference in insurance quotes is small it might be worth handing over to them for peace of mind, good relations with the neighbour and use of the insurers assessor.

Edited by williredale on Sunday 1st December 17:59

Mr GrimNasty

8,172 posts

201 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
It's very easy to hit another car and not notice/hear anything and yet do damage - despite what some may believe.
It is also completely true that road camber, suspension compression etc. could easily account for an inch difference.
If your dad has no idea when/how the damage was done to his car, then on the balance of probabilities, I know what I think.

TwigtheWonderkid

49,308 posts

181 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
tme015 said:
Your dad should also point out that if (big if) the cars did come together at some point, then it may have been the neighbour's car that was moving and your dad's car that was stationary, and that your dad will be considering calling the police and his insurance company to report said neighbour for damaging his car.
What rubbish advice. If he does this, he's as good as admitting their was a collision. If not, how did he get the damage you say he should report?

Ffs. rolleyes



tme015

4 posts

157 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
New to the forums. Merely pointing out simple point that neighbour's case does not hold water for a number of reasons. Re-read my post, and notice the emphasised use of the word 'if'.

I won't post on PH again if this is the response.

Well done.
G.

BertBert

21,355 posts

242 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
williredale said:
Have a go on the insurance comparison websites with your dad's current NCB and with it adjusted to reflect a claim. See how much difference it makes.

It sounds like the neighbour's being a bit of a mong but for the sake of good relations it may be worth offering something.

Edit. What I'm trying to say is that if the difference in insurance quotes is small it might be worth handing over to them for peace of mind, good relations with the neighbour and use of the insurers assessor.

Edited by williredale on Sunday 1st December 17:59
So you are saying that if he was certain he didn't cause the damage, he should proceed as if he had for peace of mind and good relations? Not the approach I'd be taking!
Bert

barker22

1,037 posts

198 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
An inch difference could be very light acceleration/deceleration on even the hardest of suspension especially at the very extreme ends of the car.
How many cars are there down your dad's road OP? - Main road/cul de sac?

What are the chances of what I imagine, the same colour car hitting the neighbours car at the same height as your dads especially given the fact your neighbour has not been out in it so much.

Your father is in denial OP as he may not have felt it/didn't care/won't admit he is wrong.

Mad Dave

Original Poster:

7,158 posts

294 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for all the advice guys. The neighbour has been perfectly pleasant and I can appreciate that he's in a pretty awkward position - IMHO he genuinely thinks my dad damaged his car, so with that in mind he's been very diplomatic. It doesn't change the fact though that my old man is certain he would have known if he'd hit it, and he doesn't believe he did. The mark on my dad's car is so minor that he wasn't aware of it, and it was covered in mud and general road grime that he was only made aware of it when the neighbour pointed it out. My dad isn't one for washing his car (in fact I can't remember him ever doing it!) and it wouldn't surprise me if the mark was there when he bought the car a year ago and he's never spotted it (it's 6 years old and quite high miles, so has a few marks on it).

I can't emphasise enough - if he'd hit it, he'd have coughed it immediately, he's straight as a die. I'd just hate for him to lose his NCB when he's done nothing wrong.

Mad Dave

Original Poster:

7,158 posts

294 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
barker22 said:
An inch difference could be very light acceleration/deceleration on even the hardest of suspension especially at the very extreme ends of the car.
How many cars are there down your dad's road OP? - Main road/cul de sac?

What are the chances of what I imagine, the same colour car hitting the neighbours car at the same height as your dads especially given the fact your neighbour has not been out in it so much.

Your father is in denial OP as he may not have felt it/didn't care/won't admit he is wrong.
It's a cul-de-sac, but the cars are on a shared 'side by side' driveway. My parents are out all day and the neighbour informed us the other day that he keeps catching taxi drivers reversing on the drive and sitting there reading the paper etc. Other than that, nobody else uses it. IMHO it's a very nasty scrape, and looks more akin to scraping brickwork than another vehicle, and the damage on my dad's car is incredibly minor in comparison. There's no paint transfer visible on either car to narrow down a colour etc. I can see the neighbour's POV - the only person who legitimately drives near to his car on the driveway is my dad, but it could have happened at the local supermarket (he doesn't use it much, but he only noticed it when he washed it, so can't be sure even what week it happened in). I can also see that it's possible to hit a car and not realise, but the damage is such that I think you'd have felt this impact (it's taken a chunk of paint and undercoat clean off his car!) and I think it would do more damage to my dad's if he was the culprit (it's a few very very light scratches that'd probably polish out. It also looks old).

Centurion07

10,395 posts

278 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Mad Dave said:
My parents are out all day and the neighbour informed us the other day that he keeps catching taxi drivers reversing on the drive and sitting there reading the paper etc.
But he's decided it must have been your dad? I'd politely tell him to jog on.

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
If a dead body was found by a road then any paint samples on or around that body or on bits of vehicle nearby would be forensically tested in an attempt to find the vehicle involved. The substantial costs of this can be justified because (among other reasons) there has been a suspicious death.

In this case? The police will do what they usually do after an alleged "damage-only hit and run" and (eventually) let each of the parties have the other parties' names, addresses, name of insurer and that's it. Paint samples will not be taken and analysed because it's not value for money (by any definition) for any routine alleged "damage-only hit and run" therefore not in the public interest in relation to ever decreasing budgets. That the neighbour is talking this talk shows he is clearly silly if not nuts .

And the neighbour says Taxis use the shared drive area on a regular basis? scratchchin Tread carefully here, OP, your neighbour is a 'live one' wink .

hedgefinder

3,418 posts

201 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
tme015 said:
New to the forums. Merely pointing out simple point that neighbour's case does not hold water for a number of reasons. Re-read my post, and notice the emphasised use of the word 'if'.

I won't post on PH again if this is the response.

Well done.
G.
Jesus H Christ... probably the biggest over reaction in PH history....

Mad Dave

Original Poster:

7,158 posts

294 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Thanks, I'm quite aware of how the police side of things works, it's more the insurance side of things - dad really doesn't want to lose his NCB on the basis of an allegation. I did point out to the neighbour that it could have been a cabbie and he said 'no they don't go near the cars'. He's convinced that my dad did the damage and nothing with dissuade him. Personally in his position I wouldn't even be considering making a claim due to my own NCB, not for the sake of £200, but it's up to him.

stuartmmcfc

8,775 posts

223 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
If the neighbours being friendly and only wants £200 then maybe it might be an idea to give it to him.
Don't tell your Dad, to save his pride and pay it yourself,but falling out with a neighbour is far worse than losing £200 IMO.
Maybe your old man did, maybe he didn't, but it's only money but bad feelings with a neighbour can ruin your life.

Mad Dave

Original Poster:

7,158 posts

294 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
It's not about the money, he's already said that if he thought there was the slightest possibility he'd done it, he'd happily cough up, but he's convinced he'd have known about it and didn't cause the damage. He's very keen to maintain neighbourly relations, he just doesn't see why he should pay for someone else's mishap. I'm inclined to agree with him.

stuartmmcfc

8,775 posts

223 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
From your posts I'm 100% sure he's positive he didn't do it.
Unfortunately I'm not so sure he didn't.
Dads have a habit of being very stubborn as they get older and also not quite as aware of what they're doing.
I speak from the view point of someone probably as old as your Dad (or if not, heading that way smile )