Noisy tenant problem
Author
Discussion

Rollcage

Original Poster:

11,345 posts

223 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
A friend of mine rents a ground floor flat in, and has been there a number of years. She has newish neighbours with a baby directly above her.

They seem to be the neighbours from hell - screaming, shouting, arguing, fights and the baby as well. Seems to be minimal soundproofing, and it's making her miserable. They are not amenable to any sensible discussion regarding keeping noise levels down, and the bloke has intimidated my friend at least once.

The landlord seems a semi reasonable guy, but he's dragging his feet about an offer to soundproof the ceilings.

Under a standard tenancy agreement, would such nuisance neighbours amount to a breach of her right to "quiet enjoyment" or not? (I'm aware quiet enjoyment doesn't mean literally quiet)

She's intimated it could lead to a "they go or I go" situation, but gets the impression he'd rather she went, as he then wouldn't need to soundproof, though he'd get the same problem with the next tenant.

Is there anything she can "force" him to do, or does she need to rely on his reasonableness?

TIA

73mark

774 posts

158 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Her local council will help it's all about decibel levels

Disco You

3,749 posts

211 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
If she's renting, why not just move? This is the advantage of rental properties, after all.

Wings

5,983 posts

246 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Disco You said:
If she's renting, why not just move? This is the advantage of rental properties, after all.
^^^^this, whilst the local council's environmental health officer could be contacted, it is possibly easier for a tenant just to give Notice to their LL, and find alternative accommodation.

Rollcage

Original Poster:

11,345 posts

223 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
That is of course an option - but she's lived there five or six years and likes the property itself, and she isn't causing the problem. Why should she be the one to suffer the stress of finding a suitable new property (not to mention the move itself) just because her neighbours are aholes?

Who me ?

7,455 posts

243 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
73mark said:
Her local council will help it's all about decibel levels
Env Health (noise) will help on the noise ,and it might be worth talking to council about level of soundproofing. Might be that building regs have not been observed, and LL needs to act . I know ( but not about level of powers) that LA have powers on repairs on private. but as said- it's giving in to bullies if she has to move because noise is excessive and no one will act. If it was her body in danger-folk would act. Try living next door to a noisy house with CDs played high. I have, but fortunately I have a secret weapon- my CD/LP /download collection of bagpipe music.

rambo19

2,972 posts

168 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
A close friend of mine went through this, and the council were useless.
It got to the stage where we going to commit murder against the offender.

Rollcage

Original Poster:

11,345 posts

223 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Building regs might be a possibility, but I doubt it's a recent conversion. It's a fairly old house!

Worth investigating along those lines though!

hdrflow

854 posts

169 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Rollcage said:
They seem to be the neighbours from hell - screaming, shouting, arguing, fights and the baby as well. Seems to be minimal soundproofing, and it's making her miserable. They are not amenable to any sensible discussion regarding keeping noise levels down, and the bloke has intimidated my friend at least once.

Under a standard tenancy agreement, would such nuisance neighbours amount to a breach of her right to "quiet enjoyment" or not? (I'm aware quiet enjoyment doesn't mean literally quiet)
Technically yes. Enforcing it is rather more complicated. A formal complaint to their landlord, if they have intimidated her log it with the police, when arguing/fighting report to the domestic violence unit.
She'll also need to record it when it happens since they'll probably deny it. Or as others said, if she's renting is prolly better/easier to move. As I was once told 'It's only as good as your neebors!'. It's a pita frown

Rollcage

Original Poster:

11,345 posts

223 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
It is indeed. frown

skeggysteve

5,724 posts

248 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
As she's been there for years (and I assume not been a problem) I would think her landlord would want to keep her as a tenant.
So why not ask the landlord for advice/help?


DocSteve

731 posts

253 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
The Landlord is most unlikely to be obliged (legally) to improve the soundproofing of the property.

The proper route, as stated above, is to approach the council's relevant environmental health department. However, it may be tricky if noise is mostly coming from a baby or other person. There are other possible remedies - the flat causing the nuisance is presumably either occupied by the lessee (i.e. an owner-occupier) or a sub-lessee (i.e. someone the owner is renting the flat out to) and either way there will be a breach of the lease. It might be worth suggesting this to the landlord and the freeholder could then approach the nuisance lessee detailing the consequences of breaching the lease. If the nuisance flat is sub-let, the easiest threat is for the freeholder to suggest removal of the lessee's right to sub-let. This usually focuses landlords' attention and gets their tenants in order.

Edited by DocSteve on Monday 2nd December 00:41

Perec

28,176 posts

253 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all

An experienced landlord will evict the noise makers before accepting notice from anyone else.

mcflurry

9,192 posts

284 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Perec said:
An experienced landlord will evict the noise makers before accepting notice from anyone else.
True, although they may have different landlords smile

Perec

28,176 posts

253 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
mcflurry said:
Perec said:
An experienced landlord will evict the noise makers before accepting notice from anyone else.
True, although they may have different landlords smile
Agreed. The tone of the OP suggested that this problem was within the LLs control. Assuming it is different LLs the problem is nothing to do with the OP's LL.

Rollcage

Original Poster:

11,345 posts

223 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
It's the same LL.

I think she's going to speak to various council departments today to start the ball rolling there, and continue to try and get the LL to do something!

Crappy situation to be in to be honest.

Perec

28,176 posts

253 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Rollcage said:
It's the same LL.

I think she's going to speak to various council departments today to start the ball rolling there, and continue to try and get the LL to do something!

Crappy situation to be in to be honest.
The LL obviously enjoys hassle then. I manage lots and lots of flats with thin ceilings and drop on noisy tenants like a tramp on chips. Three strikes and out because I don't want to lose good tenants in favour of noisy ones and I don't want the busy bodies from the council rocking up en masse (why do thy do that?) poking their nose into things that the would like to concern them but don't.

Fab32

381 posts

164 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Rollcage said:
They seem to be the neighbours from hell - screaming, shouting, arguing, fights and the baby as well.
Maybe a call to children's services for them to come out and see that the baby is okay, living in that environment?

Who me ?

7,455 posts

243 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Rollcage said:
It's the same LL.

I think she's going to speak to various council departments today to start the ball rolling there, and continue to try and get the LL to do something!

Crappy situation to be in to be honest.
Not nice, but I note that our council Env health dept are trying to wriggle out,( locally weve had a rat problem in local park. Council now trying to claim it's water voles .pity they are endangered ) so you've got to shout longer and harder. Don't forget if council drag heels ,you've got an elected rep ( ward councillor) you can ask for health .

Rollcage

Original Poster:

11,345 posts

223 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice folks.

I'll let you know what happens.