Nice smackdown on Foxtons and other estate agencies
Discussion
http://anjaliszt.blogspot.co.uk/2013/10/will-civil...
Picked up by the FT today. Claims multiple criminal infringements of consumer protection laws by the main plc estate agencies, and compares their liability to fines and civil claims to the PPI situation.
Newc said:
http://anjaliszt.blogspot.co.uk/2013/10/will-civil...
Picked up by the FT today. Claims multiple criminal infringements of consumer protection laws by the main plc estate agencies, and compares their liability to fines and civil claims to the PPI situation.
Pure bPicked up by the FT today. Claims multiple criminal infringements of consumer protection laws by the main plc estate agencies, and compares their liability to fines and civil claims to the PPI situation.
ks IMO. Guess Foxtons have upset someone.I remember the years where people respected their estate agent and were pleased with the job.
This was before the growth in the 90's when every man(kid) and his dog decided that it was a nice money earner and jumped in wearing shiny suits, gell'ed hair and driving mini's BMW's with their huge mobile in one hand and the filofax in the other...
This was before the growth in the 90's when every man(kid) and his dog decided that it was a nice money earner and jumped in wearing shiny suits, gell'ed hair and driving mini's BMW's with their huge mobile in one hand and the filofax in the other...
I don’t think that this will sink them but they are on borrowed time and this may add to the issues they are going to be dealing with in the near future as they come out the woodwork. Add to this that there are people who are/were managers of these offices who are retiring and/or have moved into the independent sector for their last few years and are now able to speak a little more freely about the training they received. I had a very illuminating conversation with one such a few weeks ago.
We are aware of Clients who have been told by EA’s working for two of those names that they will not be recommending their offer on a Property unless they use their tied legal and/or financial services. And they are just the Clients who have told us of this.
Of course a big company can not be responsible for the actions of individual members of staff, yet when you hear it or similar once or twice a month and from people who have had this from different negotiators you start to wonder if there is any fire behind the smoke.
We are aware of Clients who have been told by EA’s working for two of those names that they will not be recommending their offer on a Property unless they use their tied legal and/or financial services. And they are just the Clients who have told us of this.
Of course a big company can not be responsible for the actions of individual members of staff, yet when you hear it or similar once or twice a month and from people who have had this from different negotiators you start to wonder if there is any fire behind the smoke.
This is a very,very old story. Can't remember which channel it was on but there was an "expose" of Foxtons and other agents practices a few years ago....St John's Wood and Notting Hill were the featured Foxtons offices. Showed how there financial advisory arm gave confidential/private info to negotiators so they knew how far they could push buyers etc. e.g. Client is putting a £450k offer on a flat that is on the market for £475k. Negotiator knows client has a mortgage sign off for £475k so pushes them to that price level....
I got two maybe three paragraphs into reading that and realised that the writer has absolutely no idea about numbers that actually matter for running a business.
Hint: net assets and goodwill are generally utterly irrelevant.
She essentially sounds like someone who is cross because they signed up to some EA services without reading the small print.
It is hardly "opaque" to quote a fee excluding VAT.
The only point she has that might have potential merit is that Foxtons still make a gargantuan amount of money signing up tenants for a second year.
AFAIK they are not allowed to charge for this - but they do.
And idiot landlords continue to let them.
Mostly, I suspect, because those landlords don't give a flying f
k about rounding errors on their P&L for letting when they are making out like bandits on capital gains.
Hint: net assets and goodwill are generally utterly irrelevant.
She essentially sounds like someone who is cross because they signed up to some EA services without reading the small print.
It is hardly "opaque" to quote a fee excluding VAT.
The only point she has that might have potential merit is that Foxtons still make a gargantuan amount of money signing up tenants for a second year.
AFAIK they are not allowed to charge for this - but they do.
And idiot landlords continue to let them.
Mostly, I suspect, because those landlords don't give a flying f
k about rounding errors on their P&L for letting when they are making out like bandits on capital gains.EskimoArapaho said:
walm said:
It is hardly "opaque" to quote a fee excluding VAT.
Is it illegal, though, to advetise and quote to consumers without VAT?I am just not sure that it is a smoking gun that is going to bring down every Estate Agent in the country - since in my experience - they all do that.
And, really? I mean it pretty clearly says "+ VAT" - won't they just say that many of their customers are BTLers well above the VAT threshold who don't pay any VAT so they can't tell what the fee will be...?
Either way - I am not sure Foxtons are trembling much in their shiny shiny suits!
walm said:
Fair point.
I am just not sure that it is a smoking gun that is going to bring down every Estate Agent in the country - since in my experience - they all do that.
And, really? I mean it pretty clearly says "+ VAT" - won't they just say that many of their customers are BTLers well above the VAT threshold who don't pay any VAT so they can't tell what the fee will be...?
Either way - I am not sure Foxtons are trembling much in their shiny shiny suits!
Re. first paragraph, they all do it because of pathetic regulatory enforcement, and they all copy each other. I am advocating mass civil action because illegally misrepresented prices are negligent misrepresentations or fraud, either of which is a firm basis for civil action, and multiple civil actions would immediately stimulate disciplined compliance.I am just not sure that it is a smoking gun that is going to bring down every Estate Agent in the country - since in my experience - they all do that.
And, really? I mean it pretty clearly says "+ VAT" - won't they just say that many of their customers are BTLers well above the VAT threshold who don't pay any VAT so they can't tell what the fee will be...?
Either way - I am not sure Foxtons are trembling much in their shiny shiny suits!
Re. second paragraph, only BTLers with many properties are defined as businesses, and the OFT therefore recommends that, to avoid breaking the law, lettings agents should treat landlords as consumers.
Re. third paragraph, Foxtons has already reacted to the blog and to its coverage by the Financial Times Alphaville site by making major changes to its website, including quoting all its fees inclusive of VAT. Whilst it still breaks the law, it is now, as far as I know, more compliant than any other agency. See my update
.Re. your earlier post,
You seem to be unaware that it is a criminal offence not to disclose material risks or to trade whilst insolvent, i.e. with negative net assets, and that these are particularly serious offence for listed companies and their auditors.
Quoting consumer prices exclusive of tax is defined in law as a misleading omission. Hence it is opaque.
If you had read more of the blog, you would have discovered that about half of the agencies' revenue is from lettings, that about 16% of their revenue comes from improperly disclosed VAT, and that another large chunk, about 10% in Foxtons's case, came from other improperly disclosed charges. None of these are rounding errors. Removing them reverses the companies' profitability.
Sorry not allowed.
Edited by Big Al. on Sunday 15th December 18:35
anja said:
walm said:
Fair point.
I am just not sure that it is a smoking gun that is going to bring down every Estate Agent in the country - since in my experience - they all do that.
And, really? I mean it pretty clearly says "+ VAT" - won't they just say that many of their customers are BTLers well above the VAT threshold who don't pay any VAT so they can't tell what the fee will be...?
Either way - I am not sure Foxtons are trembling much in their shiny shiny suits!
Re. first paragraph, they all do it because of pathetic regulatory enforcement, and they all copy each other. I am advocating mass civil action because illegally misrepresented prices are negligent misrepresentations or fraud, either of which is a firm basis for civil action, and multiple civil actions would immediately stimulate disciplined compliance.I am just not sure that it is a smoking gun that is going to bring down every Estate Agent in the country - since in my experience - they all do that.
And, really? I mean it pretty clearly says "+ VAT" - won't they just say that many of their customers are BTLers well above the VAT threshold who don't pay any VAT so they can't tell what the fee will be...?
Either way - I am not sure Foxtons are trembling much in their shiny shiny suits!
Re. second paragraph, only BTLers with many properties are defined as businesses, and the OFT therefore recommends that, to avoid breaking the law, lettings agents should treat landlords as consumers.
Re. third paragraph, Foxtons has already reacted to the blog and to its coverage by the Financial Times Alphaville site by making major changes to its website, including quoting all its fees inclusive of VAT. Whilst it still breaks the law, it is now, as far as I know, more compliant than any other agency. See my update
.Re. your earlier post,
You seem to be unaware that it is a criminal offence not to disclose material risks or to trade whilst insolvent, i.e. with negative net assets, and that these are particularly serious offence for listed companies and their auditors.
Quoting consumer prices exclusive of tax is defined in law as a misleading omission. Hence it is opaque.
If you had read more of the blog, you would have discovered that about half of the agencies' revenue is from lettings, that about 16% of their revenue comes from improperly disclosed VAT, and that another large chunk, about 10% in Foxtons's case, came from other improperly disclosed charges. None of these are rounding errors. Removing them reverses the companies' profitability.
And I don't agree that quoting + VAT is illegal. The act says that where the charge cannot be determined prior to the transaction the method of calculation must be stated clearly. They did that ten years ago, assume they still do.
anja said:
You seem to be unaware that it is a criminal offence not to disclose material risks or to trade whilst insolvent, i.e. with negative net assets, and that these are particularly serious offence for listed companies and their auditors.
Thanks for taking the time to defend yourself anja but you really need to learn some accounting.As above the VAT comment is a school-boy/girl error.
Secondly the level of net assets has nothing to do with solvency.
How many people are signed up for the class action?
At what stage is it in court?
Because I am afraid that one blog post does not usually pose a "material risk".
walm said:
The only point she has that might have potential merit is that Foxtons still make a gargantuan amount of money signing up tenants for a second year.
AFAIK they are not allowed to charge for this - but they do.
Friendly question, are you able to qualify this?AFAIK they are not allowed to charge for this - but they do.
As one of those idiot landlords, what legislation / evidence / reason should I rely on in order to avoid being charged the agency fee in years 2 and beyond?
Friendly question, I ask it not to antagonise but to save myself some money!
Many thanks
I guess you have to check what you signed up to. I may have overstated the claim that they CAN'T charge for year 2.
From this link it looks like for a few years when they hid those terms in the small print they were unenforceable but now they may have made them more prominent to avoid that issue. It's not clear...
It would certainly be worth arguing the point though and personally I would absolutely avoid signing up to anything that pays them for doing nothing.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/8144161.stm
Or just join the class action
From this link it looks like for a few years when they hid those terms in the small print they were unenforceable but now they may have made them more prominent to avoid that issue. It's not clear...
It would certainly be worth arguing the point though and personally I would absolutely avoid signing up to anything that pays them for doing nothing.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/8144161.stm
Or just join the class action

Do you have to be registered with anyone in particular to be an estate agent.
There's a small shop near us that's been a little plumbing and heating company's office for as long as i can remember. Shutters only ever half open, never seems anyone going in or out, but if you pass the door, you can see light on and someone normally sat at a desk. Anyway, of late, shop next door has come up for sale and they've bought it, used same name but instead of XYZ Plumbing and Heating, they're now XYZ Estate Agency. This shop seems to be doing ok too.
There's a small shop near us that's been a little plumbing and heating company's office for as long as i can remember. Shutters only ever half open, never seems anyone going in or out, but if you pass the door, you can see light on and someone normally sat at a desk. Anyway, of late, shop next door has come up for sale and they've bought it, used same name but instead of XYZ Plumbing and Heating, they're now XYZ Estate Agency. This shop seems to be doing ok too.
sider said:
Do you have to be registered with anyone in particular to be an estate agent.
There's a small shop near us that's been a little plumbing and heating company's office for as long as i can remember. Shutters only ever half open, never seems anyone going in or out, but if you pass the door, you can see light on and someone normally sat at a desk. Anyway, of late, shop next door has come up for sale and they've bought it, used same name but instead of XYZ Plumbing and Heating, they're now XYZ Estate Agency. This shop seems to be doing ok too.
No, no requirements whatsoever to open as an estate agent.There's a small shop near us that's been a little plumbing and heating company's office for as long as i can remember. Shutters only ever half open, never seems anyone going in or out, but if you pass the door, you can see light on and someone normally sat at a desk. Anyway, of late, shop next door has come up for sale and they've bought it, used same name but instead of XYZ Plumbing and Heating, they're now XYZ Estate Agency. This shop seems to be doing ok too.
Re: the plumbing business / estate agent, I know of an exactly similar scenario (except it was a letting agent) that turned out to be a money-laundering front business for a fairly major drug dealer. He owned over 100 houses, all owned outright & rented - nice income until he got shot over a drug deal gone bad! Should have retired & lived off the rents...
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


