Accused of Littering - Utter Rubbish!
Accused of Littering - Utter Rubbish!
Author
Discussion

Mike Raffone

Original Poster:

1,204 posts

218 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Evening All,

I’d like some help with the following query please?
Mainly because it’s factually incorrect and, also because even if it were the case – I do not believe the way these situations are processed are neither legally nor morally correct.

Brief’ish outline.

I drive my fiancés car to commute to/ from work because it’s a diesel and much cheaper than my car.
I’m down as the main driver on her insurance, but the car remains registered to her.

My partner received a letter on Saturday from a nearby local authority where I drive through their boundary on my way to/ from work 5 days a week.

The letter is from “Operational Services Neighbourhood Wardens” where, whilst cutting to the chase, they have accused me of littering.

I appreciate everyone will sing the same song of “not me guv’na” – and other than taking my word for it, I will say – without any doubt, I did not, do not and will not litter!

This person has quoted S87 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990, where I am accused of littering.

He also refers to Section 110 of the Environmental Act 1995 to ensure my details are handed to him if the registers keeper is not the “guilty” party. Also Section 108 of the Environmental Act 1995 where a brief questionnaire must be completed.

Obviously I was extremely angry at being accused of this, but my partner, playing the role of a level-headed-citizen took control and telephoned the gentleman is question today to establish communication and verify the details.

He has effectively stated that I have been witnessed to have thrown litter from the drivers window whilst stationary.

A full description of me was given….. which is correct.

So here lies my problem:

He has confirmed the car was in that area, and I was the driver.

However, the time of the alleged offence is wrong. The time given in the letter clashes with my start time at work. I simply can not have been at that location at that time as there is no way I could have have gone form there and arrived at work, during rush hour, in such a limited time.

Unfortunately, my new job does not have swipe cards or check-ins or anything like that.
We merely park up, walk in, make a brew and start work.

Knowing that I do not litter and, knowing I was not at that location at the specified time – I was under the assumption I could explain this to him and he would find another rock to crawl under.

But alas – and here is my main issue. I am now in a position of a “He Said - I Said - They said” et al.
My word against theirs. And by a quick google search, it would seem they have the power to remember someones reg plate, their description and issue a fine,

I would very much appreciate some assistance with knowing:
1) How can I prove I did not do it, when he says I did.
2) How is it now legally viable for someone to accuse someone else of a crime without hard evidence?

To twist this another way – if I saw someone who I didn’t like, who the hell am I to impose a fine on them purely because I can recall their description and location?

I do not appreciate being accused of something which is incorrect.
I especially do not appreciate being accused of something without any evidence other than a bloody notepad.

Any assistance would be much appreciated,
And as always – I remain obliged.

Mike.





AWRacing

1,747 posts

256 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Have you any way of prooving you couldn't have been there at that time, work computer, emails you sent at that time, telephone calls, work colleagues etc?

The only thing I can suggest is to gather as much evidence as you can

V8RX7

28,982 posts

294 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
You need a witness or other evidence to prove you weren't there.

Shouldn't be hard to gather.

s3fella

10,524 posts

218 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
So he got the reg and a description of you as the driver that you agree sounds like you? Or is the description not correct?

Could it have been a different day, ie day before or after when you were there.
What are you accused of littering with? Cigarette, mcds bag? Do you smoke or eat mcds in the car?

Is it utterly inconceivable that it was you? If so, fight it. If you think it could be you at a different time or day, I'd be inclined to suck it up?

shovelheadrob

1,564 posts

202 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Not wishing to play devils advocate, do you smoke? Could it have been a fag end? Please accept my apology if I am wrong, but it amazes me that smokers don't consider throwing/dropping cigarette ends as littering.

gus607

1,001 posts

167 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Did I read somewhere that local councils cannot ask/demand driver details. S172 ?

Have a wander down to Peppipoo & do some searching.

Rubin215

4,201 posts

187 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Worst "I've been caught throwing condoms out of the window of my girlfriend's car; how do I stop her discovering I'm podgering her sister in the back of her own car?" thread ever...

hehe

Mike Raffone

Original Poster:

1,204 posts

218 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Thank you for the replies all, much appreciated.
I don't smoke - infact, I don't do anything other than drive in her car. No drinks, sweets, munchies, mints etc etc - Just me and the radio.

I've even discovered that if you enable "Location" on your Android handset and have it registered with your gmail account, then you're able to view and trace your whereabouts for any given day - this does include time stamps. But just my luck, it has a timestamp for when I left home, and then one just before lunch. Unsure whether it's a blackhole I drive though each morning, but there's no record of the roads I use on that google service
Other than bringing colleagues into this to witness I was in the office (which I'd prefer not to as I've only been at this gig for a few weeks), and I'm still in the mindset that I should not have to prove my innocence - he should prove my guilt.

Purely stating a reg plate and a drivers description simply can not warrant the ability to dish out bogus fines onto the public.

The only thing that comes to mind is I may have been tapping the roof of the car whilst sat in traffic, as one does when the car gets a too hot & stuffy and you're sat bored on a slip road waiting to join a gridlocked roundabout which leads to a gridlocked A-road.

Are we in 'that' society now where it is my duty to prove innocence against the state? A civil servant has the power to accuse and demand money without the requirement of proof? I'm really trying to avoid quoting 1984 / tinfoil hats here, but it's very, very difficult when considering the possible implications of paying out £40 just to keep life simple.

Thank you for your responses once again - I do appreciate other viewpoints on this, with hopefully some hard-boned facts about what this jobsworth actually can, and can not, do.

Mike.


Cliftonite

8,754 posts

169 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all

It may be interesting to ask them what form the litter actually took? If it had been smoking-related, for example, it would strengthen your case somewhat!

I have also thought I have seen litter thrown from a vehicle I had been following, but have not been too sure as to whether it may have just been something from the road caught up in the vehicle's slip stream.


numtumfutunch

5,184 posts

169 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all

Does the cctv image they have match your car?

Wondering:
a) have you been cloned?
b) if so how stupid would the perp be to use it locally?

cheers

s3fella

10,524 posts

218 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Was the description they provided consistent with you.?

Did they say what they saw you throw out ?


Tapping on the car roof, as you do? Not something I see a lot of tbh!

I think you should get some more details about the alleged offence. They've almost certainly seen 'something' and quite possibly it was you doing that something, if their description matches. But 'man with brown hair' is not 'man with rash, brown hair, centre parting, wearing a pink onesie' etc.
do you know if it was a person seeing you or CCTV?

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
It might be worth posting on PePiPoo - it's relatively 'normal' for local authorities to quote the wrong sections of the various acts and to state (as in this case) that the registered keeper must name the driver of the vehicle at the time of the alleged offence when the section they quote doesn't say that at all... wink

Or pop on there and do a search at least, they have some interesting info you can use to knock this on the head smile .

I hope that, while your partner has spoken to the council chappie, she has NOT completed any paperwork and sent it off? frown

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Mike Raffone said:
I would very much appreciate some assistance with knowing:
1) How can I prove I did not do it, when he says I did.
2) How is it now legally viable for someone to accuse someone else of a crime without hard evidence?
Inoocent until proven otherwise, surely?

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
shovelheadrob said:
Not wishing to play devils advocate, do you smoke? Could it have been a fag end? Please accept my apology if I am wrong, but it amazes me that smokers don't consider throwing/dropping cigarette ends as littering.
Agree. I have been known to throw discarded fag ends back thru open car windows. I know I shouldn't but the look on the occupants faces can be priceless.

Why do so many smokers not regard their fag ends as litter?

Prizam

2,447 posts

172 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
Mike Raffone said:
I would very much appreciate some assistance with knowing:
1) How can I prove I did not do it, when he says I did.
2) How is it now legally viable for someone to accuse someone else of a crime without hard evidence?
Inoocent until proven otherwise, surely?
Guilty until proven innocent... no, wait?

Personally i wouldn't entertain it with a response. Like you say, they want to prosecute you, let them show the evidence.

Next time you drive through, look out for a day glow idiot. take note of there description and then accuse them of littering.

Cliftonite

8,754 posts

169 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
Innocent until proven otherwise, surely?
But this is a motoring offence and the above, therefore, does not apply.

(This would be funny if it weren't true in so many cases!)

frown


Vipers

33,525 posts

259 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
bad company said:
Why do so many smokers not regard their fag ends as litter?
Retards biggrin

I had the pleasure whilst crossing a London street when the bus driver in a stationary bus threw his apple core out, I swiftly picket it up and threw it back in his open window, his face was priceless.



smile


Edited by Vipers on Tuesday 3rd December 11:08

Nightmare

5,279 posts

315 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
s3fella said:
Tapping on the car roof, as you do? Not something I see a lot of tbh!
really? i do it all the time i must admit....elbow in windowsill and fingers drumming on the roof usually!

It seems very odd that someone has gone out of their way to not only fabricate a littering claim, but to also bother getting a description of car and driver etc and then actually report it. wonder how many other, similar claims said individual has made against people.

XCP

17,761 posts

259 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Cliftonite said:
But this is a motoring offence and the above, therefore, does not apply.

(This would be funny if it weren't true in so many cases!)

frown
This is not a motoring offence.

Monkeylegend

29,590 posts

262 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Mike Raffone said:
Other than bringing colleagues into this to witness I was in the office (which I'd prefer not to as I've only been at this gig for a few weeks), and I'm still in the mindset that I should not have to prove my innocence - he should prove my guilt.



The only thing that comes to mind is I may have been tapping the roof of the car whilst sat in traffic, as one does when the car gets a too hot & stuffy and you're sat bored on a slip road waiting to join a gridlocked roundabout which leads to a gridlocked A-road.

Surely if you have colleagues who were at work with you at the time you were allegedly littering, they would be happy to verify this wouldn't they?

That should be more than enough for the council to withdraw the fine.

If you were at work at the time you could not have been sitting in traffic tapping on the roof.