National Rail - Works noise & property boundaries
National Rail - Works noise & property boundaries
Author
Discussion

speed_monkey

Original Poster:

3,503 posts

220 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
A local railway bridge is in the process of being demolished and this is causing a massive issue with my parents, I will list the issues here as its a bit of a long drawn out issue...

- Network rail (NR) send letter round that a railway bridge (A509), marked with yellow, is to be demolished over the Christmas period.
- NR begin works beginning of November and clear the blue marked area, my parents land is marked with red so you can see they have cleared some of the trees and shrubs on their property to gain access to the bridge.
- NR leave a massive pile of rubble on parents land where the blue and red overlap.
- NR work throughout the night all days of the week creating huge amounts of noise and have bright work lights in the blue area
- Parents complain to NR, no response.
- Parents write to the local MP, who then emails NR
- NR respond with generic copy and paste email about "road closures".... rolleyes
- Parents respond outlining the issue again only to be told that they were informed the work would be taking place and they will continue to do so regardless - yes the email was that blunt.
- NR emailed my parents to say that the worse of the noise will take place on 24/12 evening (yes Christmas Eve) as they workers will be using pneumatic equipment.



Everyone understands that the work does have to take place but it seems that NR have no concern for the adjoining properties inhabitance.

The worse of the work is on Saturday evenings. This is genuinely having an impact on my mums health as she is getting >3 hours sleep a night and works long shifts as a nurse. Also, the cleared area of my parents land has left the property totally open to the main road with no security whatsoever. This was "rectified" by NR by putting up a waist high barrier.

Is there anything that they can do?


ETA - I have just chescked and it is NETWORK RAIL, not National Rail

Edited by speed_monkey on Tuesday 3rd December 11:37

Prizam

2,447 posts

172 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
parents have house backing on to railway... complain when railway has works done to it.


The work needs to be done, it cannot be done in the day because of the disruption, it cannot be done quietly.


What would you suggest National Rail do?

speed_monkey

Original Poster:

3,503 posts

220 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Prizam said:
parents have house backing on to railway... complain when railway has works done to it.


The work needs to be done, it cannot be done in the day because of the disruption, it cannot be done quietly.


What would you suggest National Rail do?
Did you even read the post?

Prizam

2,447 posts

172 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
speed_monkey said:
Prizam said:
parents have house backing on to railway... complain when railway has works done to it.


The work needs to be done, it cannot be done in the day because of the disruption, it cannot be done quietly.


What would you suggest National Rail do?
Did you even read the post?
Yes.

So far as them working on your land and making a mess of it. Document it with lots of pictures and submit them an invoice for land rental for the period of the works.

Also submit pictures of what it was like before and ask them to put it back to the state it was in before they started work.


This however wont help with the noise and lights, which seemed to be the main issue.

nipsips

1,167 posts

166 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Was the railway there before the house was built or before your parents moved in?

Panda P

247 posts

167 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
It's a hazzard of owning property near any infrastructure for transport unfortuately and while annoying for those that owned property previously not near to it (think of all the people currently up in arms over CrossRail) I think that anyone buying a property near to any kind of this type infrastrucure needs to be aware of the potential for disruption.

Repairs need to be done and there is no arguement about it; either we want a prompt and safe service or we don't and frankly, the latter is not an option. Contractors are only allowed, by contract, to enter the site between certain hours to avoid disruption to services and for safety of course. Contractors must also have left and made safe the site after each shift meaning that the beginning and end of each shift can be quite noisy whilst things are packed/unpacked/grinded off etc and is not as simple as 'tools down, off you go'.

In short there's nothing that you can do about the noise and you'd be very lucky to get any financial sum that would pay towards a hotel stay for that period.

In regard to use of your paren'ts land, appropriate advise has already been given. NR, or their Contractors, are obligated to leave the land on other's property as found. In a few cases that I know of, where a house is alongside the tracks and works have been performed, the owner has had new gardens, fences and driveway paid for as NR ran over a considerable amount of it (previously agreed).

blueg33

47,023 posts

255 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Op, is it Network Rail we are talking about?

If so they have pretty wide ranging powers and are a right royal pain in the ass to deal with. Took me 4 years to sort out a boundary encroachment.

Do they have a licence to occupy your parents land? What notification have they given?

Personally I would speak to a property lawyer and serve notice on them to vacate your parents land if they have no licence. It need a lawyer to understand the rights of NR. Is there anything in your parents title for the red land relating to rights for the railway?

You can't do much about the noise, its a consequence of where your parents live and the best time to do the work

speed_monkey

Original Poster:

3,503 posts

220 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Panda P said:
It's a hazzard of owning property near any infrastructure for transport unfortuately and while annoying for those that owned property previously not near to it (think of all the people currently up in arms over CrossRail) I think that anyone buying a property near to any kind of this type infrastrucure needs to be aware of the potential for disruption.

Repairs need to be done and there is no arguement about it; either we want a prompt and safe service or we don't and frankly, the latter is not an option. Contractors are only allowed, by contract, to enter the site between certain hours to avoid disruption to services and for safety of course. Contractors must also have left and made safe the site after each shift meaning that the beginning and end of each shift can be quite noisy whilst things are packed/unpacked/grinded off etc and is not as simple as 'tools down, off you go'.

In short there's nothing that you can do about the noise and you'd be very lucky to get any financial sum that would pay towards a hotel stay for that period.

In regard to use of your paren'ts land, appropriate advise has already been given. NR, or their Contractors, are obligated to leave the land on other's property as found. In a few cases that I know of, where a house is alongside the tracks and works have been performed, the owner has had new gardens, fences and driveway paid for as NR ran over a considerable amount of it (previously agreed).
Thats the thing though - this wasn't previously agreed.

I agree the works are essential, I understand this, and so too do my parents. However, the timing is a bit questionable, no? Christmas eve the bridge is being demolished.

speed_monkey

Original Poster:

3,503 posts

220 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
blueg33 said:
Op, is it Network Rail we are talking about?

If so they have pretty wide ranging powers and are a right royal pain in the ass to deal with. Took me 4 years to sort out a boundary encroachment.

Do they have a licence to occupy your parents land? What notification have they given?

Personally I would speak to a property lawyer and serve notice on them to vacate your parents land if they have no licence. It need a lawyer to understand the rights of NR. Is there anything in your parents title for the red land relating to rights for the railway?

You can't do much about the noise, its a consequence of where your parents live and the best time to do the work
Nolicence whatsoever, and no agreement for the land to be used. They did not notify they would be using the land at all.

And apologies, it is NETWORK rail not national rail

Panda P

247 posts

167 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
speed_monkey said:
Thats the thing though - this wasn't previously agreed.

I agree the works are essential, I understand this, and so too do my parents. However, the timing is a bit questionable, no? Christmas eve the bridge is being demolished.
Then there is at least a case for 'making right' your parents land. Is the damage severe and what to? As I imagine properties next to the railway, there is usually fence of the property owner's, a metal/chainlink fence of NR's and a gap between the two. The gap is usually that of the property owner's but in most cases is just left as a strip of wasteland.

There is no goodwill amongst this type of company at Christmas as the theory is that as Christmas approaches the demand for services decreases (less commuters). It's flawed logic if you ask me but it's usually the busiest time of the year for major works with tight programmes set for go-live by the first week of January. National Rail have literally been throwing money at implementing improvement works this year, probably to justify (for once) the circa 9% rise in fares next year.

speed_monkey

Original Poster:

3,503 posts

220 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Hmmm I think this is a bit more complicated than previously thought.

I will tell my parents to seek advice from someone in the know when it comes to these things.

I guess with regards to the noise and disruption its a case of shut up and put up? its been 5 weeks of hell and wont stop till end onf January frown

Thanks anyway guys

blueg33

47,023 posts

255 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
No licence!

IANAL but this is what I would do.

First off that needs a letter sending immediately to NR property dept with a plan showing your parents title and the area of land within that which is being occupied.

The letter needs to state that the land is your parents property and that they have not given permission for access and storage of materials etc thereon. You need to state that this is trespassing and that you are seeking legal advice and are considering an injunction.

This is best coming from a solicitor. I did a similar letter only stronger last year where NR had dumped spoil containing Japanese Knotweed on one of my sites

Exige77

6,523 posts

222 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
blueg33 said:
No licence!

IANAL but this is what I would do.

First off that needs a letter sending immediately to NR property dept with a plan showing your parents title and the area of land within that which is being occupied.

The letter needs to state that the land is your parents property and that they have not given permission for access and storage of materials etc thereon. You need to state that this is trespassing and that you are seeking legal advice and are considering an injunction.

This is best coming from a solicitor. I did a similar letter only stronger last year where NR had dumped spoil containing Japanese Knotweed on one of my sites
Will this stop the Noise and bright lights ?

I thought that was the main problem ?

Panda P

247 posts

167 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
It's a case of put up with the noise and light pollution I'm afraid as they are essential byproducts of the required works.

At a previous property that was fairly close to a railway bridge we had the exact same nuisance. In the end I invested in (this sounds daft but really worked for drowing out the noise) earplugs and a sleep sounds app for my phone in which I blasted out the pattering of rain from the phone's speaker. Both combined worked very well.

Podie

46,650 posts

306 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
My understanding was that NR basically have carte blanche as the law on their side - for example, if your trees overhand the railway they can force you to remove them.

chrisjackson184

7 posts

212 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
BTW, it's Network Rail.

I'd double check the land boundaries before doing anything else. I've worked in the rail industry and have come across issues where home owners thought they owned land up to the back of footway, when in reality they owned only to the bottom of embankment and at some point in the past the fence got moved. Double check the land registry plan. If NR have gained access across your parent's land without an appropriate order / consent then there is much more to complain about.

Sadly the noise is a fact of life. Rail bridges need replacing and the work is noisy the only opportunity to get a long enough rail closure to do this is Christmas and sometimes Easter. The guys working the shifts over Christmas don't like it much either.

speed_monkey

Original Poster:

3,503 posts

220 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Exige77 said:
blueg33 said:
No licence!

IANAL but this is what I would do.

First off that needs a letter sending immediately to NR property dept with a plan showing your parents title and the area of land within that which is being occupied.

The letter needs to state that the land is your parents property and that they have not given permission for access and storage of materials etc thereon. You need to state that this is trespassing and that you are seeking legal advice and are considering an injunction.

This is best coming from a solicitor. I did a similar letter only stronger last year where NR had dumped spoil containing Japanese Knotweed on one of my sites
Will this stop the Noise and bright lights ?

I thought that was the main problem ?
There is no "main pproblem"

Yes the noise is annoying, especially when its every night 7 days a week but also the destroyed land and lack of security is just as bad

blueg33

47,023 posts

255 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Noise will be temporary, land issues won't necessarily go away unless you make them go away

POORCARDEALER

8,670 posts

272 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
My land borders onto a railway and its written into our deeds that they have right of access through our property to carry out works should they need to (hasnt happened in 14 years )

blueg33

47,023 posts

255 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Which is why I asked the OP what the Title says