Protected no claims.
Author
Discussion

Perec

Original Poster:

28,176 posts

253 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all

I pay for protected no claims and am just about to make a claim. Aviva tells me that this will put up my premium. Apparently claiming puts up the premium, protecting no claims just means that I will still get the same percentage discount off the increased premium.

Is protected NCB a bit of a con?

TPS

1,860 posts

244 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
No.
It's very simple,it provides a percentage discount on your premium based on your risk.

Without ncb you do not get the reduction.



How did you think it works?

What happened with the Range Rover and the recovery?

Nick1point9

3,920 posts

211 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
say you have a policy price of £500 and NCB equivalent to 75% - You'll pay £125.
You claim, and this means that you are statistically a higher risk, policy price is now £1000.

Protected no claims you'll still get a 75% discount, paying £250. No protected NCB you'll get 0% NCB so pay £1000.

Easy.

TPS

1,860 posts

244 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Perec said:
I pay for protected no claims and am just about to make a claim. Aviva tells me that this will put up my premium. Apparently claiming puts up the premium, protecting no claims just means that I will still get the same percentage discount off the increased premium.

Is protected NCB a bit of a con?
So your amazed that claiming puts up your premium. rofl

Perec

Original Poster:

28,176 posts

253 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all

Perhaps I didn't explain myself clearly enough.

There is an asymmetry of information regarding how premiums are calculated. Therefore the insurer can adjust premiums upwards to compensate for the increase that will not be levied as a result of reduced no claims.

The question I was asking really is whether broadly speaking premiums are increased to a point that negates the effect of protected NCB.

tex200

447 posts

202 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Perec said:
The question I was asking really is whether broadly speaking premiums are increased to a point that negates the effect of protected NCB.
Quite possibly, but I doubt the insurers would ever admit to it!

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Perec said:
I pay for protected no claims and am just about to make a claim. Aviva tells me that this will put up my premium. Apparently claiming puts up the premium, protecting no claims just means that I will still get the same percentage discount off the increased premium.

Is protected NCB a bit of a con?
Yes, it is a bit of a con.
It is implied you're protecting your premium, but you aren't.

Also, for many insurers the Max discount is applied at 5 years.
Any more is recorded but makes no difference, if you have a claim them may only take off 3 years no claims, so you still get full discount anyway.

In some ways you are a bit silly for not checking this before spending your money, but on the other hand the insurers have put a lot if effort into getting the wording right to entice customers.
So, don't feel too bad about it. smile

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
Yes, it is a bit of a con.
It is implied you're protecting your premium, but you aren't.

Also, for many insurers the Max discount is applied at 5 years.
Any more is recorded but makes no difference, if you have a claim them may only take off 3 years no claims, so you still get full discount anyway.

In some ways you are a bit silly for not checking this before spending your money, but on the other hand the insurers have put a lot if effort into getting the wording right to entice customers.
So, don't feel too bad about it. smile
If an Insurer gives a maximum of five years no claims bonus you will lose two years no claims taking you back to three years. The typical discounts would be 65% and 50% respectively.

As an example a gross premium of £1000 would equate to £350 after 65% no claims or £500 after 50%, any loadings for a claim would be on top of these figures so having protected would obviously save you money (Ignoring the initial cost of protected no claims which is circa 15%).

Protected no claims tends to help even out your premiums making it easier to budget and if you have a low excess means you can afford to claim for smaller incidents which may not be worth it without protected.

If you have more than one fault claim in the space of a couple of years, then protected makes much larger savings.

TwigtheWonderkid

49,308 posts

181 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
Yes, it is a bit of a con.
It is implied you're protecting your premium, but you aren't.
It isn't a con and it doesn't imply that. No one I know thinks that. The premium can increase even if you don't claim. Everyone realised that. But the bonus itself is protected.

How is it a con? It's called protected bonus and it protects your bonus. If it protected your premium it would be called protected premium.

Nick1point9

3,920 posts

211 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Perec said:
Perhaps I didn't explain myself clearly enough.

There is an asymmetry of information regarding how premiums are calculated. Therefore the insurer can adjust premiums upwards to compensate for the increase that will not be levied as a result of reduced no claims.

The question I was asking really is whether broadly speaking premiums are increased to a point that negates the effect of protected NCB.
In that case, using a comparison site compare the prices for a driver with a claim and X years' no claims, and a driver with the same claim and 0 NCB. That will make it clear enough.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
Snowboy said:
Yes, it is a bit of a con.
It is implied you're protecting your premium, but you aren't.
It isn't a con and it doesn't imply that. No one I know thinks that. The premium can increase even if you don't claim. Everyone realised that. But the bonus itself is protected.

How is it a con? It's called protected bonus and it protects your bonus. If it protected your premium it would be called protected premium.
This is more a matter of opinion and perception than one of fact.

I consider it to be a bit of a con.
You don't.

It is quite common for people to be surprised when thier premium goes up even though it was protected.
This is a mistake on their part of course, but the fact it happens so often leads me to believe it's not being explained well when sold.

I questioned an insurance agent about it a while back when buying insurance and they were very evasive.

I think it's the costomers fault if they buy it without knowing what it is, but I also think insurers are a bit sneaky in how they sell it.

I thought the same about the ppi thing too though, and look how that turned out.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Perec said:
I pay for protected no claims and am just about to make a claim. Aviva tells me that this will put up my premium. Apparently claiming puts up the premium, protecting no claims just means that I will still get the same percentage discount off the increased premium.

Is protected NCB a bit of a con?
And I thought you had surpassed yourself with your complaint about the police charging £150 to securely recover and store your stolen Range Rover whilst doing all they could to catch the thief was genius. This beats that one.

supersport

4,646 posts

258 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Personally I think protected NCB is a waste of time. I stopped paying it some 11 years ago and thereby have more than saved the difference.

Somewhat thickly I assumed that it protected my premiums, until it occurred to me that the premium would simply go up to negate the saving. Also if you moved insurer they would simply raise the premium in response to the claim. Either way you wouldn't save very much.


Perec

Original Poster:

28,176 posts

253 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
Perec said:
I pay for protected no claims and am just about to make a claim. Aviva tells me that this will put up my premium. Apparently claiming puts up the premium, protecting no claims just means that I will still get the same percentage discount off the increased premium.

Is protected NCB a bit of a con?
And I thought you had surpassed yourself with your complaint about the police charging £150 to securely recover and store your stolen Range Rover whilst doing all they could to catch the thief was genius. This beats that one.
Twisting the facts and missing the point twice in succession. What is it you do for a job Loon?

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Perec said:
Twisting the facts and missing the point twice in succession. What is it you do for a job Loon?
You moaned explicitly on the thread about the cost. Others pointed out your failings on there not me.

Apparently I'm a Call Centre worker in insurance according to some on here. You don't have to work in insurance though to know what a policy called Protected No Claims Discount / Bonus protects as many above have proven.

Edited by LoonR1 on Tuesday 3rd December 17:56

chevy-stu

5,392 posts

259 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
After reading this I doubt if I'll bother with Protected NCB next time on my motor policies. I also foolishly assumed for years it protected the premium not the % discount... (as mentioned already, premium can be hiked to suit, hence making protected element pointless)..

TPS

1,860 posts

244 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
Perec said:
I pay for protected no claims and am just about to make a claim. Aviva tells me that this will put up my premium. Apparently claiming puts up the premium, protecting no claims just means that I will still get the same percentage discount off the increased premium.

Is protected NCB a bit of a con?
And I thought you had surpassed yourself with your complaint about the police charging £150 to securely recover and store your stolen Range Rover whilst doing all they could to catch the thief was genius. This beats that one.
I have to say I agree with loon here.

Perec

Original Poster:

28,176 posts

253 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
Perec said:
Twisting the facts and missing the point twice in succession. What is it you do for a job Loon?
You moaned explicitly on the thread about the cost. Others pointed out your failings on there not me.

Apparently I'm a Call Centre worker in insurance according to some on here. You don't have to work in insurance though to know what a policy called Protected No Claims Discount / Bonus protects as many above have proven.

Edited by LoonR1 on Tuesday 3rd December 17:56
I didn't moan about the cost at all. I merely questioned whether the cost should be borne by me or the police. A letter I've received from the police today suggests that it should have been them, but we'll see.

So according to you, what is it you do for a job? Are you really a call centre worker in insurance?


LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
Perec said:
I didn't moan about the cost at all. I merely questioned whether the cost should be borne by me or the police. A letter I've received from the police today suggests that it should have been them, but we'll see.

So according to you, what is it you do for a job? Are you really a call centre worker in insurance?
I do a job insurance.

Perec

Original Poster:

28,176 posts

253 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2013
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
Perec said:
I didn't moan about the cost at all. I merely questioned whether the cost should be borne by me or the police. A letter I've received from the police today suggests that it should have been them, but we'll see.

So according to you, what is it you do for a job? Are you really a call centre worker in insurance?
I do a job insurance.
Specifically?