Barrister cab rank
Author
Discussion

DP1

Original Poster:

289 posts

252 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
I was just walking past a taxi rank in Leeds and this got me thinking (sadly) about the way the barristers are allocated cases. I understand that this is done on the 'cab rank' principle so barristers can't pick and choose what cases they want (so no cherry picking).

Am I right in thinking this is correct and if it is, is it possible for some major case/person to be represented by someone who is not as talented as one of the top guys.

It always seems that big cases attract star counsel, is this just the luck of the draw?

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
Are you saying that a solicitor is not free as to which QC he/she can instruct? IANAL but I find that hard to believe.

DP1

Original Poster:

289 posts

252 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
Cut out of wiki -

In English law (and other countries which adopt the rule), the cab-rank rule is the obligation of a barrister to accept any work in a field in which he professes himself competent to practise, at a court at which he normally appears, and at his usual rates. The rule derives its name from the tradition by which a Hackney carriage driver at the head of a queue of taxicabs is supposed to take the first passenger requesting a ride.

Paragraph 602 of the Code of Conduct of the Bar of England and Wales states:

A self-employed barrister must comply with the "Cab-rank rule" and accordingly except only as otherwise provided in paragraphs 603 604 605 and 606 he must in any field in which he professes to practise in relation to work appropriate to his experience and seniority and irrespective of whether his client is paying privately or is publicly funded:

(a) accept any brief to appear before a Court in which he professes to practise;

(b) accept any instructions;

(c) act for any person on whose behalf he is instructed;

and do so irrespective of (i) the party on whose behalf he is instructed (ii) the nature of the case and (iii) any belief or opinion which he may have formed as to the character reputation cause conduct guilt or innocence of that person.[1]

In the absence of such a rule, it might be difficult for an unpopular person to obtain legal representation, and barristers who act for such people might be criticised for doing so.


This is why I was asking. I'm not quite sure if I've understood it correctly but it may not be possible to get the barrister of choice if others are available and ahead in the queue

supersport

4,646 posts

258 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
It doesn't work like that, solicitors ask for a specific Barrister, that one may not be available and so they may get another or go to a different chambers.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
It is only a cab rank in the sense of an obligation on the cab driver to take the punter. The punter is not obliged to get into the taxi at the front of the line. In other words, the client can choose which counsel to instruct, and counsel is not able to refuse the case if he/she is available, it is within his/her field of practice and an adequate fee is offered (legal aid is deemed adequate, although in practice it often isn't).

The cab rank principle is important, as it enables people with bad cases or who are unpopular with the public to obtain representation. Of course, as with a real taxi, there are more or less subtle ways of saying "South of the river, Guv? You're having a giraffe".

PS: the cab rank rule does not stop the ill informed from criticising barristers who represent unpopular clients simply for representing them (see comments in the news section of PH on high profile cases).

Edited by anonymous-user on Wednesday 4th December 14:11

DP1

Original Poster:

289 posts

252 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for that BV, much clearer now.

So in your experience are there many cases where a barrister is representing someone they would rather not? It would imagine that in these cases it would be quite hard for a counsel to be as enthusiastic in their work as someone who is representing someone they want to.

Just to add, I'm sure that their professional standards would be maintained but it must be hard.

Shnozz

30,694 posts

302 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
DP1 said:
Thanks for that BV, much clearer now.

So in your experience are there many cases where a barrister is representing someone they would rather not? It would imagine that in these cases it would be quite hard for a counsel to be as enthusiastic in their work as someone who is representing someone they want to.

Just to add, I'm sure that their professional standards would be maintained but it must be hard.
As Breadvan states, the cab rank is symbolic only of the fact that they cannot refuse the case. The reality is no different to a taxi driver also - they can find any number of 'genuine' reasons why they would not take it on, the most obvious simply being their availability. It's not as though the instructing solicitor (or the parties to the case) will follow up to check whether this was a genuine swerve, or indeed what the consequence would be even if this were to be uncovered.

It's a fairly draconian measure that never plays out in real life.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
You try your hardest even when you don't think your client has a good case, or think his position lacks moral merit even if legally correct, as doing so comes with the professional territory. Being human, it is natural perhaps to perform better when you think the case has merit, but you try to maintain detached judgment.

There are probably few barristers who have not found excuses for not taking a case, but the cab rank rule isn't a mere cipher. I once had to represent a sports coach accused by his sport's governing body in disciplinary proceedings of being a child molester. I wasn't thrilled, but I worked hard and didn't judge the man, as that wasn't my job. I later had to pass the case to a colleague after the first hearing because of a diary clash. I had to give my colleague a bit of a pep talk on the cab rank rule, as he was reluctant to take the case, but he then got on with it.

I am glad that I don't do criminal cases, but even in civil work I have represented some right scumbags, (including two or three prime ministers).

V8LM

5,566 posts

240 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
Well, is it two or is it three?

Two or three is a term used by someone who knows it not to be one. So two or three probably means more does it not Mr BV. Four perhaps. smile

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
Dredging my memory, well dodgy clients include Thatch, Major and Blair, and a few of Cameron's ministers, but not him. I've got quite a good set of Home Secretaries, each more slippery and unreliable than the last. They pay rubbish, too.

3Dee

3,206 posts

252 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
Dredging my memory, well dodgy clients include Thatch, Major and Blair, and a few of Cameron's ministers, but not him. I've got quite a good set of Home Secretaries, each more slippery and unreliable than the last. They pay rubbish, too.
I feel a book coming on......OH IF ONLY! biggrin
It would sell in it's millions, but you might have to move to Russia.....hmmmm!

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
You try your hardest even when you don't think your client has a good case, or think his position lacks moral merit even if legally correct, as doing so comes with the professional territory. Being human, it is natural perhaps to perform better when you think the case has merit, but you try to maintain detached judgment.
The bit that always amuses me though is clients who really take the adversarial thing literally. The losers get all het up if they happen to have seen their QC exchanging a friendly smile during a recess or have a friendly conversation after the trial with opposing Counsel. They seem to think that hostilities should prevail 24/7. They don't understand that a courtroom is rather like a stage and both silks are actors playing specific parts. Life outside the arena is not the same.





Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
...and an adequate fee is offered (legal aid is deemed adequate, although in practice it often isn't...
So i take it you are not on the VHCC 'Blackleg' list then winkhehe

ETA read further on down now - sounds like you aren't having to pony up to that bun fight!

Edited by Rude-boy on Wednesday 4th December 16:43

7db

6,060 posts

261 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
No cab rank for no win no fee cases.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
That is correct, because the cab rank rule only applies if a market rate or legal aid fee is offered. Taking on a conditional fee agreement is a matter of choice, as is taking on a pro bono case (ie working for free).

Solicitors, by the way, have no cab rank rule and can choose their clients, but market forces may narrow the choice, at least at the cheaper end of the market.

jensenhealey2

163 posts

190 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
Breadvan72 said:
You try your hardest even when you don't think your client has a good case, or think his position lacks moral merit even if legally correct, as doing so comes with the professional territory. Being human, it is natural perhaps to perform better when you think the case has merit, but you try to maintain detached judgment.
The bit that always amuses me though is clients who really take the adversarial thing literally. The losers get all het up if they happen to have seen their QC exchanging a friendly smile during a recess or have a friendly conversation after the trial with opposing Counsel. They seem to think that hostilities should prevail 24/7. They don't understand that a courtroom is rather like a stage and both silks are actors playing specific parts. Life outside the arena is not the same.
A story I was told when I started out in the legal caper concerned a (now retired) intellectual property barrister who never took things too seriously (even as a silk), who unwisely turned to his opposite number on a shortish application to a judge and said, " We should be able to spin htis out for a couple of days. The patent attorney involved in the case refused ever again to have him on a case he (the patent attorney) was concerned with.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 5th December 2013
quotequote all
What? An IP lawyer with a sense of humour? That would never happen.

Lowtimer

4,293 posts

199 months

Thursday 5th December 2013
quotequote all
Indeed: patently absurd, one might say.