UKPC Breach of Contract Parking Fine
Discussion
I recently parked in a free car park and obtained a penalty ticket of £60 from UKPC. The reason for the penalty was I had parked across two bays.
The car park was empty and it was on a sunday. I parked in this fashion as I was attending an emergency vets with one of my bull dogs. I needed to make sure I had complete access to harness him back in to the fron seat of a two seater car (The wife had my landrover so I was forced to use the TT). Parking at an angle meant i would retain access to the drivers door.
Where do I stand with this. I under stand these arent fines or legal penalites, they are actually this organisation trying to extract cash on the grounds of breach of contract.
Additional Info-
The ticket was virtually in comprehensible as the information was not printerd in the correct blank boxes.
I made them aware of this in there online appeal but they seemed to think that was fine..
The car park was empty and it was on a sunday. I parked in this fashion as I was attending an emergency vets with one of my bull dogs. I needed to make sure I had complete access to harness him back in to the fron seat of a two seater car (The wife had my landrover so I was forced to use the TT). Parking at an angle meant i would retain access to the drivers door.
Where do I stand with this. I under stand these arent fines or legal penalites, they are actually this organisation trying to extract cash on the grounds of breach of contract.
Additional Info-
The ticket was virtually in comprehensible as the information was not printerd in the correct blank boxes.
I made them aware of this in there online appeal but they seemed to think that was fine..
Einion Yrth said:
You expected an empty car park to fill completely while you were at the vets?
Sounds g4y but i have damaged a tendon in my ankle and the vets is inside Pets at home. The car park is shared by Marks and spencers, halfords etc etc I arrived early morning so it could well have picked up.Let's think this through.
1. Is there a contract? Did you have the opportunity to agree to the terms of the contract? Was the signage clear? With reasonable care (and forget the dog's emergency) could you have read and agreed to the terms?
2. If there is a contract, are they entitled to enforce it? On what basis? Are they actually instructed by the landowner to enforce on their behalf? If so, the contract may be with the landowner, not with the parking company. Does the parking company understand this and have they followed it? If they are bringing the claim in their own name, they may not have a contract with you (but they may be authorised to contract, so this may not go anywhere).
3. If there is a contract then did it specify that parking across two bays would be a breach? (Probably but you should check!)
4. If there is a contract, is the fee:
a. the parking charge for the second space - i.e., you've breached by not paying a fee?; or
b. a genuine pre-assessment of loss (and if so, is it the company's loss?).
If a. then that should have been clear that these were the fees. If b. then it can include an amount for recovering the loss but the costs of recovery can't be the sole basis for that recovery. What it cannot be, assuming that this is a normal privately owned car park, is a penalty designed to encourage particular behaviour: it must be reflective of a reasonable assessment of the loss (to the landowner or tenant of the car park) as a result of the breach. It does not have to be the loss as a result of your particular breach (i.e., if someone suffers £20 of lost profit + £40 of enforcement on average, including when the car park is full) it is not a defence to show that there was no loss in your particular case because the car park was empty, but there must be a loss in general).
1. Is there a contract? Did you have the opportunity to agree to the terms of the contract? Was the signage clear? With reasonable care (and forget the dog's emergency) could you have read and agreed to the terms?
2. If there is a contract, are they entitled to enforce it? On what basis? Are they actually instructed by the landowner to enforce on their behalf? If so, the contract may be with the landowner, not with the parking company. Does the parking company understand this and have they followed it? If they are bringing the claim in their own name, they may not have a contract with you (but they may be authorised to contract, so this may not go anywhere).
3. If there is a contract then did it specify that parking across two bays would be a breach? (Probably but you should check!)
4. If there is a contract, is the fee:
a. the parking charge for the second space - i.e., you've breached by not paying a fee?; or
b. a genuine pre-assessment of loss (and if so, is it the company's loss?).
If a. then that should have been clear that these were the fees. If b. then it can include an amount for recovering the loss but the costs of recovery can't be the sole basis for that recovery. What it cannot be, assuming that this is a normal privately owned car park, is a penalty designed to encourage particular behaviour: it must be reflective of a reasonable assessment of the loss (to the landowner or tenant of the car park) as a result of the breach. It does not have to be the loss as a result of your particular breach (i.e., if someone suffers £20 of lost profit + £40 of enforcement on average, including when the car park is full) it is not a defence to show that there was no loss in your particular case because the car park was empty, but there must be a loss in general).
Thanks CYMRO. From what I can see reading around this is a grey area. I have asked them what the loss would be in this car park and they have instantly reffered to a previous case which went to court.
As you can see from the below, in response to my appeal, the reply seems to have been written by one of nasa's chimpanzees with a new type writer. (They didnt attach a copy of the "incorrectly completed" ticket, although they think it was "InCompletely Corrected".

As you can see from the below, in response to my appeal, the reply seems to have been written by one of nasa's chimpanzees with a new type writer. (They didnt attach a copy of the "incorrectly completed" ticket, although they think it was "InCompletely Corrected".
Edited by m4tti on Friday 6th December 12:18
I'd head to peepeepoopoo, they specialise in this kind of thing on their forum.
I'd say that I had something similar, and I wrote back once telling them to take a short walk off a long pier, and have heard nothing since. But the law is constantly changing with these cowboy outfits, so that's the place to go.
I'd say that I had something similar, and I wrote back once telling them to take a short walk off a long pier, and have heard nothing since. But the law is constantly changing with these cowboy outfits, so that's the place to go.
Genuine pre-estimate of loss is NOT the costs of running the business (stationery, wages for the person issuing the ticket, uniforms etc), rather in this case it would (for example) be something like the loss of revenue from the driver taking up two spaces and only paying for one... PPCs seem to get this wrong a lot
.
OP, first wait for their "notice to keeper" (don't do anything now, as this costs them £2.50 and they may get the timing wrong). Then appeal to UKPC, KISS along the lines of appealing against the ticket because the parking charge does not reflect their true losses and is punitive and ask for a POPLA code if they refuse your appeal. Then appeal to POPLA (this costs them £27+VAT) with a stronger appeal along the same lines and maybe a few other points (lack of sufficient interest in the land to attempt to form contracts such as the one they are claiming, for example) - but bear in mind that POPLA only consider one appeal point so there's no point in going crazy.
If POPLA refuse your appeal, it's not binding on the registered keeper anyway
.
See pepipoo.com (specifically their private parking forum), moneysavingexpert and parkingprankster websites for more details
.
.OP, first wait for their "notice to keeper" (don't do anything now, as this costs them £2.50 and they may get the timing wrong). Then appeal to UKPC, KISS along the lines of appealing against the ticket because the parking charge does not reflect their true losses and is punitive and ask for a POPLA code if they refuse your appeal. Then appeal to POPLA (this costs them £27+VAT) with a stronger appeal along the same lines and maybe a few other points (lack of sufficient interest in the land to attempt to form contracts such as the one they are claiming, for example) - but bear in mind that POPLA only consider one appeal point so there's no point in going crazy.
If POPLA refuse your appeal, it's not binding on the registered keeper anyway
.See pepipoo.com (specifically their private parking forum), moneysavingexpert and parkingprankster websites for more details
.I rarely post on these parking threads, as they make my head explode with tedium, but if no charge is made for parking at this place on Sundays, then the loss caused by someone taking up two spaces instead of one is twice times zero.
Cosmic Karma dictates that anyone who parks like the OP did deserves some sort of mild and moderate punishment such as being tortured to death live on public telly, but as a matter of contract the OP has a defence.
BTW, some might say there is no contract if the punter does not have to pay to park, but the punter provides consideration by agreeing to park according to the rules. Also, "Thou shalt not park like a total f
kbat" is one of the eternal rules of the universe.
Cosmic Karma dictates that anyone who parks like the OP did deserves some sort of mild and moderate punishment such as being tortured to death live on public telly, but as a matter of contract the OP has a defence.
BTW, some might say there is no contract if the punter does not have to pay to park, but the punter provides consideration by agreeing to park according to the rules. Also, "Thou shalt not park like a total f
kbat" is one of the eternal rules of the universe. Breadvan72 said:
I rarely post on these parking threads, as they make my head explode with tedium, but if no charge is made for parking at this place on Sundays, then the loss caused by someone taking up two spaces instead of one is twice times zero.
Genius.Say that you realised you needed two bays - so paid up fully for those two spaces in order not to leave them out of pocket.
You have proof - send them a photo of a completely empty dashboard.
m4tti said:
I recently parked in a free car park and obtained a penalty ticket of £60 from UKPC. The reason for the penalty was I had parked across two bays.
The car park was empty and it was on a sunday. I parked in this fashion as I was attending an emergency vets with one of my bull dogs. I needed to make sure I had complete access to harness him back in to the fron seat of a two seater car (The wife had my landrover so I was forced to use the TT). Parking at an angle meant i would retain access to the drivers door.
Where do I stand with this. I under stand these arent fines or legal penalites, they are actually this organisation trying to extract cash on the grounds of breach of contract.
Additional Info-
The ticket was virtually in comprehensible as the information was not printerd in the correct blank boxes.
I made them aware of this in there online appeal but they seemed to think that was fine..
Serious question: if the car park was empty, why did you need to straddle two bays in order to ensure you had 'complete access'? Surely if there were so few vehicles parked, you would have been able to park with nothing else around you thereby ensuring said access?The car park was empty and it was on a sunday. I parked in this fashion as I was attending an emergency vets with one of my bull dogs. I needed to make sure I had complete access to harness him back in to the fron seat of a two seater car (The wife had my landrover so I was forced to use the TT). Parking at an angle meant i would retain access to the drivers door.
Where do I stand with this. I under stand these arent fines or legal penalites, they are actually this organisation trying to extract cash on the grounds of breach of contract.
Additional Info-
The ticket was virtually in comprehensible as the information was not printerd in the correct blank boxes.
I made them aware of this in there online appeal but they seemed to think that was fine..
Funk said:
Serious question: if the car park was empty, why did you need to straddle two bays in order to ensure you had 'complete access'? Surely if there were so few vehicles parked, you would have been able to park with nothing else around you thereby ensuring said access?
See above, lame excuse, a combination of being injured myself and wanting to rush the dog in. Yes I should be pilloried for s
t parking. m4tti said:
Sounds g4y but i have damaged a tendon in my ankle and the vets is inside Pets at home. The car park is shared by Marks and spencers, halfords etc etc I arrived early morning so it could well have picked up.
Edited by m4tti on Friday 6th December 13:31
m4tti said:
Funk said:
Serious question: if the car park was empty, why did you need to straddle two bays in order to ensure you had 'complete access'? Surely if there were so few vehicles parked, you would have been able to park with nothing else around you thereby ensuring said access?
See abovem4tti said:
Sounds g4y but i have damaged a tendon in my ankle and the vets is inside Pets at home. The car park is shared by Marks and spencers, halfords etc etc I arrived early morning so it could well have picked up.
k all in my view.Breadvan72 said:
If no charge is made for parking at this place on Sundays, then the loss caused by someone taking up two spaces instead of one is twice times zero.
I agree that their actual loss is probably zero (probably one times zero as consideration was provided for the other zero, but I digress...)However isn't that kind of the point of liquidated damages? In other words, neither party has either a right or obligation to sit down and calculate the actual loss but rather that they can show that the car park tends to fill up over the course of the week (or would do so but for the enforcement of LDs) and that the average loss of profitability caused by the landowner is £x and therefore in the interests of efficient administration, everyone who is in breach of contract is assessed at £x + their reasonable costs of enforcement (not running the business per se but the work caused by administration).
As for the burden of proof question - certainly it's true that it lies with the person asserting that it is a penalty and not a pre-estimate of loss, but the fact that:
1. There may demonstrably be no actual loss other than spurious costs of enforcement;
2. The clause appears designed to encourage certain behaviour rather than to recover losses
suggests that it may be a penalty rather than LDs, at least in the absence of supporting evidence (i.e., the balance of probabilities test is a relatively low barrier if the party seeking to rely on the clause cannot advance *any* evidence rather than 'because we say so.') In fact, depending on the business model, the parking company may be in a very difficult position arguing that these are LDs because they will almost always be better off in the breach of the contract than in the observance.
Edited by CYMR0 on Friday 6th December 13:35
supersport said:
If the car park was empty why would some jobsworth bother to issue a ticket, it wasn't causing a problem 
Facetiously, because he's been told to and it is indeed more than his job is worth.
More broadly, because in this particular case, because the liquidated damages are recoverable against the driver and therefore the company can use them to offset any loss that arises when such parking does cause a problem.
A liquidated damages clause only works when addressing a situation in which loss will be caused. A clause which provides for damages in a situation in which loss could never be incurred must by its very nature be an unenforceable penalty.
The clause might work in respect of a day when parking is charged for, but if the contract is made on a zero charge day, the clause cannot be a genuine estimate of loss.
The clause might work in respect of a day when parking is charged for, but if the contract is made on a zero charge day, the clause cannot be a genuine estimate of loss.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



