Wrong date booked by ticket company - resolution?
Discussion
SWMBO booked tickets for a concert on a Saturday night, over the phone. Tickets came through, but for a different (very much less suitable) date.
Ticket company has checked the phonecalls, apologised for the administrative error on the part of the call handler, and stated that SWMBO cannot have the Saturday night tickets as originally contracted because there are none left. They have suggested that SWMBO goes to the concert on the very much less suitable date, or is refunded the original purchase price.
SMWBO is unhappy and feels that she's losing out because of the negligence of the ticket booking company. She wants to see the concert, and isn't interested in a refund, but isn't happy about watching a performance that isn't the Saturday night (as originally specified at point of sale).
What would y'all suggest was an acceptable possible resolution for this from the ticket company's perspective? (I'm not asking you to enter the mind of SWMBO for even a second!)
Some cash/vouchers back?
Free tickets to the alternative unsuitable date?
VIP tickets to the Saturday night?
Ticket company has checked the phonecalls, apologised for the administrative error on the part of the call handler, and stated that SWMBO cannot have the Saturday night tickets as originally contracted because there are none left. They have suggested that SWMBO goes to the concert on the very much less suitable date, or is refunded the original purchase price.
SMWBO is unhappy and feels that she's losing out because of the negligence of the ticket booking company. She wants to see the concert, and isn't interested in a refund, but isn't happy about watching a performance that isn't the Saturday night (as originally specified at point of sale).
What would y'all suggest was an acceptable possible resolution for this from the ticket company's perspective? (I'm not asking you to enter the mind of SWMBO for even a second!)
Some cash/vouchers back?
Free tickets to the alternative unsuitable date?
VIP tickets to the Saturday night?
AngryPartsBloke said:
They are only required to place you back in a postion you were before I belive? Which would be the refund, they might offer some sort of compensation as a customer service exercise and you could argue that this might even be expected but i wouldn't think it to be mandatory.
Thanks for the reply! Yeah they've initially offered refund/alternative tickets which would appear to be fair enough from their perspective, in a financial accounting sense. I initially said that to SWMBO: "what do you want them to do? They've offered a refund or an alternative..." which was a bad idea on my part 
In an admittedly pseudo-legal sense: SWMBO should be in the position of having Saturday night tickets. But she isn't, because of the company's error. Although the financial face-value of other nights might be the same, they aren't to my other half in this case.
I'll see what they say to it after further email contact. The chap from complaints emailed to say: "please let me know if you would like a refund or tickets for the alternative date."
The reply will explain that Saturday night was the best night, and the alternative night will be much less enjoyable because of the prospect of work in the morning. We understand that the company have a difficult position on their hands here, but think it would be reaonable for them to offer some recompense because of their error. In this case I'd suggest free tickets to the alternative date, and perhaps some money on top so we can "meet in the middle" at free tickets.
Edited by simoid on Friday 6th December 11:51
AngryPartsBloke said:
They are only required to place you back in a position you were before I believe? Which would be the refund, they might offer some sort of compensation as a customer service exercise and you could argue that this might even be expected but i wouldn't think it to be mandatory.
Nope, that's the measure of damages for tort - i.e., you're put in the position you'd have been in had the tort not been committed.In contract, you're entitled to be put in the position you'd have been in had the contract been fulfilled, i.e., you pay £x and you get £x worth of stuff.
That said, the idea that you get free tickets + compensation (so that a night out is cheaper than a night in watching reruns of Murder She Wrote) is not even slightly reasonable, because you can still go out with your £x and get £x of stuff on another night.
If there were tickets available when you called you might have a case.
But, if they were already sold out I don't think you would.
I'm pretty sure there's nothing to be done here.
These ticket places work on tiny margins so they can't afford to be gracious - and unless you are a good repeat customer they won't care about customer service.
It sucks.
But there's not much that can be done about it.
But, if they were already sold out I don't think you would.
I'm pretty sure there's nothing to be done here.
These ticket places work on tiny margins so they can't afford to be gracious - and unless you are a good repeat customer they won't care about customer service.
It sucks.
But there's not much that can be done about it.
elanfan said:
How about you find the tickets you want for the day you want on fleabay (or other aftermarket ticket place) and the ticket company pay for the difference. See if they'll bite?
I think I've found tickets advertised for sale for the Saturday by one of their subsidiary companies. Might be a better shout, but I appreciate the sentiment.klingelton said:
These vendors normally keep back several tickets for just such an occasion - kick up a stink.
Just drafted an email to send back to the complaints dept basically saying their alternatives cannot be accepted, and that they should fulfil their original contractual obligations by obtaining tickets from their subsidiary company.elanfan said:
How about you find the tickets you want for the day you want on fleabay (or other aftermarket ticket place) and the ticket company pay for the difference. See if they'll bite?
This. I sold some tickets once and by accident wrote the wrong block in the advert, I had to buy those ticket's from somebody else and cover the difference myself. If that makes sense...e.g. I sold tickets for block B for £100, I actually had block C. Block B were for sale for £200 privately, so I had to expend an extra £100 to buy those ticket's to make sure the purchaser was in the same position they should be from buying my tickets.
In other words, they should buy you those specific ticket's from somewhere else and then re sell the tickets that they refund to you. That way your in the correct position.
Snowboy said:
If there were tickets available when you called you might have a case.
But, if they were already sold out I don't think you would.
I'm pretty sure there's nothing to be done here.
These ticket places work on tiny margins so they can't afford to be gracious - and unless you are a good repeat customer they won't care about customer service.
It sucks.
But there's not much that can be done about it.
Tiny margins? That's got to be a joke.But, if they were already sold out I don't think you would.
I'm pretty sure there's nothing to be done here.
These ticket places work on tiny margins so they can't afford to be gracious - and unless you are a good repeat customer they won't care about customer service.
It sucks.
But there's not much that can be done about it.
They charge a processing fee, fee to use credit card and they also buy large quantities of tickets which they sell well above face value on ticket resell websites which they also own.
Thanks guys, knew a PHer would have some personal insight somewhere 
Unfortunately there'a a few mates going too, including school teachers so the mornings off work aren't really acceptable.
I've no interest in making this more difficult than it has to be for anyone, if there was a more cost effective resolution for the company that would be sound. But they've made a mistake and breached a contract, admitted it, and can hopefully rectify

Unfortunately there'a a few mates going too, including school teachers so the mornings off work aren't really acceptable.
I've no interest in making this more difficult than it has to be for anyone, if there was a more cost effective resolution for the company that would be sound. But they've made a mistake and breached a contract, admitted it, and can hopefully rectify

The very large ticket company (or at least a desk droid) reckons that while they are in breach of contract, it's perfectly reasonable for them to give a refund or an alternative date.
I'm not so sure - do we reckon that's a reasonable attempt at mitigation, or since the tickets were supposed to be for the Saturday, is that a material breach? Should they be sourcing the Saturday night tickets?
Apologies for any internet law bulls
t on my part, it's a long time since my 2 semesters of contract law at uni! 
I'm not so sure - do we reckon that's a reasonable attempt at mitigation, or since the tickets were supposed to be for the Saturday, is that a material breach? Should they be sourcing the Saturday night tickets?
Apologies for any internet law bulls
t on my part, it's a long time since my 2 semesters of contract law at uni! 
simoid said:
The very large ticket company (or at least a desk droid) reckons that while they are in breach of contract, it's perfectly reasonable for them to give a refund or an alternative date.
I'm not so sure - do we reckon that's a reasonable attempt at mitigation, or since the tickets were supposed to be for the Saturday, is that a material breach? Should they be sourcing the Saturday night tickets?
Apologies for any internet law bulls
t on my part, it's a long time since my 2 semesters of contract law at uni! 
Give it up for goodness sake. The ticket company screwed up. They can't meet the original terms of the contract (there are no Saturday tickets left) so have done the next best thing - refund or an alternative. I understand your disappointment but if you think you have a good case then go for it via the courts - but you will have to prove that Saturday evening tickets are available somewhere - can you? Otherwise prove financial loss/damage - ooops, there is none so you could try compo for trauma ........... good luck down that route! Why not just rely on the LDs terms in your contract .............. what, no LDs terms - didn't think so!I'm not so sure - do we reckon that's a reasonable attempt at mitigation, or since the tickets were supposed to be for the Saturday, is that a material breach? Should they be sourcing the Saturday night tickets?
Apologies for any internet law bulls
t on my part, it's a long time since my 2 semesters of contract law at uni! 
Just take the refund (or alternative date), kick the cat and move on.
Garvin said:
Give it up for goodness sake. The ticket company screwed up. They can't meet the original terms of the contract (there are no Saturday tickets left) so have done the next best thing - refund or an alternative. I understand your disappointment but if you think you have a good case then go for it via the courts - but you will have to prove that Saturday evening tickets are available somewhere - can you? Otherwise prove financial loss/damage - ooops, there is none so you could try compo for trauma ........... good luck down that route! Why not just rely on the LDs terms in your contract .............. what, no LDs terms - didn't think so!
Just take the refund (or alternative date), kick the cat and move on.
Fair enough, it's not for me, it's the Missus and her mates, who are raging. So it's for an easy life that I'm exploring this Just take the refund (or alternative date), kick the cat and move on.

There are still plenty of tickets available for sale, not from the original company "Blah Blah", but from company "B" who state on their websit that they are "a Blah Blah company" if that makes sense. (Company B appear to hold back tickets and sell them at a significant markup.)
The original company could easily put SWMBO in the position she should be in, therefore fulfilling their original obligations, but it would cost them some additional money.
I

There are still plenty of tickets available for sale, not from the original company "Blah Blah", but from company "B" who state on their websit that they are "a Blah Blah company" if that makes sense. (Company B appear to hold back tickets and sell them at a significant markup.)
The original company could easily put SWMBO in the position she should be in, therefore fulfilling their original obligations, but it would cost them some additional money.In which case they can meet the terms of the contract so insist they do, in a reasonable timescale, otherwise you will fulfil the original requirement by purchasing the tickets from company B and charging them accordingly with the difference plus expenses. To make this stick you may well have to take it 'all the way' via court etc. Are you prepared to do this? If so, go for it.
simoid said:
Garvin said:
Give it up for goodness sake. The ticket company screwed up. They can't meet the original terms of the contract (there are no Saturday tickets left) so have done the next best thing - refund or an alternative. I understand your disappointment but if you think you have a good case then go for it via the courts - but you will have to prove that Saturday evening tickets are available somewhere - can you? Otherwise prove financial loss/damage - ooops, there is none so you could try compo for trauma ........... good luck down that route! Why not just rely on the LDs terms in your contract .............. what, no LDs terms - didn't think so!
Just take the refund (or alternative date), kick the cat and move on.
Fair enough, it's not for me, it's the Missus and her mates, who are raging. So it's for an easy life that I'm exploring this Just take the refund (or alternative date), kick the cat and move on.

There are still plenty of tickets available for sale, not from the original company "Blah Blah", but from company "B" who state on their websit that they are "a Blah Blah company" if that makes sense. (Company B appear to hold back tickets and sell them at a significant markup.)
The original company could easily put SWMBO in the position she should be in, therefore fulfilling their original obligations, but it would cost them some additional money.
Garvin said:
In which case they can meet the terms of the contract so insist they do, in a reasonable timescale, otherwise you will fulfil the original requirement by purchasing the tickets from company B and charging them accordingly with the difference plus expenses. To make this stick you may well have to take it 'all the way' via court etc. Are you prepared to do this? If so, go for it.
Thanks, I was reckoning it would all come down to the balls to stand the ground.Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



