How to value a domain
How to value a domain
Author
Discussion

Roo

Original Poster:

11,504 posts

238 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
I know this has been a couple of times before but I'm after some advice on the value of a domain.

Having read previous threads on here I've been off to valuate.com to have a look but it doesn't see the domain as having any value.

The domain relates to the model designator for a car, not its actual brand or name, with forums.com at the end.

I assume valuate doesn't see any value in it as it's a new model of car and unless you knew how the model designation works it would, intitally, appear to be worthless.

The evolving model designators for the car are how they've been referred to for over twenty years so those that know, know.

I've been emailed by someone from a dns company asking if I'm interested in selling the domain but have no idea how to value it.

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
Ultimately, what's the potential for someone to make money from it?

Roo

Original Poster:

11,504 posts

238 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
It would be a global forum for a marque specific car.

LooneyTunes

9,528 posts

189 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
In this case, Valuate is probably right.

Forums seem like a bugger to make money from. Lots of work to set up (especially in terms of reaching "critical mass"), lots of competition from incumbents, and difficult to monetise.

Single model forums are always going to be small, and I'm not sure a "global" forum necessarily works due to model differences LHD vs RHD, most traffic being irrelevant to local sponsors, etc.

If you think it's a got value then your best bet would probably be to get it working then sell as a going concern.

BTW, are you sure the email you've got isn't a scam? There are a few domain sales ones around... usually linked to forcing you to pay for an "independent" valuation (independent ha ha ha) at some inflated price.

simonrockman

7,136 posts

286 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
If they are offering sensible money, say more than $3,000, I'd bite their hands off. All the work is in creating traffic, not the URL. no-one types URLs in anymore they search. What has "Amazon" got to do with books? It's not like Books.com (which I see is owned by Barnes & Noble) has any intrinsic value.

There is an advantage in short domain names, particularly for mobile, and I think the x Commerce site, formerly the paypal developer site x.com is very cool.

jammy_basturd

29,778 posts

243 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
I'd say if they're offering anything above £100 I'd bite their hands off - especially if you're not doing anything with the domain at the moment.

I know from experience that a model based car forum can generate several thousand a year in advertising and/or sponsorship - but as has been said, it takes A LOT of effort to set up a forum to that sort of level.

The domain, unfortunately, is generally not worth a great deal.

Roo

Original Poster:

11,504 posts

238 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for your input gents.

The email came from extremedns if anyone has heard of them.

Just in case anyone is interested, and if it makes any difference to its value, the domain relates to the new Mustang.

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
What's the model designation that you've got?! I can't think of anything other than 'new mustang', '2015 mustang' or similar...?

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
Ok, so it's s550forums then.

I'd say that's going to be incredibly hard to monetise personally. I'd like to think I've got a little bit of knowledge about 'stangs and didn't know the new one was going to be a 's550'!

Let's look at Porsche and, say, the 993 model. Google 993 forum and you'll find the only 993 specific forum on the first page of Google is a German site and they're not exactly overrun with traffic...

Ok - maybe that's a fluke - take the previous model, the 964. Again, the best result is one linking to several other more generic forums.

Again, on that first page of Google, there is a dedicated 964 forum...I just saw the tumble weed roll on by.

Admittedly, in the US, they can sell a st load of 'stangs and with the market moving to Europe, they'll sell more however I think for a business to work in this area, it would need to be around 'Mustang' at the very least.

jammy_basturd

29,778 posts

243 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
s550-forum.com is available.

So anyone interested in buying your domain would have to weigh up whether the lack of a hyphen is worth any premium over the $10 the domain above would cost.

Roo

Original Poster:

11,504 posts

238 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
@moose. I would have no idea which model designator was which with a 911. To me they're all just a 911.

The gen4 Mustang, which is pretty much a US only car, has a dedicated forum at SN95forums.com with over 11k members. The gen5 car has a UK forum at s197.co.uk

The gen6 car does have a forum already but it's called mustang6g.com which is hardly catchy.

They've made me a low ball offer so I'll go back with a counter offer and see what they say.

A friend of mine owns another similar domain so I could just team up with him if I want.

robuk

2,512 posts

221 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
simonrockman said:
It's not like Books.com has any intrinsic value.
It would sell for several million quid if that domain came up for sale.

In terms of the OP - it is possible there could be TM issues as well as it doesn't sound a particularly generic term.

Generally speaking generic and/or short domains have value if in decent extension eg. .co.uk / .com however if contains goodwill of others then probably not and could even be a liability.

fridaypassion

11,458 posts

259 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
The old diy.com books.com thing is a bit oldschool now

You could give someone books.com as a birthday present and they still wouldnt be able to compete with amazon

These days some VC funded outfit will just plough money into wobblemonkey.com instead of even trying to source a normal domain. The domain/brand are tied up in ways they weren't 10-15 years ago.

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Roo said:
@moose. I would have no idea which model designator was which with a 911. To me they're all just a 911.

The gen4 Mustang, which is pretty much a US only car, has a dedicated forum at SN95forums.com with over 11k members. The gen5 car has a UK forum at s197.co.uk

The gen6 car does have a forum already but it's called mustang6g.com which is hardly catchy.

They've made me a low ball offer so I'll go back with a counter offer and see what they say.

A friend of mine owns another similar domain so I could just team up with him if I want.
That's exactly the point I'm trying to make! Whereas if you look for 911 forums or Porsche forums, there are loads more.

On the s197 forum, there's only 65k posts or there abouts. The domain was registered in 2007 so it's been around for up to 6 years - that's not many posts and hard to monetize effectively at that level.

Good luck whichever way you choose to go, however, unless you can turn it into a business, I'd wager you'd be lucky to do more than cover your costs when selling the domain at this point.

Roo

Original Poster:

11,504 posts

238 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
SN95 forums has 1.2million posts with over 11,000 members. S197 never had a cohesive global forum.

This is the first ever global Mustang, and Mustangs are always known by their model designator.

He's made an increased offer which I shall think about.

Thanks all for your input.

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
Roo said:
This is the first ever global Mustang, and Mustangs are always known by their model designator.

He's made an increased offer which I shall think about.
Good luck with their increased offer, but Mustangs may be referred to by their model designator by people in the know. Just in the same way 911s are also referred by their respective model designator.