parked car damaged by sign, any advice?
parked car damaged by sign, any advice?
Author
Discussion

jabbalon

Original Poster:

68 posts

198 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
hi folks. have a tricky situation which i am trying to solve without involving insurers, wondered if any of the resident legal eagles or insurance type bods could chip in with any wisdom?

i had the use of a borrowed car while mine was off the road for a fair bit of pre m.o.t. work. the mechanic who was working on my car was good enough to lend me his own mk 1 focus estate to use for a runaround for a week. he's a good guy!

my driveway runs parallel to the main road outside and there is no pavement, just a small concrete strip separating the tarmac from the gravel where i park my car and cars are only a couple of feet from the roads edge when parked. there is also a wall separating my drive from the neighbours.

pulling in the other night i noticed a 'men at work' type sign placed outside my house. the sign was on my driveway and angled so that approaching drivers could see the sign but it wouldnt intrude onto the road. it was just beside the dividing wall so didnt intrude too much. i parked the car as normal, leaving a few feet between the back of the car and the sign.

went out in the morning after serious gale force winds overnight and found the sign resting against the back of the borrowed car. there is a dent in the tailgate which is scraped down to the metal, a rectangular hole punched in the bumper, and various small to serious scratches. didnt get pictures as it was dark, wet and very windy!

the contractor who owns the sign wants me to go through insurers to recover any costs for repair. i dont want to do this as im sure that i will take a hit for it on my next renewal. the guy who owns the car doesnt want to do this as the car is worth very little and fears the car being written off due to the price of new parts / repair work. i basically would like to buy second hand parts and be able to return the car to the same condition it was in when i got it, with the contractor covering any costs. do i have another approach here? contractor chappy blames me for parking my car near the sign (on my drive), and has suggested to other folk im probably making the whole thing up and should pay to fix the car myself. he is a c0ckmuncher. first class.

wont be a major expense for parts but seriously grudge getting shafted by this greasy piece of work. with christmas round the corner and a seriously big m.o.t. bill due i just cant happily shell out for this repair without trying to get the money back.

thanks for any advice! im sure the sensible thing to do is contact insurers but i am wide open to any other ideas. cheers, gavin.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
You could ask him if he'd pay for it to be repaired if you provide him with a couple of quotes. If he doesn't want to and you go through your insurance then you may or may not have a little extra on your premium for a non fault incident, but it won't be much.

andyiley

13,663 posts

183 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
I am no legal eagle, but I have to say, I don't think it has anything to do with your insurance at all, as the car was parked up.

Do you have "legal assistance cover" either at home or with your car insurance?

They would be who I would be getting in touch with it to sort out with the contractors public liability insurance.

Alternatively get all the information/evidence you can together & send it through with a statement to the company head office and insisit that they get it sorted out.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
There is also the issue of negligence which is needed for the contractor to be liable for the repair. I know this has been done before but was he negligent by leaving the sign there or were you negligent for parking there?

andyiley

13,663 posts

183 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
From the information we have before us, I would think the contractor did not take all reasonable steps to ensure the security & therefore effectiveness of his sign.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
I'll leave you all to discuss it. Just a discussion point no more.

redstu

2,287 posts

270 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
andyiley said:
From the information we have before us, I would think the contractor did not take all reasonable steps to ensure the security & therefore effectiveness of his sign.
I'd agree with this pov.
But I'd let a real judge decide in court.
Give the contractor the option to pay for repairs (at reasonable cost) or take it to the small claima court.

DrDeAtH

3,706 posts

263 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
It will just come off of the contractors public liability insurance. That's what he pays it for. Offer a couple of quotes for repair and see how he wants to go about it.

gazza285

11,265 posts

239 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
There is also the issue of negligence which is needed for the contractor to be liable for the repair. I know this has been done before but was he negligent by leaving the sign there or were you negligent for parking there?
Jabbalon negligent for parking on his own drive? The rotter!

Is he also negligent for buying a house where it might get windy?

160

239 posts

176 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
Could you not charge 'rent' for the usage of your drive for the sign that they put up.

Rubin215

4,201 posts

187 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
Is the contractor accepting responsibility for his sign causing the damage, i.e. is he admitting negligence?
If he hasn't directly admitted this, then you are now chasing his insurers and as we all know, when it comes to insurance companies... rolleyes

The biggest issue is whether the contractor took reasonable precautions to secure the sign or not; was it set up correctly, was it on all four legs when he left it, did he add ballast to prevent it blowing over. He only needs to take precautions to guard against what is reasonably foreseeable; gale force winds might not come under this.

I quite often see fold up signs with a sandbag over the rail between the legs to stop it blowing (or being knocked) over, I've never seen one like this on its back.
If he argues that he did this, it might become difficult to prove negligence; his word against yours etc and, as a contractor who is no doubt used to doing this sort of work, his word is more likely to be believed.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Rubin215 said:
He only needs to take precautions to guard against what is reasonably foreseeable; gale force winds might not come under this.
Given the news coverage of the damage caused by the recent storms I think foreseeable is eminently possible.

Rubin215 said:
I quite often see fold up signs with a sandbag over the rail between the legs to stop it blowing (or being knocked) over, I've never seen one like this on its back.
If he argues that he did this, it might become difficult to prove negligence; his word against yours etc and, as a contractor who is no doubt used to doing this sort of work, his word is more likely to be believed.
That's the big question. Did he actually take sufficient and reasonable precautions under the circumstances? The very fact of the sign being blown around suggests otherwise.

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Oh good, it's this thread again:

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

First time round, it was a flying gazebo and a Porsche Cayenne.

I know that they say that history repeats itself, first as tragedy, then as farce, but I think this might be the other way around.

In that case, which of course might be distinguished on its facts, the claimant was ultimately successful.

With that, I'm out of this thread.

Rubin215

4,201 posts

187 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
Rubin215 said:
He only needs to take precautions to guard against what is reasonably foreseeable; gale force winds might not come under this.
Given the news coverage of the damage caused by the recent storms I think foreseeable is eminently possible.
News coverage, of course, being retrospective.

The weather forcast leading up to the recent storm only upgraded the severity of its warnings 24 hours prior to the event; could it be argued that the contractor was unaware of the updated forcast severity so only took precautions relative to what would reasonably be expected?
Devils advocate...