If an engine broke 50miles after a rebuild...
If an engine broke 50miles after a rebuild...
Author
Discussion

sato

Original Poster:

591 posts

242 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
If you had an engine rebuilt at a marque specialist, for a not inconsiderable sum, agreeing to any additional precautions that they suggested and 50 miles later something broke, would you ever be liable to pay to fix the "something"?

Or to put it another way, does the original bill only give you protection for the bits worked on, not other components of the engine?

Butter Face

35,170 posts

191 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Was the 'something' that broke anything to do with the rebuild?

If it's something that hasn't been touched/replaced then why would you expect it replaced?

If it's a part that was worked on or replaced then broke then it should be replaced by those who did the rebuild.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Butter Face said:
Was the 'something' that broke anything to do with the rebuild?

If it's something that hasn't been touched/replaced then why would you expect it replaced?

If it's a part that was worked on or replaced then broke then it should be replaced by those who did the rebuild.
I imagine the answer is in the OP's last paragraph: "Or to put it another way, does the original bill only give you protection for the bits worked on, not other components of the engine?" Else, why ask that question?

Streaky

Butter Face

35,170 posts

191 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
It still doesn't read very clearly, he hasn't said for sure that it is or isn't a part that was worked on or replaced.

Unless you can understand it better than I can?

davemac250

4,499 posts

236 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Do you also own my TVR?


sato

Original Poster:

591 posts

242 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Butter Face said:
It still doesn't read very clearly, he hasn't said for sure that it is or isn't a part that was worked on or replaced.

Unless you can understand it better than I can?
I dont know what has broken yet.




sato

Original Poster:

591 posts

242 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
davemac250 said:
Do you also own my TVR?
I can only dream of the reliability of a TVR at the moment.

sato

Original Poster:

591 posts

242 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Butter Face said:
If it's something that hasn't been touched/replaced then why would you expect it replaced?

.
I take your point, but at the same time I would expect to have an engine that works at the end of it.
I would have hoped that they would have enough experience of rebuilding engines to inspect/replace anything that was likely to go while it was apart.

mph1977

12,467 posts

199 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Butter Face said:
Was the 'something' that broke anything to do with the rebuild?

If it's something that hasn't been touched/replaced then why would you expect it replaced?

If it's a part that was worked on or replaced then broke then it should be replaced by those who did the rebuild.
that's the 'reasonableness' type issue that i suepct it will all revolve around ..

Mill Wheel

6,149 posts

227 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
You say you were having the engine "rebuilt" rather than some specific fault/item being fixed.
If that were correct, I would expect the whole engine to be subject to scrutiny during that process... so now we come down to "what broke" and could its failure have been foreseen by the specialists during their work. You did say they were specialists, so I'd half expect them to be more aware than any other garage.

I'm guessing there will soon be a cry for "more information..." once you have it.

Butter Face

35,170 posts

191 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
sato said:
Butter Face said:
If it's something that hasn't been touched/replaced then why would you expect it replaced?

.
I take your point, but at the same time I would expect to have an engine that works at the end of it.
I would have hoped that they would have enough experience of rebuilding engines to inspect/replace anything that was likely to go while it was apart.
I suppose that's why you need to know what's broken, is the 'something' inside the engine?

As said, if it's something completely unconnected like your rear brake caliper has seized on then you obviously have no recourse.

I'd be interested to know what has broken and how much of a 'rebuild' has taken place?

BertBert

21,354 posts

242 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
You'd expect that a specialist would stand behind a rebuild for the whole engine generically.

However, if something happened externally like an alternator. Then I'd probably expect you to stand the cost of that, unless you could argue it was done as part of a fixed price type deal.

What deal did you do with the engine builder?

Bert

andyiley

13,661 posts

183 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
The upshot of all of the above is the definition of reasonable.

To help with this we need to know what you actually asked for, and what has happenned since in considerably more detail to be able to assist more.

DrDeAtH

3,706 posts

263 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
not enough facts.
too much vagueness.

sato

Original Poster:

591 posts

242 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
DrDeAtH said:
not enough facts.
too much vagueness.
It's just happened, hence the vagueness.
I dont know what is broken, but Im not very happy at the potential of another bill.

Jasandjules

72,700 posts

260 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
You need to know:

1. What the garage did/changed/adjusted/replaced
2. What part went wrong


littleredrooster

6,417 posts

227 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Depends on the original brief to the rebuilder.

If the instruction was - for example - "lift the heads and recut the valve seats" and the no. 3 big-end failed shortly after, then it may be very difficult to hold the rebuilder liable for the failure.

On the other hand, if the dialogue was along the lines of "the engine's goosed, please rebuild it", then one would imagine that a much more comprehensive job was called for.

Having been on the receiving end of a scenario like the first example, I would be interested to know what instructions were given.

HustleRussell

26,715 posts

191 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
We're told that the 'engine broke' and that engine had been 'rebuilt' 50 miles previous. The word 'rebuilt' is thrown around quite a lot. We need to know the extent of the work carried out and the mode of failure of the engine (even symptoms will help). We also need to know how the engine was treated for those 50 miles. Were the 'rebuilders' recommendations adhered to?

andygo

7,422 posts

286 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Try racing FF1600. Spend £2500 on a rebuild. They fit wrong distributer. Engine misfires like a pig when hot. Waste £2000 on race meeting whilst trying to sort said misfire.

Query engine builder who says,"oh, it was all right on the dyno".
Present him with distributer that has Pinto (Ford 2.o OHC) internals.

"Oh, yeah, thats wrong isn't it?"

Any compo, even just for the wasted petrol?

Haha, no chance.



Rubin215

4,201 posts

187 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Years ago a friend had a VW aircooled engine rebuilt by a performance specialist. It cost him a lot of money but included many new parts; crankshaft, pistons, cylinders, heads, cams, pushrods etc etc.
After the rebuild however, he fitted his own choice of distributor, carbs and manifolds and, crucially, fuel pump.

The fuel pump went wrong dumping fuel down into the cranckase to mix with the oil.

Very quickly, things went very, very wrong and he was left with a partially siezed engine

Despite the fuel pump being nothing to do with the engine builder, he still took the engine back and rebuilt it a second time, charging only for the parts needed and asking for just a case of beer for his time.
His rationale, apparently, was that he had already been paid once by the customer who had never had value for the money paid; how could the customer ever recommend that friends use his workshop if the customer didn't know how good his engine work was.

I just wish I could remember the name of the workshop!