2004 S4 audi advice?
Author
Discussion

gixermark

Original Poster:

752 posts

218 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Hi guys,

Saw a mint S4 convertible 68k full history, it's the 4.2 V8 motor.

Doesn't seem to be any horror stories, slightly concerned with the chain at the bulk head... Which would be an engine out job to replace it or guides/adjusters etc... But I guess maybe more on the probability stakes is IF? There are accessories driven off it? Like power steering/water etc etc? I appreciate they will likely munch their way through brakes.. Drink fuel, maybe need coil packs etc... But more concerned about big bills due to huge labour (I assume) of an engine in/out..

Doesn't look like there is a lot of room.. So assume its a proper nightmare?

The actual cars seem to be at a £ level that is likely to be fairly solid, so not worried about depreciation too much! and appreciate in real world terms will be 15-20 mpg

On a slightly different topic, do insurance companies lump in cheap cars on the back of a main policy? I'd probably keep the load lugging galaxy I have for towing duties for race car... Firing bikes/dog etc into..

Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
Engine out and mostly apart to do the chains, it's a very big job. Regular oil changes key to avoiding it. If the car you're looking at has been stretched to the absolute limits of 'longlife' servicing each time tread very carefully.

Audi are quite clear about what use is and is not suitable for longlife and a lot of owners choose to ignore this.

Cold start the engine (i.e. not run for several hours) and listen for the rattle/clatter. 1-2 second is normal for the engine to pressurise but if it's longer than this or overly loud/harsh walk away.

bazzabear

113 posts

288 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
In terms of coil packs, they're not listed as consumables in the service schedule.

There was a recall on them called 28E9, so might be worth checking that's been done. But it was a 'product enhancement' so whether it's considered vital I don't know.

Edited by bazzabear on Monday 9th December 08:59

gixermark

Original Poster:

752 posts

218 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
thanks guys... yes - seems to have spent most of its life with dealer history... and last two at audi independents... just had the clutch/fly wheel replaced.

if i was to have it - the car would have to endure some cold stop starts (school run) through the week, and likely to get decent run(s) at the wk end... i don't suppose cold stop starts are the best for any engine - but this one should be no better/worse than anything else ?

what is the milage for normal vs long life servicing ? i'm guessing it should have service history every two years (minimum) its an '04 with 68K on it currently..

Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
Longlife servicing is for persons doing more than 20k miles per annum with nothing but long, smooth journeys.

Otherwise it should have oil every 12 months or 10k. If you're planning on driving it very hard perhaps even more often. Quite a few owners use a slightly heavier oil that standard also (5w40 instead of 5w30).

Standard plug intervals are optimistic too, they're normally pretty mucky by 40k.

bazzabear

113 posts

288 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
Dr G said:
Longlife servicing is for persons doing more than 20k miles per annum with nothing but long, smooth journeys.
From what I read in the service book.

The stipulation for longlife servicing was largely that you had to use the specified oil. While the idea for it was the types of journey you suggest, what it seemed to describe was that the car itself would judge (from your use of it) when the next service would be due.

So, it would be two years if the long journeys were the norm. I guess if there was loads of in-town driving, it would recognise that and pull it in sooner?

So a car which used Longlife service but didn't always do long journeys would be OK, if the owner took notice of the car requesting more frequent services? (And used the right oil.)

Does that sound right? Or would you maintain that if the car didn't have that mileage, and was on Longlife, you'd steer clear?

gixermark

Original Poster:

752 posts

218 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
its had 6 services (from what i gather) maybe 7 (if the recent one was not included in the overview) so at 9 years old.. and 68K covered.. sounds reasonable at a service every 18 months.. or say 8k miles (very approx and assuming steady usage which is no doubt not accurate)


kippax

2,792 posts

280 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
Fantastic cars traded my Boxster S in for one earlier this year & haven't regretted it for a minute.

The milltek exhaust was a must & it now sounds as good as it goes.

gixermark

Original Poster:

752 posts

218 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
That's interesting.. The boxster handles well... So the S4 must be pretty good despite its weight and size...

Need to get wifey into a practical tow barge to pull this off!

kippax

2,792 posts

280 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Handles far better than I expected not as nimble as the Boxster but faster & more practical.

Best car I've owned bar the Tuscan (list includes M3 & M5, Chimaera, Boxster s plus lots of fast fords)

Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
S4s are bloody good cars and awesome value for money these days smile

gixermark

Original Poster:

752 posts

218 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Yep, I need to do a bit more research on real value... Prices advertised vary quite a bit..

It's tough to know... I've of those cars that I'd rather pay a grand or two more to get a good un.. As that grand or two could easily be eaten up (and more) to fix bits and pieces.

I'm also trying to get a clear picture on insurance... To own this I'd need to either keep my family bus/barge and hence need a 2nd policy (then no claims bonus on it) or get wifey into a bigger car...

Never straightforward :-)

kippax

2,792 posts

280 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Where in uk are you? If your in North West you can give mine a spin it'll convince you

gixermark

Original Poster:

752 posts

218 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
That's very kind kippax! I am in n Ireland.... So not convenient, but very much appreciate the offer.

I want to do the man maths.... And see what the dealer is talking realistically for a cash straight sale price.. I've done some research of the market prices tonight... This one is at the top end (for '04) but it has 68k miles, just had full service inc clutch and fly wheel... So is attractive on paper if the price was right... It's a 2 owner ( 3 if you inc audi - must have been a demo) with good service history (from what I gather on phone)


Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Sounds like you've answered your own questions there; if I had one as good as you describe I wouldn't budge on price.

Plenty of cheapos with 7 owners, patchy history, 'ok' condition to choose from. Genuinely clean cars that are well maintained are much harder to find.

matts4

2,117 posts

222 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
I think people are really starting to see the value these cars present. Good, well kept cars are worth the premium.
I've had 2 people ask to buy mine this week.
One was a technician at a local VW dealer who happened to see it getting valeted at a detailers when it was there. (he even did an HPI check on it to see what the history of the car was). He told the guy who owns the detailling company that he should let me know he'd be keen to buy it should I ever look to sell it.
Second was a plumber who I've used for the last 4 years. He came round to sort out a leak for me and told me he wants to buy it when I sell it too.

Good ones are out there, but really good ones are hard to find as owners will hang onto them.

Having said that, if my MX5 gets sold in the next 3 or 4 months, then I'll be looking to potentially move mine on first half of next year to fund a B8 S4 or Sportback S3.


gixermark

Original Poster:

752 posts

218 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
yep... i think they are probably about the level in money terms that will pretty much be flat for a good while, could dip 1-2K, but could also rise 1-2K over a 2-3 year period.... after that who knows.

you coudl be lucky and have to spend relatively little on one... or sink quite a few grand into one ! at the end of the day they are a top end car with a pretty rare and large motor


Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
90,000 mile 2004 car in for an annual service this morning; only things it was picked up one were very minor wear to some suspension rubbers and one of the rads just starting to show signs of weeping. I've known the owners for a few years and they've not had any dramas with it at all.

They're strong cars if you take care of them smile

gixermark

Original Poster:

752 posts

218 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
for those that have driven both.......... how would you compare the auto (tip) with the manual ?

i had an '06 A6 avant 3.0tdi quattro auto ('06) in the past would it be the same gearbox ? it was absolutely fine with the oil burner engine... i'm not sure it its sharpened up when installed with the V8 petrol ?

Fort Jefferson

8,237 posts

253 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
gixermark said:
Need to get wifey into a practical tow barge to pull this off!
They don't do a towbar for the S4.