Low run injection mouldings ??
Low run injection mouldings ??
Author
Discussion

unclegrouch

Original Poster:

388 posts

220 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
Hi,

does anybody here do this or buy moulded parts ? I'm not sure if we can order / use enough to make it a viable option or not.

One of our suppliers seems to have a lot of difficulty supplying even small amounts of some components & I am wondering if it's worth buying them in ourselves ?

The components are all less than matchbox size & we could order 1000 - 5000 at a time.

Is the "mould" or "tooling" likely to make it uneconomic ?

As a guide, we pay between 10p & 30p per unit (when we can get them !)

I know I can speak to a moulding company directly, but don't want to waste their time quoting if it's dead on it's feet as an idea - usually somebody on PH has experience & can offer ideas ;-)











NightDriver

1,082 posts

257 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
How complex is the part? Simple open shut tool or does it need lots of movements?

To be honest you will be better of talking to a supplier straight off because even if hard tooling is too expensive you could get very good value prototype tooling which could make a few thousand. Can recommend Formaplex as a good company to have a chat with.

rustandoil

89 posts

203 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
Who owns the existing tooling?

rossmc88

490 posts

191 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
These guys are good

http://www.alumould.co.uk/

unclegrouch

Original Poster:

388 posts

220 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
NightDriver said:
How complex is the part? Simple open shut tool or does it need lots of movements?
Many thanks for the quick reply...

The part I need is fairly simple & I would guess the mould could release it in one movement (if I'm grasping the idea correctly). I guess it will make sense to speak to somebody, at worst it will only waste a few mins of their time & I will get the answers I need.

Pic attached of something similar (I want to modify the design), the only bit you can't see is a tapered section that is hiding behind the window seal.


unclegrouch

Original Poster:

388 posts

220 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
rustandoil said:
Who owns the existing tooling?
Our existing supplier owns the tooling and machines. BUT, they are extremely unreliable and i think the item would work better with a re-desing, hence the reason for wanting to have them moulded myself.

I am guessing dozens of small guys like us are having the same issues, so if we could do this, i could have a market for it. There are a few other components, mostly smaller than these, which I can source elsewhere.

unclegrouch

Original Poster:

388 posts

220 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
rossmc88 said:
These guys are good

http://www.alumould.co.uk/
much appreciated Sir ;-)

Richjam

318 posts

219 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
Try fentonprecision.co.uk we could do you alluminium tool for low volumes.

DSLiverpool

16,577 posts

233 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
You can get a 50 tonner for buttons and get trained how to set it or bring in a setter per run
- not a huge leap and you are in charge

unclegrouch

Original Poster:

388 posts

220 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
richjam: any idea of the cost to make a low run tool ?

DS - yeah, seen some of the machines on ebay for not a lot of money, I have the room and the time, but it's another learning curve & that might be a step too far (but it does interest me !)

DSLiverpool

16,577 posts

233 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
unclegrouch said:
richjam: any idea of the cost to make a low run tool ?

DS - yeah, seen some of the machines on ebay for not a lot of money, I have the room and the time, but it's another learning curve & that might be a step too far (but it does interest me !)
Look for a local setter or advertise as loads are redundant you may need to buy the machine first as not all setters can set all machines. I was in moulding for years and loved it we used to take a 50 tonne to the nec and made paperclips actually on our stand

Richjam

318 posts

219 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
unclegrouch said:
richjam: any idea of the cost to make a low run tool ?

DS - yeah, seen some of the machines on ebay for not a lot of money, I have the room and the time, but it's another learning curve & that might be a step too far (but it does interest me !)
We would need to quote you. Do you have any data of your part? Low run ally tools typically are around £3000 to £5000 but we can do deals by adding costing to mouldings to keep the tool price lower. Really need to see the product properly to give you a proper price

Have dropped you an email with some contact details if your interested.

Edited by Richjam on Monday 9th December 19:40

unclegrouch

Original Poster:

388 posts

220 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for that Richjam,

answers my questions perfectly. I had no idea what a tool would cost to make for a simple moulding, but the maths just doesn't work out.

I would need to have thousands done at pennies to just break even on the tooling.

I had no idea it would cost so much to make a tool for the moulding, hence asking the question here & not going direct to a company & looking a complete fool lol

Another brilliant idea for world domination goes to the wall laugh

Richjam

318 posts

219 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
Keep us in mind if you have any other ideas there's not much we can't do.

Remster500

206 posts

248 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
We are a small Injection Moulder primarily in the Medical market but use to small qty runs and low cost tooling. Based on your pic. and limited info, I would have thought we could have a tool running for £2500 and component price of 25p.

Happy to discuss further if you see potential in this product or others. We can always do a 1+1 tool with x2 different components from the same tool. Would need to be same raw material and similar in size.

Richjam, Where are you based in the Midlands? We are North Leics./South Notts. border.

unclegrouch

Original Poster:

388 posts

220 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies ;-)

£2500 / 25p

your input is much appreciated but the cost of the tooling just doesn't make it viable at our level. We can buy that component for 30p in packs of 100, but I had an idea to modify it to improve the system - the problem is, we would never sell enough to recover the tooling cost. The supplier is pretty erratic with supplies, but we can hold enough stock to overcome that problem.

I (wrongly) assumed that making the tool would be a simple job on a cnc machine, but obviously there is a lot more to it that I could possibly have imagined - apologies for being a dummy & showing my lack of understanding.

smash

Richjam

318 posts

219 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
Remster500 said:
We are a small Injection Moulder primarily in the Medical market but use to small qty runs and low cost tooling. Based on your pic. and limited info, I would have thought we could have a tool running for £2500 and component price of 25p.

Happy to discuss further if you see potential in this product or others. We can always do a 1+1 tool with x2 different components from the same tool. Would need to be same raw material and similar in size.

Richjam, Where are you based in the Midlands? We are North Leics./South Notts. border.
We are based in North Northamptonshire Kettering area but I live in Rutland so cant be that far way from you?

951TSE

600 posts

188 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
unclegrouch said:
Thanks for all the replies ;-)

£2500 / 25p

your input is much appreciated but the cost of the tooling just doesn't make it viable at our level. We can buy that component for 30p in packs of 100, but I had an idea to modify it to improve the system - the problem is, we would never sell enough to recover the tooling cost. The supplier is pretty erratic with supplies, but we can hold enough stock to overcome that problem.

I (wrongly) assumed that making the tool would be a simple job on a cnc machine, but obviously there is a lot more to it that I could possibly have imagined - apologies for being a dummy & showing my lack of understanding.

smash
Hi, two thoughts, I run a company that casts items in Polyurethane resin, using silicone moulds. The costs run into the tens of pounds rather than the thousands, now I admit that my usual market is low volume and I've never cast so many components at the same time but if you're willing to send me some examples that I can try to make replicas of then please PM me (I hope the PH mail system works).

Other thought would be for you to investigate the 3D printing market as I'm sure someone with a high end printer could do the job for you at less cost than the injection moulding tooling. Alas I don't have one or access to one but I'm sure a new thread on PH would find someone able to help you out.

I would point out though that neither of these suggestions will be able to make 100 items for 30p as you quote above.

unclegrouch

Original Poster:

388 posts

220 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
951TSE said:
Hi, two thoughts, I run a company that casts items in Polyurethane resin, using silicone moulds. The costs run into the tens of pounds rather than the thousands, now I admit that my usual market is low volume and I've never cast so many components at the same time but if you're willing to send me some examples that I can try to make replicas of then please PM me (I hope the PH mail system works).
Interesting !! As with injection moulding / machining, i have no idea about resin moulding but it had crossed my mind & I saw a couple of demos on youtube.

The bracket shown above holds a small aluminium rail but there is little force / pressure on it, so I guess strength isn't an issue.

Cheap mould & higher unit cost would be an option (each unit we manufacture uses 4 of these, so obviously a cost of £1.20 per unit sold at present).

Production would be quicker with a re-design of the bracket, but of course the cost of each brackets is relevant as it is one of many components in the finished unit.

I will pm you & sending some samples is no problem, would be interested to see the results / costs per unit ;-)


Edited by unclegrouch on Wednesday 11th December 08:16