VW/Audi's automatic transmissions - why so many choices?
VW/Audi's automatic transmissions - why so many choices?
Author
Discussion

AudiWurst

Original Poster:

4,837 posts

258 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
What is VW/Audi up to with its automatic gearboxes?

I have an A4 with the Multitronic (CVT) box, and it works well for me.

But Audi also has the S-tronic (DSG) in its Quattro cars, and apparently uses the new ZF 8-speed gearbox in North American cars.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZF_8HP_transmission#A...

I understand that S-tronic is better suited to 4WD than Multitronic, but why is there the third option of the ZF 8-speed box for the Yanks? It's not like they don't trust CVTs - plenty of mass market Jap saloons are already using them over there.

I also don't get why the Multitronic box isn't offered on VW/Seat/Skoda cars. CVT is supposedly better for economy and CO2 emissions figures, right?

And finally, if the Yanks get the new ZF box, why don't we get it in Europe? It's supposedly an excellent transmission - is this just a cost thing?

Not intending to create another Multitronic-bashing thread (we've had enough of those already). Just trying to understand what VW/Audi is up to, and what their future plans are.

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
DSG/S-Tronic is used in both in-line and transverse engine cars as well as FWD/4WD applications. The availability of this box is becoming wider every year.

In line engine high torque applications use the ZF 8 speed. 'We' do get this box in Europe.

In line engine FWD autos use multitronic/CVT.

There are power train differences in different market to suit cost/use/emissions/packaging and most manufacturers do this to some degree.

AJB

856 posts

246 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
AudiWurst said:
What is VW/Audi up to with its automatic gearboxes?

I have an A4 with the Multitronic (CVT) box, and it works well for me.

But Audi also has the S-tronic (DSG) in its Quattro cars
The Multitronic CVT doesn't have a centre diff or output for a prop-shaft, so can't be used in the quattro cars.

AudiWurst said:
I also don't get why the Multitronic box isn't offered on VW/Seat/Skoda cars. CVT is supposedly better for economy and CO2 emissions figures, right?
The Multitronic box is designed for a longitudinal (front-back) engine position, and front wheel drive. It is therefore used in, for example, Audi A4, A5, A6. Pretty much all of the VW, Seat and Skoda cars are transverse engine, and so share gearboxes with Audi A1 and A3 instead.

AudiWurst said:
And finally, if the Yanks get the new ZF box, why don't we get it in Europe? It's supposedly an excellent transmission - is this just a cost thing?
I don't know if it's cost, driver preference (Yanks like slush-boxes, Europe like a directly-connected feel), or EU CO2 figures. But the really high torque engines (eg Bi-Turbo A6) which would be too much for the S-Tronic do get the ZF box in Europe.

AudiWurst

Original Poster:

4,837 posts

258 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the explanations. All seems logical.

Still can't help thinking it would be easier for them to follow BMW's example, and simply offer the ZF 8 speeder in everything, big or small, 2WD or 4WD, from the 118d all the way up to the big-dog 760Li. But what do I know.

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Marketing comes into it as well; Audi pioneered the double clutch box and very much sing its praises.

DocArbathnot

29,117 posts

214 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
AudiWurst said:
Thanks for the explanations. All seems logical.

Still can't help thinking it would be easier for them to follow BMW's example, and simply offer the ZF 8 speeder in everything, big or small, 2WD or 4WD, from the 118d all the way up to the big-dog 760Li. But what do I know.
Bare in mind all BMW engines are longitudal with no |FWD cars.

RGambo

888 posts

200 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
I like my dsg box in my a6 Quattro , it's the only thing that disappoints about my new biturbo is loosing the double clutch for a slush box. But everybody continually sings the prases of the zf 8 speed, so hopefully It'll be ok.