Purchase law, help needed.
Discussion
To the collective, a question:
If someone has a car for sale and they tell you the price they are happy to accept, if you ring them and they agree to give you first refusal on the car, are they then allowed to refuse you the car even though you have offered the agreed asking price on the basis they might want to sell it to someone else??? Is this not discrimination and have we not entered into a verbal contract on part of the first refusal basis??
Any advice gladly received.
If someone has a car for sale and they tell you the price they are happy to accept, if you ring them and they agree to give you first refusal on the car, are they then allowed to refuse you the car even though you have offered the agreed asking price on the basis they might want to sell it to someone else??? Is this not discrimination and have we not entered into a verbal contract on part of the first refusal basis??
Any advice gladly received.
For a contract to be formed in law, some consideration must be given (I.E you need to have given something to the seller for a contract to have occured, eg a deposit)
I can't how it can be discrimination ? That is a big jump.
Ulitimately they can sell the item to whomever they choose, just because you had a verbal agreement means nothing in law.
Consider if you had agreed to buy the car, but paid no money or deposit, but another buyer comes along and offers more, or the seller decides not to sell the car (for whatever reason)
Why should they then be forced to sell, would make no sense.
clearly there is more to this, why would you feel discriminated against ?
I can't how it can be discrimination ? That is a big jump.
Ulitimately they can sell the item to whomever they choose, just because you had a verbal agreement means nothing in law.
Consider if you had agreed to buy the car, but paid no money or deposit, but another buyer comes along and offers more, or the seller decides not to sell the car (for whatever reason)
Why should they then be forced to sell, would make no sense.
clearly there is more to this, why would you feel discriminated against ?
Darren156 said:
Think of it the other way round. If you lost your job and your home would you still be expected to buy it?
No relevance, the car will be sold the asking price and payment method met, can the seller refuse and sell to someone else after agreeing the first refusal??, this is the important part. Discrimination is only unlawful if it is based on one of a number of characteristics specified by statute, and occurs in certain specified contexts.
When people refer to verbal contracts they probably mean oral contracts, as a written contract is a verbal contract (it uses words, and "verbal" is derived from the Latin for word).
An oral contract is valid, provided that it can be proven if disputed, save in some contexts where writing is required (sale of a car not being one of them).
A promise to pay is good consideration.
The OP needs to explain the transaction in more detail in order to be advised whether or not he made a binding contract.
When people refer to verbal contracts they probably mean oral contracts, as a written contract is a verbal contract (it uses words, and "verbal" is derived from the Latin for word).
An oral contract is valid, provided that it can be proven if disputed, save in some contexts where writing is required (sale of a car not being one of them).
A promise to pay is good consideration.
The OP needs to explain the transaction in more detail in order to be advised whether or not he made a binding contract.
wessexrfc said:
To the collective, a question:
If someone has a car for sale and they tell you the price they are happy to accept, if you ring them and they agree to give you first refusal on the car, are they then allowed to refuse you the car even though you have offered the agreed asking price on the basis they might want to sell it to someone else??? Is this not discrimination and have we not entered into a verbal contract on part of the first refusal basis??
Any advice gladly received.
When you say they have agreed to give you first refusal, what do you mean by this?If someone has a car for sale and they tell you the price they are happy to accept, if you ring them and they agree to give you first refusal on the car, are they then allowed to refuse you the car even though you have offered the agreed asking price on the basis they might want to sell it to someone else??? Is this not discrimination and have we not entered into a verbal contract on part of the first refusal basis??
Any advice gladly received.
From that I'd say you've not agreed to purchase the car at all as yet.
When you offered the full asking price, what did he say?
It is possible, and in some commercial contexts not unusual, for two parties to make what is sometimes called a lock out agreement, whereby party A is given an exclusive right to negotiate something with party B for a certain period of time, during which B will not deal with anyone else, but it is not clear what the OP means by "first refusal", or whether he did in fact commit to pay the price that the seller wanted.
Anyway, few cars are unique, so why not find another car rather than try to legalise something?
Anyway, few cars are unique, so why not find another car rather than try to legalise something?
Ok, to try to give some more info. A trader sees a car advertised, rings the seller and asks the purchase price on behalf of a customer, the seller then gives the trader the price they would be happy to accept. The trader then asks if he can "put his name to the car" the seller agrees and tells him he can have first refusal. When the trader gets to view the car he tells them he is happy to pay the price asked. The buyer is then told that the seller has someone else coming to look at the car. Question is can they sue for loss of profit they could've made on the car??
This is for a third party.
This is for a third party.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



t, time to move on would be my response.